To whom will it be accountable?

Gov. Chris Gregoire recently appointed a Higher Education Task Force. It has many laudable goals, including making higher education funding more reliable and making colleges more affordable.

But what a limited vision she has for our colleges! Of the representatives from outside education, the vast majority are CEOs or leading administrators of businesses. There are few representatives from other spheres of society and life. Is this all that we can imagine for higher education?

What might a more comprehensive task force have looked like? For starters, it might have had more leaders from Washington’s nonprofit institutions. Nonprofits are not only among the most important economic institutions in the state, they offer significant and vital social services, health care, spiritual services, art and education. Are none of these things important?

A vibrant economy is a social good, and those who produce wealth perform a public service. Yet a society is more than just money; money matters only if it permits a society to flourish by producing other goods. But who represents those other goods? There are no artists, no writers and no musicians. There are no labor leaders, no social workers. More striking, other than Everett’s mayor, there are no political leaders. There are no elected representatives, no activists, no civil servants. Americans have long believed that higher education ought to prepare the next generation of civic leaders, but this goal has no place on the governor’s task force.

When the governor refers to “accountability and performance,” it is clear to whom she wants higher education to be accountable. Not to our citizens; not to our society; not to humanity. To the bottom line. She is not interested in ensuring that Washington’s college-educated citizens are prepared to lead meaningful lives, nor that they might help make Washington a better state to live in through their creativity and philanthropy.

Instead, she wants to ensure that businesses get what they need, which implies that students should treat their education as nothing but an investment in their own private self-gain. What a narrow, sad vision for an education. What a narrow, sad vision for a society. How uninspiring, and how dangerous.

What is needed instead is a recognition that each human life and, by extension, society itself needs many things from public higher education. In the wake of Enron, the housing bubble, derivatives and the Gulf of Mexico oil spill, big business has demonstrated its moral limitations, its unwillingness to devote minds to improving society when doing so conflicts with self-interest.

A society worth living in, however, would develop its citizens’ diverse capabilities. It would boast artists of all kinds. It would boast entrepreneurs that create new wealth, and scientists who generate new ideas. It would offer citizens multiple ways to develop their talents. It would have citizens who believed, as all good patriots should, that giving back is as important as taking from.

None of these virtues is expressed by the governor’s task force. It is a board of big business, by big business, and will inevitably be for big business. Is this what democracy is about? Is this what education is for? We consistently deny ourselves an opportunity to ask these questions because we assume that they have no place. Perhaps that’s part of our problem.

Johann N. Neem is associate professor of history at Western Washington University in Bellingham.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Tuesday, Dec. 10

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

A burned out truck in Malden, Wash., Wednesday, Sept. 9, 2020, two days after a fast moving wildfire swept through the area. Nearly all of the homes and municipal buildings - including the post office and fire department - in the small town of Malden were burned to the ground. (Rajah Bose/The New York Times)
Trump: State officials planning for ‘chaos’ of second Trump term

Along with potential court challenges, the state treasurer wants to make sure federal funding isn’t held up.

Comment: Politicians and public need crash course in economics

A better understanding of inflation, global trade and families’ needs could make all the difference.

Friedman: Five quick takes on the regime change in Syria

All thoughts that the U.S. should not be involved ignore the opportunity and peril of the situation.

Stephens: Syrians also have Israel to thank for liberation

Israel’s pursuit of Iran-backed terrorists helped to weaken and isolate al-Assad from his supporters.

Comment: Lame-duck Congress can still save medication abortion

Republicans have vowed to use the Comstock Act against the pills. Congress should repeal the archaic law.

Electric Time technician Dan LaMoore adjusts a clock hand on a 1000-lb., 12-foot diameter clock constructed for a resort in Vietnam, Tuesday, March 9, 2021, in Medfield, Mass. Daylight saving time begins at 2 a.m. local time Sunday, March 14, 2021, when clocks are set ahead one hour. (AP Photo/Elise Amendola)
Editorial: Stop the clock on our twice-yearly time change

State lawmakers may debate a bill to adopt standard time permanently, ending the daylight time switch.

The Everett Public Library in Everett, Washington on Thursday, Jan. 19, 2023. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Editorial: What do you want and what are you willing to pay?

As local governments struggle to fund services with available revenue, residents have decisions ahead.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Monday, Dec. 9

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Green investments aren’t having a good year, but their focus on the bottom line still makes good financial sense.

By Mark Gongloff / Bloomberg Opinion As a concept, environmentally responsible investing… Continue reading

Comment: If you want to be a grandparent, make parenting easier

The birth rate is dropping because it’s difficult to see support for young families.

Collins: A second-rate crime warrants second-rate pardon

Biden’s pardon of his son was ill-advised, but Trump has already had some doozies of his own.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.