Ken White: Analogies are useful tools but they can be misused

Comparing mask mandates and vaccine rules to the oppression of the Holocaust is pure propaganda.

By Ken W. White / Herald Forum

Years ago, I applied to a college of education and took the Miller Analogies Test. The MAT measures things like cultural literacy and reasoning ability. Reasoning by analogy draws logical conclusions from the similarities and contrasts between two things. In short, it’s about knowing the difference between an apple and an orange.

Metaphorical language — analogies and similes — is a powerful tool in teaching, social change and political communication. It uses everyday objects or experiences to explain more complex ideas such as “a business is like a family.”

Unfortunately, if misused, analogies oversimplify, lead to misunderstanding and hide important facts. Businesses have similarities to families but you can’t fire a family member.

Analogies can also be tools of propaganda.

For example, Republicans aim to associate Democratic policies intended to save lives with anti-democratic acts intended to control people. U.S. Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene, R-Ga., who earlier claimed that Jewish space lasers sparked disastrous forest fires, recently compared mask mandates to the Holocaust, an event she probably doesn’t even believe is true. More recently state Rep. Jim Walsh, R-Aberdeen, made a similar comparison by wearing a yellow Star of David — which Nazis forced Jews to wear during the Holocaust — to protest covid vaccination rules. Walsh later apologized.

Greene cynically likens mask requirements to the Nazis’ use of the Star of David and shows no understanding of the difference between controlling a disease to save lives and controlling people to gas them. To Greene, the two ideas were politically analogous and morally equivalent.

Greene cannot reason by analogy — to know an apple from an orange — but her muddled thinking is open to irony. Although she doesn’t comprehend the full meaning of her public comparison, people see the backhandedness. They know that right-wing extremists — American Nazis, white supremacists, Jan. 6 rioters, Greene’s allies — oppose masks mandates as threats to their personal freedom while they openly attack Jewish personal identity, safety and liberty. The use of the Star of David for public identification and humiliation is their dream, and it was clearly displayed at the U.S. Capitol insurrection.

On the other hand, while Greene is not good at reasoning by analogy, she is exceptional at projecting. She follows the Trump playbook of accusing others of doing what they are doing — anti-Semitism, sex trafficking, election fraud and fascist bullying — in order to cloak their real intent.

To find the intent of Greene and Republicans like her, we need to “watch what they do, not what they say.”

Ken W. White lives in Marysville.

Talk to us

More in Opinion

Interior of Tulalip Indian School with students demonstrating learning procedures.  Possibly taken May 13, 1914 for a photo exhibit shown at the Panama Exposition. (J.A. Juleen / Everett Public Library's Northwest History Room)
Editorial: Getting to the truth of Tulalip boarding school

As with other Indian boarding schools in the U.S., a local school left an equally disturbing legacy.

Editorial cartoons for Monday, Sept. 27

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Pamela Propeck works on an assignment at the Advanced Manufacturing Training & Education Center Wednesday morning at Everett Community College on June 3, 2020. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Editorial: Students, economy need boost of free college

EvCC canceled students’ debt, showing what free community college can deliver to students and employers.

The 214-foot tall cranes work to unload their first cargo shipments at South Terminal at the Port of Everett on Thursday, April 8, 2021 in Everett, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Editorial: Murphy can bring more transparency to port board

Voters will choose between two strong candidates for Everett’s port board, each with years of service.

A houseboat rests in a cove at Lake Powell Friday, July 30, 2021, near Page, Ariz. This summer, the water levels hit a historic low amid a climate change-fueled megadrought engulfing the U.S. West. (AP Photo/Rick Bowmer)
Editorial: Summer of extremes calls for climate change action

The significant investments now considered by Congress are our best chance to limit climate change.

Burke: Something ain’t right, deep in the heart of Texas

The Lone Star state sent out its lawsuit posses to end a constitutional right. But masks? No ma’am.

Deniers of covid and climate prompt pessimism

Regarding the commentary “Does too strong a message turn some from vaccine?”… Continue reading

County Council, Dist. 5: Donaghy brings diversity, experience

Please vote for Brandy Donaghy for Snohomish County Council Position 5. Brandy… Continue reading

Everett Council, Dist. 1: City needs Roberts’ experience

We have known Paul Roberts as a neighbor and friend in Everett’s… Continue reading

Most Read