Governments don’t create jobs

Regarding the letter, “Stimulus efforts are effective”: The writer and Paul Krugman (Nobel Prize winning economist) should take their government stimulus idea to its ultimate conclusion. We would have full employment if all workers were public employees. Only problem with that idea is the question, where does government get its money? The government takes money (in the form of taxes, all taxes are bad, some are necessary) from one person to give it to another person.

The transfer of wealth surely stimulates the person getting the stimulus money but in most cases doesn’t help the person supplying it. There are certain legitimate federal government functions (see Article 1, Sec. 8… U.S. Constitution) that are authorized. Governments do not create any wealth or create any jobs. They have to take it from someone else to do what they do. Sooner or later you “run out of other people’s money”!

The free market is where wealth is created and a portion of that wealth is turned over to government in the form of taxes. The more government spends, less the wealth that is created because there is less money in the private sector to create more wealth. Socialism (think Greece, etc. ) cannot survive without a free market economy. A free market economy can survive and flourish without socialism. We have thousands of years of history on this. Paul Krugman (the Nobel Prize winning economist) is dead wrong and so is the letter writer.

Al Wirta

Sultan

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

A Sabey Corporation data center in East Wenatchee, Wash., on Nov. 3, 2024. The rural region is changing fast as electricians from around the country plug the tech industry’s new, giant data centers into its ample power supply. (Jovelle Tamayo/The New York Times)
Editorial: Protect utililty ratepayers as data centers ramp up

State lawmakers should move ahead with guardrails for electricity and water use by the ‘cloud’ and AI.

Bad Bunny on stage during his residency at the Coliseo de Puerto Rico José Miguel Agrelot in San Juan, Puerto Rico, Aug. 9, 2025. Bad Bunny’s three-month concert series in San Juan is spurring a short-term surge in Puerto Rico’s economy. (Amy Lombard/The New York Times)
Comment: NFL suits up Bad Bunny in long drive for global appeal

President Trump and others don’t like the halftime choice, but the NFL’s bet is that Latinos will.

Comment: Bill can restore hope for incarcerated Native people

Legislation would allow for review of the sentences for some Native Americans held in prison.

Student protests prove kids as the adults in the room

I want to express how proud I am of the thousands of… Continue reading

Welcome new immigrants adjusting to a new culture

I am reminded, in these days of cleaving, we are encouraged to… Continue reading

Has Trump forgotten what’s written on Lady Liberty?

Have Donald Trump and his partners in arms forgotten, overlooked, or interpreted… Continue reading

Comment: Listening to, helping boys and men can help us all

State lawmakers can establish a state Boys and Men Commission to address the challenges they face.

Comment: LifeWise misreads Constitution in suing Everett Schools

Case law allows release time for off-campus religious instruction. Schools don’t have to promote it.

Comment: Without child care support, work stops; it’s simple

Families and employers depend on state child care assistance. Cuts to two programs would harm all.

Forum: Immigration raids involving children cause lasting trauma

The cruelty and terror inherent in raids by federal immigration agents cannot be allowednear children.

Forum: As go our forests, so goes our environmental future

The Trump administration’s move to end the Roadless Rule jeopardizes ancient forests and risks collapse.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.