Our failure to teach history bodes ill for nation’s future

  • David Broder / Washington Post Columnist
  • Wednesday, July 27, 2005 9:00pm
  • Opinion

WASHINGTON – Along with millions of others, my granddaughters Lauren, Nicole and Julia eagerly tore open the boxes containing “Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince,” as soon as they arrived at the airport near the cabin where they were on vacation, and then disappeared into their rooms – barely to reappear for the next 24 hours, while they were devouring the sixth in the best-selling series.

And thereby they proved David McCullough’s point. Late last month, the prolific historian had told a Senate hearing that his examination of school history textbooks had shown a disquieting trend. Over the years, he said, he has noticed that the typeface in those books is growing larger, the illustrations more lavish and the content shrinking. The authors and the teachers using these textbooks “seem to assume that students don’t like to read,” he said, “and then Harry Potter comes along and blows it all away.”

McCullough, whose latest volume, “1776,” is a nonfiction best-seller, was the star witness at a hearing convened by Sens. Lamar Alexander and Ted Kennedy to air their concerns about what they called, “U.S. History: Our Worst Subject?”

Alexander, a Tennessee Republican, noted that “according to the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), commonly referred to as ‘the nation’s report card,’ fewer students have just a basic understanding of American history than have a basic understanding of any other subject which we test – including math, science and reading.”

Charles Smith, the executive director of the NAEP governing board, spelled out what that means. In 2001, the last time the American history test was given, 57 percent of the 12th graders scored “below basic” in the subject.

“This means,” he said, “that the majority of 12th graders did not know, for example, that the Monroe Doctrine expressed opposition to European colonization in the Americas at the early part of the 19th century; how government spending during the Great Depression affected the economy; and that the Soviet Union was an ally of the U.S. in World War II.”

Kennedy added that the historian emeritus at his brother’s presidential library in Boston had reported that nine states have no standards for teaching American history and 22 others have standards he regarded as weak.

Alexander said, “Our children don’t know American history because they are not being taught it,” adding that the Florida Legislature had recently passed a bill permitting students to graduate from high school without taking a single U.S. history course.

McCullough said at the hearing that the problem starts with the training that teachers receive. “Too many have degrees in education,” he said, “and don’t really know the subject they are teaching.”

“It is impossible to love a subject you don’t know,” he said, “and without a passion for history, the teaching of history becomes a matter of rote learning and drudgery.”

Without personal knowledge of history and enthusiasm for the subject, “you’re much more dependent on the textbook,” and, with rare exceptions – he mentioned the great one-volume American history text by Daniel Boorstin, the late Librarian of Congress – “you read these texts and ask yourself, ‘Are they assigned as punishment?’”

McCullough, who is nothing if not passionate about the subject, added: “Amnesia of society is just as detrimental as amnesia for the individual. We are running a terrible risk. Our very freedom depends on education, and we are failing our children in not providing that education.”

The schools, he said, are also denying them “a source of infinite pleasure,” a pastime that can enrich them throughout their lives. “I think we human beings are naturally interested in history. All our stories begin, ‘Once upon a time … .’ To make history boring is a crime.”

Just as Harry Potter’s extraordinary success demonstrates young people’s hunger for a compelling narrative, other factors suggest ways that history can be made vivid. A Smithsonian Institution official testified that its program last year offered 57,000 teachers an opportunity to work shoulder to shoulder with scholars doing primary-source research work – an experience they can then share with their students.

And McCullough gave enthusiastic support to a suggestion from Alexander and Kennedy that the hundreds of National Historical Sites scattered around the country be used for seminars where teachers could visit the places where signal events of the past occurred and fill themselves with the stories the well-informed guides can provide.

“I am very optimistic about what can be done,” McCullough said, if the nation just decides to recapture its history.

David Broder is a Washington Post columnist. Contact him by writing to davidbroder@washpost.com.

Talk to us

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Friday, April 16

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

This Aug. 23, 2020 photo shows a long line of unsold 2020 models charge outside a Tesla dealership in Littleton, Colo.  The European Union is lacking sufficient charging infrastructure for electric vehicles, according to the bloc's external auditor. In a report published Tuesday, April 13, 2021, the European Court of Auditors said users are gaining more harmonized access to charging networks but the EU is still “a long way from reaching its Green Deal target of 1 million charging points by 2025." (AP Photo/David Zalubowski)
Editorial: Bills’ merger makes clean-driving future possible

Combining two bills will aid the sales of electric vehicles and ensure ample charging stations.

Comment: Build Mukilteo’s NOAA research center to fit budget

A decision to scrap a new station because its bids were over-budget calls for a change in plans.

Comment: Will people trust media when values aren’t shared?

A poll showing how the public views journalistic standards may call for a change in how news is presented.

Comment: Covid ignores borders; public health must as well

A lack of coordination among nations stunted the pandemic response. Those failures can’t be repeated.

FILE - In this undated photo, provided by NY Governor's Press Office on Saturday March 27, 2021, is the new "Excelsior Pass" app, a digital pass that people can download to show proof of vaccination or a negative COVID-19 test. Vaccine passports being developed to verify COVID-19 immunization status and allow inoculated people to more freely travel, shop and dine have become the latest flash point in America’s perpetual political wars, with Republicans portraying them as a heavy-handed intrusion into personal freedom and private health choices. (NY Governor's Press Office via AP, File)
Editorial: Vaccine passports can nudge more toward immunity

Used to persuade rather than exclude, the passports could increase access to businesses and venues.

Eric Brossard displays his commemorative Drug Court graduation coin that reads, "I came with hope, worked and learned. I have a new life. A life that I've earned." (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Editorial: Court ruling requires focus on addiction treatment

A court decision allows for a more effective and affordable solution to substance use disorder.

An architectual illustration shows the proposed Learning Resource Center at Everett Community College. The centerAn architectual illustration shows the proposed Learning Resource Center at Everett Community College. The center would replace the college's Libary Media Center, built in 1988. The Senate capital budget proposal allocates $48 million for its construction, while the House budget includes no funding for it. (Courtesy of Everett Community College) would replace the college's
Editorial: Capital budget a bipartisan boost for communities

House and Senate proposals are substantial and needed, but final talks should secure an EvCC project.

Editorial cartoons for Thursday, April 15

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Most Read