Taking a look at the beginning, end of Earth

  • George Will / Washington Post columnist
  • Saturday, August 31, 2002 9:00pm
  • Opinion

ATOP MAUNA KEA, ON HAWAII’S BIG ISLAND — On a clear day, you can see almost forever. With the help of adaptive optics, almost back to the beginning of this universe. And it is usually clear here at 13,796 feet above sea level, and above half of the atmosphere’s oxygen. That is why the W.M. Keck Observatory’s two telescopes, primarily operated by the University of California and the California Institute of Technology, are here, far from urban lights and above much of the atmosphere which, although it makes the stars twinkle prettily, does so by distorting light.

Hence the need for adaptive optics. This technology became available for civilian science when the end of the Cold War led to the declassification of some devices developed for the Strategic Defense Initiative (SDI).

The Keck telescopes — the world’s largest — are gathering light produced shortly (as these things are reckoned; about 800 million years) after the Big Bang, just under 14 billion years ago. Analysis of the light, which can be done by astronomers working anywhere, yields information about the life cycle of stars. (Grim news: our star, the sun, is doomed, so we are too, in less than 2 billion years.) The Keck telescopes have detected more than 60 planets orbiting other stars. Ten years ago, the only planets we knew of were those orbiting our own sun.

It is axiomatic that not only is the universe stranger than we know, it is stranger than we can know. But one reason the Keck telescopes are significantly augmenting our store of knowledge is the application to astronomy of adaptive optics developed for SDI. SDI’s challenge is to target, from space, ballistic missiles launched on Earth. This requires making ultraprecise measurements from space, through the distortions of the Earth’s atmosphere. Astronomy’s challenge involves looking outward — analyzing light that is distorted by the atmosphere before it reaches telescopes on Earth.

The Keck telescopes each weigh 300 tons, stand eight stories tall and involve operations of more precision than those of the finest wristwatch. They can gather 13-billion-year-old light that is 500 million times fainter than the naked eye can see. They gather the light using a primary mirror 10 meters (33 feet) in diameter, composed of 36 hexagonal segments, each engineered to conform to within a millionth of an inch of single continuous surface.

But the really remarkable device is a mirror about the size of a man’s hand. Distortions in the gathered light are removed by bouncing the light off this mirror, which has 400 pistons operated by tiny, computer-driven motors that make adjustments in the mirror’s surface 642 times a second.

From 1609 when Galileo built a refracting telescope (a lens assisting the naked eye) until the Hubble space-based telescope was launched in 1990, the atmosphere complicated astronomy. However, Hubble, which cost more than all other telescopes in history combined, does not make Earth-based telescopes anachronistic.

Hubble and its successors — next comes the Next Generation Space Telescope — operate in the cold vacuum that is space. But a multinational consortium has proposed an Overwhelmingly Large Telescope that would gather light on Earth with 2,000 panels of mirrors in an apparatus the size of a football field. Ever-better land- and space-based telescopes will find tantalizing hints about how the expansion of the universe (actually, this universe; there may be many others) began — a Big Bang? — and whether it will continue to expand or will collapse back on itself in a Big Crunch.

In any case, Earth’s fate is not going to be pretty, so what’s the use in wondering? Because wondering is what we are for.

Mauna Kea is a dormant volcano. About 40 miles southeast of here, lava from the Kilauea volcano, boiling with heat left over from Earth’s formation 4.35 billion years ago, has recently been spilling across a highway and into the ocean. To stand a few hundred feet from the stream of lava plunging into the Pacific, amid the searing heat and sulfurous fumes, is to sense what the Keck Observatory, in its very different setting, explores — the violent impermanence that permeates the entire universe.

"We are curious people," says Keck Observatory director Frederic Chaffee matter-of-factly. "And the universe is an amazing place." The most amazing things in it are the curious creatures. They have evolved literally from stardust, becoming conscious beings capable of building — indeed, their glory is that they are, in a sense, incapable of not building — mountaintop telescopes, silhouetted against the edge of the atmosphere, searching for clues as to how all this started and how it will end.

George Will can be reached at The Washington Post Writers Group, 1150 15th St. NW, Washington, DC 20071-9200.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

Customers look at AR-15-style rifles on a mostly empty display wall at Rainier Arms Friday, April 14, 2023, in Auburn, Wash. as stock dwindles before potential legislation that would ban future sale of the weapons in the state. House Bill 1240 would ban the future sale, manufacture and import of assault-style semi-automatic weapons to Washington State and would go into immediate effect after being signed by Gov. Jay Inslee. (AP Photo/Lindsey Wasson)
Editorial: Long fight for state’s gun safety laws must continue

The state’s assault weapons ban was upheld in a state court, but more challenges remain ahead.

December 5, 2025: Season of Giving
Editorial cartoons for Saturday, Dec. 6

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Comment: Latest BP pipeline spill proves why a river’s rights matter

Had a citizen’s initiative survived a legal challenge it might have ensured BP paid full remediation.

Comment: Driving impaired at .05 BAC; law should reflect that

The state’s impaired driving law needs a lower blood alcohol limit, a senator and former sheriff says.

Comment: Federal, states’ policies starving farms in the West

Tariffs and trade disputes, coupled with state taxes and regulations are eating farm profits.

Forum: Replacing planks as we steer the ship of civilization

Theseus’ paradox brings to mind thoughts about looking backward to guide decisions about the future.

Forum: We need a better grasp of reasons for Revolutionary War

Complaints about taxation fall short of understanding why the founders sought to break from England.

Anne Sarinas, left, and Lisa Kopecki, right, sort ballots to be taken up to the election center to be processed on Nov. 3, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Editorial: States right to keep voter rolls for proper purpose

Trump DOJ’s demand for voters’ information is a threat to the integrity of elections.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Friday, Dec. 5

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

The Buzz: ‘Rage bait’ word of the year; and, the next three, too

The Oxford English Dictionary said the term has tripled in use. Good thing it’s sold in bulk.

Schwab: In the line of Hegseth’s and Trump’s unfriendly fire

While one leaves an admiral holding the second-strike bag, the other pardons a Honduran narco-felon.

Many in Congress MIA on boat strikes, military abuses

While Whidbey Island’s EA-18G squadrons and Everett’s hundreds of Navy families stand… Continue reading

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.