So many soldiers in one spot – why?

With the recent losses of United States soldiers in Iraq I have some questions and some possible solutions. I question why our military leaders had so many soldiers gathered in a mess tent which by all accounts was a target and vulnerable? We send convoys of vehicles into the streets of Iraq knowing they are targets and we lose soldiers almost every day to explosions. Who orders the soldiers into these vehicles and why? Not only do President Bush and Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld owe us answers, we also deserve answers from our top military leaders in Iraq.

Any general who would place dozens of soldiers in a confined area that is a known target should not be a general and I would question how they became a general. As citizens we have every right to question these decisions because obviously the president and “Rummy” are not asking those questions.

Now, for my possible solutions. Every field grade officer in the chain of command who placed soldiers in that unprotected tent needs to be reprimanded, demoted or discharged from military service. The lives of our soldiers are too valuable for them to be squandered. I suggest a hearing before Congress in which the top commanders in Iraq explain why so many soldiers were placed in such a vulnerable position. Have not these officers heard of dispersing their soldiers? Placing dozens of soldiers in one small area invites attack. As far as protecting the convoys, if every convoy in Iraq had to have a colonel or a general placed in the most vulnerable vehicle we might see far fewer convoys and better armor for the vehicles that do travel.

Robert Zigler


Talk to us

More in Opinion

Catherine Berwicks loads ballots into a tray after scanning them at the Snohomish County Elections Ballot Processing Center on Tuesday, Aug. 4, 2020 in Everett, Wa.  (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
Editorial: Boot meaningless tax ‘advisory’ measures from ballots

The public needs better transparency on taxes; not an opaque push poll that serves no purpose.

Editorial cartoons for Thursday, Jan. 26

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Washington Future Fund
Editorial: Fund could break inequitable cycle of poverty

State version of ‘baby bonds’ would provide capital for low-income young adults’ economic success.

An alleged drunken driver hit a bicyclist and crashed into a Marysville home, killing a 97-year-old woman Saturday. (Marysville Police Department) 20200829
Editorial: Slow roll on changes to state’s police pursuit law

The new law may have resulted in a decrease in fatalities, but more data on its effects are needed.

Clyde Shavers
Editorial: Shavers should step down from House veterans panel

His false claim, before his election, of serving on a Navy sub should keep him off a veterans committee.

What other workplace safety problems has Boeing ignored?

Thank you for the very informative article on Boeing workers’ exposure to… Continue reading

Rep. Shavers should resign over false statements

The 2023 legislative session in Olympia wasn’t even two weeks old before… Continue reading

Herald delivery by mail is working for me

I was one of the complainers too. I was dreading the end… Continue reading

U.S. Mail unreliable method to deliver Herald

I’ve gotten three papers in the mail in the past week and… Continue reading

Most Read