Plenty of blame to go around in Iran air disaster

Regarding the recent news about the accidental downing of the Ukraine airlines passenger flight, a TV consultant said that airline disasters are not generally due to single cause but to series of failures any one of which, if avoided, could have prevented the disaster. I agree with that. But in this case, the only failure noted was the error of the one who fired the missile. In fact there were many other failures, to name a couple:

1. It was known that an Iranian official had been killed. Iran was likely to retaliate in some way. Iran and Iraq could be reasonably be expected to become a war zone in short order, with lots of nervous people dropping and firing lethal objects at blips on their radar screens. Ukraine, the airline, and Iran could have suspended all civilian air traffic in the area. Didn’t happen.

2; There could have been effective communication between air defenses and the control tower at the airport. Didn’t happen.

The article ended with “The man responsible was to be court-martialed.”

We are all eager to blame the poor schmuck who was left alone in the dark to make the fatal decision. If, and only if he was given a protocol to guide his decision, and he failed to follow it, then he deserves the blame.

But he’s not the only one.

Charles DeBruler


Talk to us

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Monday, June 1

A sketchy look at the day in politics.… Continue reading

Editorial: Work ahead even if county can move to Phase 2

While easing restrictions would be welcome, there’s much to be done to get the economy going again.

Commentary: Officers’ actions in Floyd’s death not by the book

Their treatment of a suspect went against the training expected of law enforcement officers.

Commentary: It’s no longer Trump’s economy; it’s the pandemic’s

While the economy is likely to improve, it may not recover quickly enough to help Trump in November.

Don’t sign petitions against K-12 sexual health education

Please offer your strong public support to implement comprehensive sexual health education… Continue reading

Everyone should follow the advice of experts

None of us has ever been here before. Previous epidemics, with the… Continue reading

Mueller report still relevant and important

The purpose of this letter is revive a simple truth, one that… Continue reading

Editorial cartoons for Sunday, May 31

A sketchy look at the day in politics.… Continue reading

Editorial: State officials’ pay raises poorly timed

Set by a citizen panel a year ago, the raises begin just as the state needs to make deep budget cuts.

Most Read