Forum: Do efforts without some sacrifice still have meaning?

We can protest with little consequence. Lose weight with a shot. But have we suffered for any of it?

By Dan Hazen / Herald Forum

Aging rockers like me will remember the break-out Metallica hit from 1989 titled “One.”

The music video solidified the horror-story narrative of a soldier who lost legs, arms and all his senses, but was kept alive; in pain and unable to communicate. The lyrics include the words, “Hold my breath as I wish for death. Oh please, God, wake me.” Dark stuff. Makes for quality head banging, dark entertainment, and is also completely implausible. Right?

I hadn’t thought about the song for decades until I read an article in the Aug. 14 edition of MIT News which detailed the development of an implantable anti-opioid overdose device: the “iSOS Robotic First Responder” which is, according to the article, “about the size of a stick of gum, can be implanted under the skin, where it monitors heart rate, breathing rate, and other vital signs. When it determines that an overdose has occurred, it rapidly pumps out a dose of naloxone.” It’s also refillable and rechargeable so it will be ready for your next overdose.

In addition, I came upon news declaring that the new class of drug called semaglutides, developed to control the blood sugar levels of those with Type 2 diabetes but increasing used by nondiabetics for weight loss, ultimately allowing for a future in which we can eat however we want, if we have access to the right pill or shot.

Both technologies reveal what I’m afraid is a growing gulf between our collective definition of life and what life actually is. Privileged university students endure fines and jail to protest for the lives of Palestinians. Millions of evangelicals give hundreds of millions of dollars to protect the lives of the unborn. But neither group repents, nor even laments any complicity in the systems that continue killing those they seek to protect.

Yes, I’m describing what’s been termed “virtue signaling,” but it runs much deeper than that.

We have sub-contracted, commodified, branded and severed compassion from self. We have lost the lived experience of compassion; literally, “to suffer with.” We’ve isolated it, sanitized it, gamified it and turned it into fashion statements and science experiments. Thus, we are losing its essence. We’ve stopped asking what life is for, and we merely seek to maintain it for vague, un-examined motives that have to do with how we feel about ourselves, even if it means protracted suffering for those we “save.” (See the increased number of miserable, unnaturally old pets dragged about in strollers and gruesomely displayed on social media). Our hollowed-out compassion is on the cusp of becoming cruelty.

I spent those “Metallica” years in active addiction, but I never overdosed, so I can’t personally speak to that experience. Yet, I can tell you that I counted life as cheap. There was more than one occasion when, as my consciousness faded, I would have been content if it never returned. Today, I find myself wondering what my response would have been if I had been automatically jolted back to life by a machine, rather than what did happen: I encountered a reason to live, not just the means to stay alive. I guess I’m asking: Why does life matter to you?

As long as there is breath, there is hope, so this is by no means a call to do away with things like iSOS, semaglutides, charitable giving or protests for justice. This is just a reminder that all of these things simply point us toward possibilities.

Dan Hazen lives in Marysville.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, Oct. 9

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Jack Armstrong, a Starbird Unit forester, cores a tree located in a portion of the Stilly Revisited timber sale on Wednesday, May 29, 2024 in Arlington, Washington. (Ta'Leah Van Sistine / The Herald)
Editorial: Herrera Beutler best to lead public lands mission

The former member of Congress would balance the state’s trust lands for revenue and conservation.

Burke: TV ads add nothing to our lives but annoyance

Fair warning: You may start humming the 1-877-Kars4Kids jingle while reading this; then you’ll just fume.

Were exposure hazards of training fire in Snohomish known?

Recent news reports indicate that perhaps up to 150 Snohomish County firefighters… Continue reading

Congress, 2nd District: Larsen a leader on many issues

I am proud to endorse Rick Larsen for re-election to the Second… Continue reading

Krugman: Bidenomics got it right on policy and prosperity

Defying doomsayers, Biden adopted investments that didn’t result in recession and high unemployment.

Comment: Netanyahu’s plan for peace has to start at home

If there’s no place in leadership for Hamas and Hezbollah, there’s no room for Israel’s nationalist fanatics.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Tuesday, Oct. 8

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Washington Attorney General Bob Ferguson speaks at the Snohomish & Island County Labor Council champions dinner on Tuesday, Oct. 10, 2023 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Editorial: Ferguson makes case as best choice for governor

The three-term AG knows Washington’s needs and challenges and is prepared to lead the state.

Superior Court Judge: Anderson empathetic, accessible

Mary Anderson exemplifies a commitment to justice and equality through her extensive… Continue reading

Comment: Wider Israel-Iran war would devastate the Mideast

And the U.S. would almost certainly be pulled into the conflict as Israel seeks combat support.

Comment: New Jan. 6 brief against Trump still faces challenge

Special counsel Jack Smith attempts to follow the Supreme Court’s guidance, but it gets the last word.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.