Wildlife kill policy should be rethought

Score one for wildlife.

Washington State Department Fish and Wildlife officials plan to reopen Banner Forest Heritage Park today, which had been closed since a Labor Day weekend bear attack.

Fish and Wildlife officers began removing baited bear traps from the park Friday. Even if the officers caught the bear over the weekend, they had made the decision to relocate it, rather than kill it, which had been the initial plan after the attack.

On Sept. 2, Anthony Blasioli was riding his mountain bike on a trail in the Kitsap County park with his two dogs. The man’s dogs were in front of him on the trail when he heard them barking. He came around a corner and was face to face with a black bear. The bear charged the man, who picked up his bike and tried to protect himself with it. The bear reached through and tore the man’s arm, face, back, neck and ear. The bear stopped the attack, the man was able to ride out, and help was called.

Blasioli is now home, after spending days in the intensive care unit. According to news reports, he’s concerned the bear hasn’t been found because he doesn’t want it to attack anyone else.

No one wants anyone else attacked by a bear, but killing one just because a man was attacked makes no sense. The man said the bear was a male, and described some markings to officials. But there is no certainty that if a bear was caught, it would be the same one that attacked Blasioli.

Black bears are timid and rarely attack. It’s logical, however, that a bear might attack when two dogs are barking at it. Killing a bear after an attack such as this one would only serve a need for revenge. There’s no evidence such a bear would then go on to carry out unprovoked attacks against humans. The bear was reacting as a bear should. There’s no defensible reason to kill a bear for acting like a bear. It was in its natural habitat, not walking down a street. The bear was likely provoked by the dogs, and probably surprised by the sudden appearance of the bike rider.

We hope for Blasioli’s full recovery, but an injured human is not reason enough to justify the “kill” policy. Better that wildlife officials would reiterate basic rules to be followed out in nature: Keep dogs leashed, or leave them home. Carry pepper spray. Make lots of noise along the trail, which will warn bears of your presence and they will steer clear. If a bear comes toward you, drop to the fetal position and play dead.

We’re glad all the black bears in the park avoided the baited bear traps. Wildlife officials need to rethink this reactionary kill policy.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

Canceled flights on a flight boards at Chicago O’Hare International Airport in Chicago, on Friday, Nov. 7, 2025. Major airports appeared to be working largely as normal on Friday morning as a wave of flight cancellations hit the U.S. (Jamie Kelter Davis/The New York Times)
Editorial: With deal or trust, Congress must restart government

With the shutdown’s pain growing with each day, both parties must find a path to reopen government.

Klein: Democrats had the upper hand. Why did they give in now?

Trump has a higher tolerance for others’ pain than Democrats do. And they made their point with voters.

Recalling the bravery of nation’s first veterans

In the year 1768 there were a lot of Americans involved with… Continue reading

Praise for both candidates in County Council race

Sam Low earned my vote for Snohomish County Council Position 5 because… Continue reading

So much ‘winning’ in Trump’s first eight months

So. Eight months into the second Trump administration, the government has been… Continue reading

Kristof: Trump’s cuts to aid killing more Christians than Jihadis do

At Trump’s insistence, the U.S. has plans to invade Nigeria. A restoration of aid would save far more lives.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Monday, Nov. 10

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Comment: If justices limit Trump’s power, it starts with tariffs

Depending on reasoning, three of the Supreme Court’s conservatives seem ready to side with its liberals.

Comment: Congress’ inaction on health care comes with human costs

If ACA subsidies expire, access to affordable health care will end for millions of Americans.

Comment: Loss of SNAP hitting vulnerable seniors especially hard

There’s nothing frugal about forcing our elders to choose between rent, medicine and food.

Comment: True conservatives need to watch alt-right fringe

Tucker Carlson’s interview with Nick Fuentes ought to raise concerns about antisemitism’s infiltration.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.