Eyman measure overreaches

As it applies to state government, Tim Eyman’s Initiative 1033 is an understandable response to a 31 percent surge in spending during the last economic boom. That binge was unsustainable, and it forced deeper, more painful budget cuts last year than should have been necessary.

Like most initiatives, though, I-1033 is a blunt instrument that overreaches, creating likely consequences that would actually discourage prudent financial stewardship and positive economic development, especially at the local level. We recommend voting no.

I-1033 would limit annual revenue increases in state, county and city government general funds to a formula that combines inflation and population growth. School districts, fire districts, water districts and the like are exempt. Any revenue increases above the formula would have to be used to lower property taxes across the board the following year. Eyman says he’s giving government a long-term incentive to cut taxes proactively.

That sounds reasonable until you consider the up-and-down cycle of the economy and its effect on tax revenues. The current downturn has drastically reduced sales-tax and business-tax revenues, forcing some local governments to cut important services and lay off staff. I-1033 would use 2009 as its budget baseline, keeping those services from being fully restored as the economy rebounds.

It would also create disincentives for local governments to act wisely. Some of the best job-creating commercial developments are the product of partnerships between business and local governments — with private interests investing in plant and equipment and government providing some infrastructure improvements and basic services like police and fire protection. The local government’s investment is repaid in tax revenue produced by new economic activity, which also benefits parks, road maintenance, and other local services.

Under I-1033, much or most of that new revenue would instead go to lower property taxes. Governments wouldn’t be able to afford entering into such partnerships, so they wouldn’t materialize. That helps explain why local chambers of commerce, whose members would receive much of the measure’s property-tax relief, oppose I-1033.

I-1033’s inflation-plus-population cap doesn’t reflect the true cost of government, which includes expenses that outpace inflation rates, such as health care and construction costs. Plus, local governments already are under strict limits regarding tax increases.

Eyman wants to provide a counterbalance to what he considers government’s insatiable appetite for taxing and spending. With state government, recent history shows he has a point.

But cities and counties aren’t in the same boat. Voters elect local representatives to handle their money prudently and provide the services they need and want. To do so, in good times and bad, those officials need flexibility that I-1033 would take away.

Talk to us

More in Opinion

RGB version
Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, Dec. 6

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

The Everett City Council approved a $375,000 settlement Wednesday with a former firefighter who alleged racist harassment went unaddressed in the department.
Editorial: Fosse shouldn’t have to choose between elected roles

The Everett City Council can bar its members from other offices, but should not do so retroactively.

Comment: Ranked-choice voting the big winnter on election day

More cities and counties — and two states — are using RCV and instilling more confidence among voters.

Comment: Democracy survived Nixon; Trump is a greater threat

A special. prosecutor in the Nixon investigation is concerned about how society has changed since then.

Burke: Dilemma in donations is in where to put your money

With a range of worthy causes — charitable and political — how should one weigh where the need is greatest?

Everett officer acted properly in arrest; The Herald didn’t

I read The Herald daily, as I have for some time, and… Continue reading

Heed warnings from Trump’s former backers

It’s not about Republicans vs. Democrats, left vs. right, liberal vs. conservative.… Continue reading

Ben Ramirez is doused with water by teammates after the AquaSox beat the Emeralds to clinch a playoff berth on Monday, Sept. 4, 2023, in Everett. (Photo provided by AquaSox)
Editorial: City’s $1 million an investment in Everett baseball

Contracts for preliminary work on an AquaSox stadium honor team’s 40 years of family fun and tradition.

civic health white board
Editorial: Improving civic health starts by coming to table

Efforts locally and at the state level seek to counter the incivility that has mired public discourse.

From the bodycam footage of Everett police officer Ryan Greely and footage from Molly Wright, Wright films officer Greely before he arrests her for obstructing a law enforcement officer on Aug. 10, 2023 in Everett, Washington. (Screenshot from a video provided by Molly Wright)
Editorial: Duties on both sides of camera during arrests

The right to record police activity is clear, but so is the need to respect the safety of officers and others.

Macro photo of tooth wheel mechanism with imprinted RECEIVE, GIVE concept words
Editorial: Get back into charitable habit for Giving Tuesday

Inflation sapped donations for charities last year; things may be looking up this year for more.

Comment: Seniors, kids share in rising rates of poverty

But too often, the solution is seen as taking from one to help the other. That’s not necessary.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.