State’s top-two primary leaving many without a voice

If you are a Republican wanting to vote in the upcoming general election for Snohomish County offices, don’t bother. There are no Republican candidates for whom to vote. That is the sad outcome of an initiative that the voters in our state approved in 2004. With this initiative, the people voted to switch our method of election so that it copied the voting system in Louisiana.

This became known as the top-two primary. It won 60 percent support in 2004, and after a few years of confusion, was confirmed by the Supreme Court. The result is that less than a quarter of registered voters decide who goes onto the general election, and if the top two vote-getters in the primary are both Democrats, so be it. Republicans are left out in the cold.

In last week’s primary, Democrat Dave Somers received a little over 31,000 votes. Democrat John Lovick received a few votes over 30,000. Republican Bob Sutherland received 25,000 votes. (These numbers are all approximate, because the final tallies have not yet been released.) Who gets on the general election ballot? Somers and Lovick. Not Sutherland, and in fact, not any Republican. And not any third party candidate, whether that person represents the libertarian party or the green party. That is how this system has boiled down voter choice. You get to choose either a Democrat or a Democrat. Keep in mind that this is a county in which eight Republicans and 10 Democrats serve in the state legislature, and in which Rob McKenna, the Republican candidate for governor, received 49 percent of the vote in Snohomish County in 2012.

It actually gets worse. In the race for Snohomish County Council Position 2, Democrat Brian Sullivan received 55 percent of the vote, and Democrat Greg Tisdal received 44 percent. There was no Republican candidate to choose, even in the primary. In Snohomish County Council District Position 3, there was only one candidate, Democrat Stephanie Wright. So there was no choice for either the primary or general elections.

So now we don’t have candidates and we don’t have voters. Seriously, why vote if you are a Republican and there is no Republican candidate on the ballot, or if you are any voter with any or no party affiliation, and there is only one candidate on the ballot?

A bigger question is how did we get here and how we reinvigorate our democracy. An election with one candidate is not an election.

One problem is the top-two primary. Washington’s secretaries of state have touted the top-two primary for more than a decade. The Secretary of State’s history of the top-two primary claimed in 2009 that, “(t)he public continues to respond positively to this form of primary.” That same history claimed in 2010 that, “Voters and candidates appreciate the focus on the candidates, not political parties.”

The actual voting statistics undermine this wishful propaganda. For example, in the last year before the top-two primary was put into effect, voter turnout for the primary exceeded 28 percent. Compare that to the less than 23 percent turnout this year. And in that pre-top-two primary year there were contested elections between Republicans and Democrats for the Snohomish County executive and the two County Council seats up for election. These contests gave voters a true choice in the primary and in the general election. This year, no such luck. The 5 percentage point difference in turnout for the primary may not seem like a lot, but it amounts to more than 22,000 voters who didn’t bother to vote, compared to 2007.

And if that trend continues, we can expect over 40,000 fewer voters participating in the November general election than did, proportionally, in 2007. So much for voter appreciation of the top-two primary system.

Now, it is not just the top-two primary to blame. Certainly, when a major party, in the case the Republicans, fail to even field a candidate for a county council seat, the message that goes out to Republican voters is “why bother.” And with third party candidates stricken from the general election ballot, the incentive to find and recruit credible candidates goes down the drain. And so, we get closer and closer to one-party and one-candidate elections. This is no way to run a democracy!

John Burbank is the executive director of the Economic Opportunity Institute, www.eoionline.org. Email him at john@eoionline.org.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Sunday, Feb. 9

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

bar graph, pie chart and diagrams isolated on white, 3d illustration
Editorial: Don’t let state’s budget numbers intimidate you

With budget discussions starting soon, a new website explains the basics of state’s budget crisis.

A young man carries water past the destroyed buildings of a neighborhood in the Gaza Strip, Feb. 2, 2025. President Donald Trump’s proposal to “own” the Gaza Strip and transfer its population elsewhere has stirred condemnation and sarcasm, but it addresses a real and serious challenge: the future of Gaza as a secure, peaceful, even prosperous place. (Saher Alghorra/The New York Times)
Comment: ‘Homeland’ means exactly that to Gazans

Palestinians have long resisted resettlement. Trump’s plan to ‘clean out’ Gaza changes nothing.

Rent stabilization can keep more from losing homes

Thank you to The Herald Editorial Board for its editorial, regarding rent… Continue reading

Don’t pamper young criminals with lenient sentences

I want to give a shout out to Todd Welch for his… Continue reading

Comment: Democracy depends on support of local journalism

A state bill provides funding to support local news outlets through a modest tax on tech businesses.

Comment: Love is intoxicating; romance doesn’t have to be

Navigating sobriety while dating, with Valentine’s Day coming up, is possible and fulfilling.

Comment: State attempt at single-payer health care bound to fail

Other states have tried, but balked when confronted with the immense cost to state taxpayers.

Curtains act as doors for a handful of classrooms at Glenwood Elementary on Monday, Sept. 9, 2024 in Lake Stevens, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Editorial: Schools’ building needs point to election reform

Construction funding requests in Arlington and Lake Stevens show need for a change to bond elections.

FILE- In this Nov. 14, 2017, file photo Jaìme Ceja operates a forklift while loading boxes of Red Delicious apples on to a trailer during his shift in an orchard in Tieton, Wash. Cherry and apple growers in Washington state are worried their exports to China will be hurt by a trade war that escalated on Monday when that country raised import duties on a $3 billion list of products. (Shawn Gust/Yakima Herald-Republic via AP, File)
Editorial: Trade war would harm state’s consumers, jobs

Trump’s threat of tariffs to win non-trade concessions complicates talks, says a state trade advocate.

A press operator grabs a Herald newspaper to check over as the papers roll off the press in March 2022 in Everett. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald file photo)
Editorial: Push back news desert with journalism support

A bill in the state Senate would tax big tech to support a hiring fund for local news outlets.

Forum: Requiem for a lost heavyweight: Sports Illustrated

SI, with Time and NatGeo, were a holy trinity for me and my dad. Now, it’s a world of AI clickbait.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.