Lottery system inherently unfair

The Marysville School District has eight Small Learning Communities that serve high school students. Each SLC specializes in unique core classes geared toward specific industry. The SLCs are not equal; the curriculum focus and electives are different.

Each spring eighth-grade students review each of the eight SLC curriculums and indicate their top three choices. Students have to think about classes that interest them and career choices. Students complete the SLC selection form and their choices are run through a computer-driven lottery. Students do not decide where they will attend, the lottery does. The lottery has made education a game of chance.

If the student is unhappy with the SLC given they can file for an in-district transfer. Transfers are only honored as space becomes available. Never does the district consider why the student made their first choice or ask what courses they need to gain academic rigor. The school district requests eighth-grade students make challenging choices about their future career paths and spend the next four years studying in this pathway. However, there are no safeguards to make sure each student receives the needed curriculum to attain future goals.

The district states in No. 7 of its vision statement: “We believe that it is critical to ensure that all students are prepared for work and post secondary education and training.” Yet, you can be an eighth-grade student who has met the challenge to think about your future, made a definitive decision and not receive the SLC of your choice. They ask that you settle for coursework and classes that were adequate but not geared toward the academic rigor you requested.

When you serve 800 freshmen the lottery is a necessity, but the district needs to amend procedures to ensure that every student is the lucky winner of the lottery.

Laurie Dunston
Tulalip

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Thursday, Dec. 12

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Free Application for Federal Student Aid FAFSA is shown on a photo using the text (Getty Images)
Editorial: Applying for financial aid key for students, economy

As families risk leaving money on the table, the state risks leaving well-paid jobs unfilled.

Comment: The lines between protectors, vigilantes and killers

Cynicism, caused by frustration with the failings of the ‘system,’ drives support for vigilantes.

Harrop: Understanding the anger behind insurance CEO’s murder

You don’t have to condone a vigilante to understand why so many people see the assailant as a hero.

Saunders: A good DOGE idea: Tell workers to return to office

With covid a bad memory, why are most federal employees working from home and not at their offices?

Goldman: What Trump’s crush on Argentina’s ‘madman’ means here

Admiration for Javier Milei is based in a small-government conservatism in feral tech-bro form.

Comment: Electric push can help Democrats spark climate action

Rather than reject climate efforts as an issue, clean energy should be seen as an enabler of broader policy.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, Dec. 11

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Are we getting money’s worth for what’s spent on elections

Now that the dust has settled and statistics are in: $16 billion… Continue reading

Everett budget punishing kids, readers

I was distressed to read this morning that the city of Everett… Continue reading

Keep time change or nix it; just make a decision

Decisions, decisions, decisions. Seems like we are always faced with decisions in… Continue reading

Krugman: Hope for moving past resentment-driven politics

Paul Krugman reflects on what’s changed in his 25 years as a New York Times columnist.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.