Expensive habitat projects to aid salmon aren’t working

The number of returning salmon does not appear to be increasing. The reconstructed habitat and the implemented protection appear to be having very little success.

Several species of fish including chinook salmon have been declared as endangered and given limited protection. Huge sums of money have been allocated in attempt to increase the populations of these species. Not a single salmon has been found in one completed multi-million dollar salmon habitat projects near Snohomish. Justification of these failed fish habitat projects are now referred to as bug habitat enhancement (and we all know that fish need bugs).

As flood events erode, block or silt-in productive fish waterways, it is considered as a natural event of nature. Efforts to restore, stop or prevent erosion, or remove debris to enhance fish passage is discouraged and frequently prohibited by regulatory agencies. The only concern the state has is that at least one pair of spawning salmon gain access and maintain it as a viable waterway. The prevented return of additional salmon and the majority loss of the hatched salmon fry population are of no concern because that is nature’s way.

The crises will continue as long as the fish population remains low. This will authorize spending absurd amounts of money, removing infrastructures, taking property rights, and imposing additional regulations. This situation will prevail until fish populations increase, but there is little incentive to eliminate the crisis.

If the fish populations increase substantially, the crisis will subside or cease, and the money for bug and fish habitat restoration will no longer be available. This may account for the low salmon numbers that are allowed to return to spawn each year.

Eighty percent of lost spawning habitat is attributed to culverts that prohibit or restrict fish passage. The courts have mandated that Washington state repair, replace or make them accessible for fish passage. Regulatory laws that are meant to protect the environment frequently create long and expensive delays in providing the fish access. The state estimates that it will take forty years to make the improvements. There will be no sense of urgency as long as the money keeps flowing.

Dan Bartelheimer

Snohomish County Farm Bureau

Snohomish

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Tuesday, Dec. 10

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

A burned out truck in Malden, Wash., Wednesday, Sept. 9, 2020, two days after a fast moving wildfire swept through the area. Nearly all of the homes and municipal buildings - including the post office and fire department - in the small town of Malden were burned to the ground. (Rajah Bose/The New York Times)
Trump: State officials planning for ‘chaos’ of second Trump term

Along with potential court challenges, the state treasurer wants to make sure federal funding isn’t held up.

Comment: Politicians and public need crash course in economics

A better understanding of inflation, global trade and families’ needs could make all the difference.

Friedman: Five quick takes on the regime change in Syria

All thoughts that the U.S. should not be involved ignore the opportunity and peril of the situation.

Stephens: Syrians also have Israel to thank for liberation

Israel’s pursuit of Iran-backed terrorists helped to weaken and isolate al-Assad from his supporters.

Comment: Lame-duck Congress can still save medication abortion

Republicans have vowed to use the Comstock Act against the pills. Congress should repeal the archaic law.

Green investments aren’t having a good year, but their focus on the bottom line still makes good financial sense.

By Mark Gongloff / Bloomberg Opinion As a concept, environmentally responsible investing… Continue reading

toon
Editorial cartoons for Monday, Dec. 9

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Comment: If you want to be a grandparent, make parenting easier

The birth rate is dropping because it’s difficult to see support for young families.

Collins: A second-rate crime warrants second-rate pardon

Biden’s pardon of his son was ill-advised, but Trump has already had some doozies of his own.

Comment: U.S. turns back on climate leadership as crisis deepens

With a disappointing climate summit, the only hope for leadership may be China’s recognition of its duty.

Comment: HPV vaccine saving lives; RFK Jr. should see that

Studies show its effectiveness in preventing infections and cancer. Discouraging its use endangers lives.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.