Landslide threat remains at Gold Basin campground

The article about the re-opening of the U.S. Forest Service Gold Basin campground is rife with errors and contradictions. The worst of all is the statement that in re-opening the campground “trees that had died were cut down.” In fact, numerous healthy, living trees were cut down, some more than four feet in diameter. I had talked with several officials and workers about those trees, with workers expressing regret, and officials always claiming that they were “hazard trees.” It turns out that any conifer that split into more than a single trunk high above was deemed a “hazard tree,” simply because it didn’t fit their definition of arboreal perfection. It’s a disgrace to see such wonderful trees cut down in the name of safety. Any tree can be deemed a “hazard tree,” because it can fall over or drop a huge branch unexpectedly.

But if safety is a concern, the campground should never have been re-opened due to the glacial till cliffs directly across the river from the campground. That’s the real safety issue, which has been geologically mapped as potentially catastrophic. In fact, it presents a far higher danger than that of geologically similar Oso slide five years ago, which killed 43 people. The entire Gold Basin campground could easily be buried by a slide from the far bigger cliffs that sit directly across the river from the campground.

Bruce Barnbaum

Granite Falls

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, Feb. 19

A sketchy look at the day in politics.… Continue reading

Editorial: Insurance fee could limit wildfire risk, damage

A modest tax would fund $63 million each year for forest health and fighting wildfires in the state.

Editorial: Our county’s dubious distinction on school funding

The failure rate for levies and bonds in the county is in contrast to 90 percent approval statewide.

Editorial: Ballot’s ‘push polls’ on taxes don’t advise anyone

The tax advisory votes serve no legitimate purpose and should be removed from state election ballots.

Commentary: Oil trains need big enough crew for safety

Legislation would ensure trains carrying hazardous materials have workers ready if a problem arises.

Commentary: We knew what Barr would do as AG; he told us

The Senate knew Barr would use the Justice Department as a political cudgel. Yet, he was confirmed.

Commentary: On climate, hope for the best, prepare for worst

As sea levels rise, low-lying cities will be inundated. By 2100, 300 million could be displaced.

Rehiring fired deputies appears political, divisive

I am a lot more worried about Sheriff Adam Fortney bringing back… Continue reading

Editorial cartoons for Tuesday, Feb. 18

A sketchy look at the day in politics.… Continue reading

Most Read