Militancy hurts wage debate

Seattle’s $15 minimum wage debate will likely be resolved at the November ballot. Although Seattle Mayor Ed Murray would like to avoid ballot battles, activists associated with the group, 15 Now, are already gathering signatures. They say if the mayor and city council fail to adopt a wage hike they like, they’ll take it to the voters.

Last week, Murray said he wanted a supermajority recommendation from the 24-member committee he appointed to address the issue. He thinks broad support from the advisory group would demonstrate that their proposal is right for the city, making dueling initiatives unnecessary.

That seems improbable. While the committee includes business, labor, nonprofits and city council members, participation in the discussion presupposed willingness to compromise. For many on both sides, compromise is capitulation.

What Seattle does matters statewide. So far, no one has devised a containment strategy to prevent Seattle politics from spreading. It’s not Vegas. What happens in Seattle doesn’t stay in Seattle.

Last week, Murray outlined six principles on which a thin majority of his committee agrees: $15 is the right number; the increase should be phased in for small businesses and nonprofits; once reached it should be adjusted for inflation; everyone pays — no exemptions; there needs to be an enforcement plan, and credit for some benefits should be phased out as higher wages phase in.

The principles are fuzzy. Here’s what’s clear: The mayor and most members of his committee want to get to a $15 citywide minimum wage quickly; they want it to affect everyone; and they will create a new enforcement system to assure compliance.

It remains complicated. Does $15 include tips and other benefits? How small is a small business? How long a phase-in? What’s enforcement entail? Although business groups sensibly argue that the minimum wage should reflect total compensation, union and progressive activists reject the idea. They contend it breaks with the state’s existing minimum wage law. Washington is one of seven states without a tip credit. Socialist city councilmember Kshama Sawant, channeling Gertrude Stein’s thoughts on a rose, says, “Wages are wages are wages.”

A sharp increase in the minimum will cause some businesses to control costs by cutting other benefits, leaving some employees worse off. Wages spent on health care or education won’t be available for groceries.

Despite the presence of business members on Murray’s committee, the Seattle process has had a consistent get-it-done slant. There’s scant acknowledgment that an unprecedented 60 percent minimum wage increase will lead to job losses, business closures and relocations.

To study the effects, the city hired a prominent labor economist who supports raising the wage. The mayor’s minimum wage symposium resembled a campus teach-in, proselytization disguised as education. No skeptical economists were invited to participate. Nothing was permitted to disrupt the narrative.

Yet, economists generally agree that raising the minimum wage leads to downsizing and slower hiring. The larger the wage jump, the greater the job loss. Some believe the positive effects of higher wages outweigh the negative impacts on employment. It’s a worthwhile debate, one the city has largely bypassed as officials attempt to fine-tune negotiations leading them to their pre-ordained destination.

This is where a columnist generally inserts a paragraph saying the advocates are well intentioned, but that their strategy is flawed. I’m disinclined. The advocacy has been too strident, too one-sided for that. The most aggressive advocates deny even the possibility of adverse consequences. That they know better, or should, calls their intentions into question.

Murray says he worries about a “class war” if a satisfactory compromise eludes the committee. The 15 Now ballot measure prescribes $15 for all and a three-year phase-in for small business and nonprofits, defining small as fewer than 250 employees. No committee compromise will go that far. Sawant wants the conflict. “We live in a capitalist system. It is class warfare,” she said, as she recycled rhetorical assaults on the 1 percent. That’s inaccurate and recklessly provocative. Civic and business leaders in Seattle have worked in good faith, arguably against their own self-interest, to increase opportunities and compensation for low-wage workers. Those efforts should not be held hostage to the demands of a small group of militant activists.

Richard S. Davis is president of the Washington Research Council. Email rsdavis@simeonpartners.com

Talk to us

More in Opinion

A reporter watches the Maricopa County ballots cast in the 2020 general election being examined and recounted by contractors working for Florida-based company, Cyber Ninjas, who was hired by the Arizona State Senate at Veterans Memorial Coliseum in Phoenix, Thursday, April 29, 2021. (Rob Schumacher/The Arizona Republic via AP, Pool)
Editorial: Wyman right to object to Arizona ballot audit

An authority on election integrity, Washington’s secretary of state sees red flags in a rogue recount.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Thursday, May 6

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

children homeless students
Editorial: Joint program connecting homeless families, school

A multi-partner program is removing barriers that keep children out of school and caught in poverty.

Gary Holt, who reads bills being considered in the Washington House, wears a mask as he sits behind a plexiglass shield with reflections of state representatives meeting remotely on it, Wednesday, April 21, 2021, at the Capitol in Olympia Wash. The House was considering a proposed new tax in Washington state on capital gains that would be imposed on the sale of stocks and bonds in excess of $250,000. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
Editorial: The ‘forgotten astronaut’ and the state GOP

Republican lawmakers in Olympia can appreciate the position of Apollo 11’s Michael Collins.

Rep. John Lovick is sworn in at his home Friday afternoon in Mill Creek on January 8, 2021.  (Kevin Clark/The Herald)
Editorial: Seeking justice after the murder of George Floyd

Rep. John Lovick saw no justice in Chauvin’s verdict alone, but hopes for a path in lawmakers’ work.

Harrop: Before you ditch that mask, consider its benefits

While we were masked up, flu deaths went down, our faces were warmer and some saved on lipstick.

Fact check: Claims a poor foundation for infrastructure talks

Comparisons of Biden’s and the GOP’s plans haven’t accurately reflected what’s included in each.

Comment: Transition a chance to create a post-pandemic life

The journey of the Israelites out of Egypt offers an example through how they changed their society.

Don Rider served community in numerous groups

Often times we become aware of those citizens who work behind the… Continue reading

Most Read