Psychosis, not evil, led to Texas deaths

Columnist Julie Muhlstein contends that Andrea Yates’ acts of violence compare with those of Osama bin Laden and Susan Smith (“No pity for parents who kill their children,” Jan. 10). Obviously, Muhlstein has never experienced postpartum depression, let alone postpartum psychosis. What Yates did was shocking, in that a mother’s instinct is to protect her children from harm rather than to perpetrate it. Muhlstein chooses to see this as evil, rather than evidence of the frightening scope of instability and unreality experienced by a woman whose cognitive abilities were dramatically impaired.

Muhlstein asserts that she “can’t comprehend” Yates’ actions. Of course she can’t. Women who have gone through postpartum psychosis have difficulty understanding this illness themselves.

To compare Yates’ situation with Osama bin Laden’s indicates a complete lack of understanding of the true nature of evil involved, and belittles the very real condition Yates suffers.

Susan Smith murdered her children, in full control of her faculties, because they were inconvenient to her romance.

Yates feared her illness, because she alone knew the power of it. She sought help, often from mental health professionals who underestimated the magnitude of the psychosis. She feared harm might come to her children due to her illness. Nobody was listening. And, something I have heard no discussion of anywhere, she mourns her children. She couldn’t handle the pressures of her children and the hormones they brought on, but she truly loved them. That is the duality of this type of psychosis. No wonder it makes no sense to us.

Incomprehensible as they are, Yates’ actions bring up the issue of culpability. Yates’ ability to comprehend her actions will be judged by a jury of her peers. Let us hope that people like Muhlstein stay home from court.

Snohomish

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

People walk adjacent to the border with Canada at the Peace Arch in Peace Arch Historical State Park, where cars behind wait to enter Canada at the border crossing Monday, Aug. 9, 2021, in Blaine, Wash. Canada lifted its prohibition on Americans crossing the border to shop, vacation or visit, but America kept similar restrictions in place, part of a bumpy return to normalcy from coronavirus travel bans. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)
Editorial: U.S. and Canada better neighbors than housemates

President Trump may be serious about annexing Canada, but it’s a deal fraught with complexities for all.

Schwab: If you’re OK with foreign aid cuts, guess who’s next

At some point, if they haven’t already, Trump’s and Musk’s cuts will hit all but a very elite few.

Poor planning behind Snohomish PUD rate increase

It did not take long in 2025 for the Snohomish Public Utility… Continue reading

Trump’s aid cut will cost U.S. influence

The last time the U.S. pulled back its aid to other countries,… Continue reading

Musk’s financial access is a threat to personal data, payments

Recently Elon Musk along with six young men between 19-24 were able… Continue reading

Comment: Birthright citizenship has helped make America great

Trump’s attempt to end it, almost certainly unconstitutional, won’t fix the nation’s problems at its borders.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Thursday, Feb. 13

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

State single-payer health care bill offers many advantages

I was excited to read in Will Geschke’s report (“Everett lawmakers back… Continue reading

Important national story missing from Herald

I couldn’t find a report in The Herald that the Trump administration… Continue reading

Comment: Trump’s ‘Man-of-Steel’ shtick will make U.S. weaker

Trump’s 25 percent tariffs on steel and aluminum will harm allies we need and won’t help industries here.

Comment: AG Bondi’s DEI memo more messaging than lawsuit threat

Talk of criminal investigations is intended to panic corporations into abandoning their DEI programs.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.