Thanksgiving 2000 could be the saddest in 37 years

  • David Broder / Washington Post columnist
  • Monday, November 20, 2000 9:00pm
  • Opinion

WASHINGTON — This is the strangest, saddest Thanksgiving week since 1963. I well remember how unsettling it felt to sit down to "celebrate" Thanksgiving that year, only six days after being in the motorcade in Dallas on Friday, Nov. 22, when John F. Kennedy was assassinated.

We lost a president then, but immediately acquired a new one, with Lyndon Johnson taking the oath of office from Judge Sarah Hughes aboard the same Air Force One that carried the coffin of his murdered predecessor back to Washington.

Between that dark Friday and the Thursday of Thanksgiving, the assassin, Lee Harvey Oswald, had been shot dead by Jack Ruby while a horrified nation watched on television. But after the two murders came the pageantry of Kennedy’s state funeral and the outpouring of emotion captured for all time by my colleague Mary McGrory in her reporting for the old Washington Star. By the time Johnson led the nation in Thanksgiving prayers, our grief had been expressed and simple exhaustion had brought a certain calm to the land.

This year, it is not a president but the presidency that may have been lost. The spectacle that has been unfolding in Florida may not have the shocking impact of the bulletins from Dealey Plaza and Parkland Memorial Hospital. But the loss is nonetheless palpable.

For two weeks, the key to the Oval Office has been tossed back and forth between George Bush and Al Gore and their teams of lawyers as if it were the football in the pickup game the young people play on Thanksgiving afternoon to burn off some of the extra calories they just acquired.

Whatever dignity may have been attached to their pursuit of the presidency has been stripped away. The sad thing is that the campaign itself was, if not ennobling, at least satisfying to most Americans. Despite the belittling comments from too many in the media, the voters recognized — as Andrew Kohut reported in last week’s Pew Center poll — that substantial issues affecting their lives were being discussed, and they came away thinking they had the information they needed to cast a reasoned vote.

Given that generally positive climate of opinion, the closeness of the election verdict was not in itself a threat to the legitimacy of the process or the acceptance of the eventual winner. All that was needed was an agreement between the rivals on how the tie would be broken.

But that never happened. The necessary phone call was never made. Instead, both of them immediately began deploying the unholy trinity of contemporary American politics — lawyers, campaign consultants and media advisers — and set out to win it for themselves. Meantime, the fourth horseman, the fund-raisers, sprang into action.

The result has been a double disaster. The machinery of American elections — involving the collection of votes, the vote counts, and the ballots themselves — has been shown to be less than 100 percent reliable. That does not come as a surprise to most political activists, but under the merciless media spotlight on Florida, these inevitable and usually inconsequential flaws have assumed epic proportions, causing many citizens to wonder about the basic fairness of our elections.

And the candidates for the highest office have been discerned — correctly, I am afraid — as being more interested in exploiting the gaps in the election system for their own advantage than in restoring public confidence in the fairness of the outcome.

In that relentless search for victory, good people have done really bad things. Gore supporters have charged that Florida officials who favor Bush intentionally disenfranchised people, comparing it to the abuses of the pre-civil rights era. Bush supporters have set out to blacken the reputation of local canvassing board members, accusing them of willfully invalidating votes cast by American soldiers and sailors serving overseas.

The hope expressed by many people as this is written is that the Florida Supreme Court will provide an authoritative interpretation of the confusing state election laws and a clear direction on how the final count is to be assembled and certified.

But it is not certain that even such a ruling would rescue the situation. Suggestions have been made that this court — all of whose members were appointed by past Democratic governors (though one had the concurrence of the Republican governor-elect, Jeb Bush) — cannot be trusted to be impartial. So another part of the governmental system — the judiciary — may yet be demeaned.

The cost of all this is heavy indeed, and makes this the saddest Thanksgiving in 37 years.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, July 24

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Vote 2024. US American presidential election 2024. Vote inscription, badge, sticker. Presidential election banner Vote 2024, poster, sign. Political election campaign symbol. Vector Illustration
Editorial: Elect Gallardo-Van Ornam to 10th LD House seat

The Republican and Arlington city council member has a diverse background from which she can draw.

Vote 2024. US American presidential election 2024. Vote inscription, badge, sticker. Presidential election banner Vote 2024, poster, sign. Political election campaign symbol. Vector Illustration
Editorial: Ron Muzzall’s work warrants reelection to Senate

Janet St. Clair offers key experience, but Muzzall is effective and sets an example for civil leadership.

South County Fire, Prop. 1: Renew charge for safety, resilience

South County Union Firefighters strongly urge the community to support the renewal… Continue reading

Everett, Prop. 1: City should manage costs better

It’s disappointing the Herald editorial board deemed the proposed 44 percent increase… Continue reading

Comment: Every vice presidential candidate is a DEI pick

Biden was. Pence was. Harris was. J.D. Vance was. It’s all about balancing diverse interests.

Krugman: Trump’s cynical attempt to scare Black Americans

He wants them to believe immigrants are taking their jobs. That’s not at all what the numbers show.

Editorial cartoons for Tuesday, July 23

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Help in efforts to save birds, wildlife

Since the 1970s, North America has lost 30 percent of its birds,… Continue reading

Say yes to saving lives by voting for Mukilteo EMS levy

The Mukilteo Fire Department is asking voters to renew the levy for… Continue reading

Kristof: What Biden’s decision not to run means for America

Biden’s selfless choice aids his party, secures his legacy and improves the world’s chances for normalcy.

G9ldberg: And just like that, Democrats find reason for joy

Following Biden’s decision to end his campaign and endorse his veep, Democrats are positively giddy.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.