Picking university leaders behind closed doors

By all accounts three of the state’s top universities have landed well-qualified and proven leaders in higher education as their new presidents.

But it’s a worrisome trend that all three — starting with Ana Mari Cauce in the fall at University of Washington, then last month Kirk Schulz at Washington State University and Sabah Randhawa at Western Washington University in Bellingham — were selected as the regents’ or trustees’ final choice at each school without announcing the names or allowing the public to meet with other candidates for the positions during the search.

The selection of Cauce in October even raised suspicions that UW’s regents had settled on Cauce privately in advance of an official meeting to make and announce their selection, which would be a violation of the state’s Open Public Meetings Act.

At the time, Toby Nixon, president of the Washington Coalition for Open Government, told the Seattle Times, “it’s absolutely clear that the decision was already made before the meeting.”

The meetings act, for which the Legislature this session increased the fines for knowing violations, requires that governing boards for public agencies, such as universities, deliberate and vote in public session.

Similar concerns were raised regarding the process used to select Schulz. Washington State University said it had a pool of eight finalists for president as it sought a successor to the late Elson Floyd. From the start, WSU’s regents had determined that they would withhold the identities of those candidates. When its regents deliberated and voted in open session, candidates were identified only by letters.

Former state auditor and open government expert Brian Sonntag said such use of “code” during a public meeting only served to keep the public in the dark.

According to WSU’s student newspaper, The Daily Evergreen, one instructor at the university’s Edward R. Murrow College of Communication, compared the process to waiting for a white puff of smoke from a Sistine Chapel flue when a new pope is selected.

Western’s selection process, according to the presidential search updates on its website, held open the possibility that more than one candidate would be brought to the Bellingham campus to meet with students and faculty.

But Western trustees instead selected Randhawa in late March and scheduled his visit this week.

Nora Selander, a Western junior studying political sciences and history, criticized the process, telling the Bellingham Herald: “I don’t know if it’s been as open as they say it has been. I would’ve really enjoyed seeing a panel of candidates here today.”

In each case, the universities’ trustees and regents have justified the closed-door process as necessary to ensure an ample pool of qualified candidates. Releasing names of candidates, the reasoning goes, could discourage applicants who wouldn’t want current employers to know they were seeking positions elsewhere.

Certainly, it could discourage some candidates. But that concern has to be weighed against the public’s right to a selection process that is open and transparent and allows insight into the qualities and talents candidates have and what trustees and regents value in a leader.

This is in the interest of the public, of course, but it’s also in the interest of the universities, their trustees and the prospective leaders. An open and transparent process, one that requires candidates to stand before the public that pays the salary for the position they seek, provides greater confidence in the person who is selected.

We expect our leaders to be able to withstand public scrutiny. That scrutiny rightly begins when he or she applies for the job.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Monday, July 22

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Scott Spahr, Generation Engineering Manager at Snohomish County PUD, points to a dial indicating 4 megawatts of power production from one of two Francis turbine units at the Henry M. Jackson Powerhouse on Friday, Feb. 17, 2023, near Sultan, Washington. Some of the water that passes through units 3 and 4 — the two Francis turbines — is diverted to Lake Chaplain, which supplies water to Everett. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Editorial: Amber King best suited for PUD’s 2nd District seat

Among three solid candidates, King’s knowledge of utilities and contracts will serve ratepayers well.

Brooks: Democrats must provide an answer to MAGA’s promises

For Democrats to succeed, they need to offer people a future of both security and progress.

Krugman: For Trump, once again, it’s carnage in America

Ignoring the clear decline in crime rates for much of the country, Trump basks in thoughts of mayhem.

Krugman: It’s not just Trump that J.D. Vance has flipped on

The GOP’s vice presidential nominee has shifted position on the white working-class folks he came from.

Comment: Blaming media a poor repsonse to political violence

Conspiracy and violent rhetoric holds no specific party identification but seeks only to distract.

Former President Donald Trump, the presumed Republican presidential nominee, speaks during a campaign event in Doral, Fla., July 9, 2024. The Biden campaign has attacked Trump’s ties to the conservative policy plan that would amass power in the executive branch, though it is not his official platform. (Scott McIntyre/The New York York Times)
Comment: Project 2025’s aim is to institutionalize Trumpism

A look at the conservative policy behind Project 2025 and the think tank that thought it up.

Vote 2024. US American presidential election 2024. Vote inscription, badge, sticker. Presidential election banner Vote 2024, poster, sign. Political election campaign symbol. Vector Illustration
Editorial: Return Wagoner and Low to 39th Disrict seats

‘Workhorse’ Republicans, both have sponsored successful solution-oriented legislation in each chamber.

A law enforcement officer surveys the Fiserv Forum in Milwaukee, the site of the Republican National Convention, on July 14, 2024. (Haiyun Jiang/The New York Times)
Editorial: Weekend’s violence should steel resolve in democracy

Leaders can lower the temperature of their rhetoric. We can choose elections over violence.

A graphic show the Port of Everett boundary expansion proposed in a ballot measure to voters in the Aug. 6 primary election. (Port of Everett).
Editorial: Case made to expand Port of Everett across county

The port’s humming economic engine should be unleashed to bring jobs, opportunity to all communities.

Editorial cartoons for Sunday, July 21

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Forum: How much do we really know about ‘bus stop people’?

Our assumptions about people, often fall short of accuracy, yet we justify our divisions based on them.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.