Harrop: Why is GOP playing a game that backfired in 2011?

The last time Republicans threatened to refuse a debt-limit boost they lost seats and the U.S. lost $19 billion.

By Froma Harrop / syndicated columnist

This is not about what would happen were the United States to default on its debt. It’s about what occurred in 2011 when one party just threatened to let that happen.

A Democrat, Barack Obama, was president, and for crazy partisan reasons, the Republican leadership deemed it a smart move to play games with the full faith and credit of the United States. Wouldn’t crashing the economy sully the record of a Democratic administration and reward us at the polls? That’s what they seemed to think.

Well, the standoff over the debt ceiling so spooked the markets that the S&P 500 index fell 7 percent in one day, erasing $1 trillion dollars from Americans’ net worth. Consumer confidence crashed to a low point not seen since the dregs of the financial meltdown a few years before.

As a bonus kick in the nation’s rear, the specter of a major political party putting into question America’s willingness to pay back money owed prompted Standard & Poor’s to take away America’s triple-A credit rating. We still haven’t gotten it back. Casting doubt on our readiness to repay investors has since cost the U.S. Treasury an estimated $19 billion in higher interest costs.

By the way, nine countries have triple-A ratings. They are Australia, Denmark, Germany, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Norway, Singapore, Sweden and Switzerland.

Republicans are at it again. As Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell put it dishonestly, irresponsibly and treacherously, “There’s no chance Republicans will help lift Democrats’ credit limit.” I’ll spare you his blah-blah-blah about socialism or that raising the debt limit would “help China.” Be assured that China is delighted at the disgraceful spectacle of national disfunction.

About the money owed: We raise the debt limit to pay for spending that has already been authorized, not future spending. And much of the spending and debt Republicans are now denouncing was their own, supercharged under the guidance of former President Donald “I’ve always loved debt” Trump.

During the Trump administration, the ratio of U.S. debt to the size of the economy surpassed 100 percent for the first time since World War II. And no, Trump’s tax cuts didn’t come close to paying for themselves; but in fact bloated further deficits. Republican spending, meanwhile, went off the charts. And in those four years, Democrats voted to raise the debt ceiling three times.

But what about the covid-19 pandemic? Wasn’t Trump simply dealt a bad economic card? He was, although his clowning-around about the seriousness of the crisis and failure to forcefully curb it made the economic damage worse than it had to be. And do recall that Obama was also handed a bad card: He inherited an economy in smoking ruins, courtesy of his Republican predecessor.

It’s crazy that Congress even has to vote on this, but when it comes time to raise the debt limit, lawmakers simply have to do it. The debt ceiling has been raised 98 times since World War II. It was done under Republican Ronald Reagan 18 times.

This may reflect the right wing’s determination to subject America to chaos all the time. But Republicans should drop the notion that playing chicken with the country’s creditworthiness is a political winner.

Americans were not amused by the stress and higher borrowing costs perpetrated by the insanity of 10 years ago. And they didn’t blame Democrats for it. The next year, Obama was elected for a second term, and Democrats gained two seats in the Senate and eight seats in the House.

Republicans will not win hearts by insisting that they don’t have to help America repay its debts; especially since they racked up so much of them.

Follow Froma Harrop on Twitter @FromaHarrop. Email her at fharrop@gmail.com.

Talk to us

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Tuesday, Dec. 7

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

FILE - In this May 17, 2018, file photo attorneys walk up the steps of the Washington Supreme Court building, the Temple of Justice, in Olympia, Wash. The court on Thursday, Sept. 30, 2021, unanimously upheld the Washington's tax on big banks aimed at providing essential services and improving the state's regressive tax system. The 1.2% business and occupation surtax, a tax added on top of other taxes — was passed by the Legislature in 2019. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File)
Editorial: Ruling may not be last word on state redistricting

The state Supreme Court accepted the redistricting panel’s work, but limited the scope of its ruling.

Harrop: Hold parents of school shooters responsible

Leaving firearms unsecured around mentally disturbed youths only invites the next massacre.

Comment: Bob Dole was partisan, but he knew how to govern

The Republican senator fought Democratic legislation but would also work diligently across the aisle.

Comment: Remembering Pearl Harbor often forgets Pacific’s past

The Dec. 7 attack followed years of colonialism by Japan and the U.S. in Hawai’i and the Philippines.

A Swift bus and an Everett Transit bus travel north on Rucker Avenue on Saturday in Everett. (Sue Misao / The Herald)
Editorial: Help pick a route for Everett’s transit future

A joint study will gather information on whether to combine Everett Transit and Community Transit.

Robert J. Sutherland (Washington State House Republicans)
Editorial: State House covid rules won’t exclude GOP lawmakers

A requirement for vaccination only means those unvaccinated will have to attend sessions remotely.

An artist's rendering shows features planned for the first floor of an expansion of the Imagine Children's Museum. The area will include a representation of the old bicycle tree in Snohomish and an outdoorsy Camp Imagine. (Imagine Children's Museum)
Editorial: GivingTuesday offers chance to build better future

Organizations, such as Imagine Children’s Museum, need our support as we look past the pandemic.

Comment: Fifth Amendment isn’t a blanket stay-out-of-jail card

Congress’ Jan. 6 committee is entitled to probe the validity of a Trump lawyer’s latest refusal to testify.

Most Read