Patents on business ideas can limit consumer choice

Less than 20 years ago, companies almost never claimed that they had invented methods of doing business and could block competitors from copying their practices. In the early 1980s, however, the courts began a series of rulings that favor patents for some business ideas.

Now, the absurdity of the idea is becoming so clear that Congress is discussing measures to address the problem. As American as apple pie, lobbyists are popping up everywhere to protect the I-thought-of-it-first interests who think a good idea should be a ticket to lifetime wealth.

As a Wall Street Journal news story pointed out the other day, the practice of patenting ideas has spread with the digital age. Microsoft and other software firm hold hundreds of patents for unique ideas. has sued a rival on-line bookseller for infringing on a patent for 1-click shopping, a process that makes purchasing items over the Internet easier.

Beyond software, however, there is a much more pernicious form of patenting focused on methods of doing business. One of the more aggressive business-patent firms at is Walker Digital, whose founder Jay Walker believes that many innovations should have been patented. Among them: the credit card, the ATM machine and frequent-flier miles.

One of Walker’s firms holds a patent for a practice currently being licensed to Kentucky Fried Chicken outlets. Clerks offer drinks or menu items at a discount, for the amount of change the customer would otherwise receive.

The patent mania provokes not just amazement but legitimate worries about the effects on consumers. The patents prohibit other companies from offering the same services for 20 years, unless licensing fees are paid. Robert Crandall, the creator of frequent-flier miles while running American Airlines, told the Journal: "It seems to me that if business processes were patentable, you would very severely limit competition."

There are various proposals for limiting the damage to competition, including a much-shorter period of time for patents on business ideas. Two members of Congress, responding to suggestions that some of the patents are being issued mistakenly, have proposed making applications public. That, at least, would give other business people or firms a chance to show that some of the supposed inventions aren’t so original as claimed.

In an age when much of the work force breaks a sweat only at the health club, it is not surprising that people seek to turn a half-clever idea into a personal fortune. If such an approach to ingenuity had been the mark of America in the past, though, we would have had a severely limited economy. We would have had attorneys fighting over who thought of drive-thru windows, express checkout lanes at groceries and clerks who say, "Did you find everything you wanted?" Instead of competing with convenience, taste and service, homegrown Pacific Northwest geniuses might have fought over the exclusive right to serve a "double-tall skinny no foam."

Granted, there could be blessings in a slower spread of some sales practices. What if telemarketing had been limited by being a patented invention? In this case, however, it’s clear that Congress ought to step in and protect consumers from abusive patent practices.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

RGB version
Editorial cartoons for Sunday, June 16

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Father's Day is a holiday of honouring fatherhood and paternal bonds, as well as the influence of fathers in society.
Editorial: Men, boys could use a little help to be better men

The work of fathers could be aided by a state commission focused on the issues of boys and men.

Comment: Father’s love includes talking about drugs, alcohol

All dads want to protect and care for their kids. Among the greatest threats are drugs and alcohol.

FILE — Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito and his wife, Martha-Ann, visit the Capitol Rotunda as the Rev. Billy Graham lay in honor there on Feb. 28, 2018. Martha-Ann Alito has built a limited public life since moving to Washington that has mainly centered on apolitical projects and charity work. (Erin Schaff/The New York Times)
Comment: This conversation may be recorded

It’s not just Supreme Court justices who need worry. Our laws around electronic monitoring are lax.

Don’t blame woodpeckers for damage to PUD power poles

The Snohomish County Public Utility Districts knows that there are lots of… Continue reading

Mainsream media is only serving elites

Without a doubt, the lowest life form in America today is the… Continue reading

Comment: Climate crisis requires declaration of World War Zero

We’ve done it before with the New Deal, World War II and the space race; and we can do it again.

Comment: Lynnwood’s cannabis ban stifles business, progress

The city council’s reversal of a vote to consider retail marijuana is based on unfounded fears.

The City of Everett is set to purchase two single sidewalk restrooms from Romtec, a company based in Roseburg, Ore., for $315,000. (Romtec)
Editorial: Utilitarian but sturdy restrooms should be a relief

Everett is placing four stalls downtown that should be accessible but less prone to problems.

Artist Natalie Niblack works amongst her project entitled “33 Birds / Three Degrees” during the setup for Exploring The Edge at Schack Art Center on Sunday, March 19, 2023, in Everett, Washington. The paintings feature motion-activated speakers that play each bird’s unique call. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Editorial: For 50 years Schack Art Center there for creation

The art center is more art studio than museum, supporting artists and fostering creativity in kids.

Snohomish School District’s Clayton Lovell plugs in the district’s electric bus after morning routes on Thursday, March 6, 2024, at the district bus depot in Snohomish, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Editorial: Money well spent on switch to electric school buses

With grants awarded to local school districts, a study puts a dollar figure on health, climate savings.

Editorial cartoons for Saturday, June 15

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.