2011 NCAA men’s tourney a Monty Python farce more than anything else

On March 1, Shaka Smart burned February to cinders. He stood before his VCU Rams, took out a calendar and proceeded to violate Virginia fire code while trying to get his team to flush a bad month. What happened in the past was, figuratively and literally, a stack of ash.

In that spirit, someo

ne should start a bonfire outside Houston’s Reliant Stadium now. The Final Four will produce a tournament champion, but it won’t reveal college basketball’s best team, and it’s not close. It’s a carnival of arbitrary contenders who would happily flambe large chunks of the previous four or five months.

I love the NCAA tournament. I love the Final Four. I can’t stand this Final Four.

It’s too much a farce to be a national championship, the brackets choked with so much randomness that the tournament is almost a caricature of itself.

At its best, it is the last great gauntlet, a worthy champion typically squeezing through. At least one No. 1 seed survived into 10 of the previous 11 Final Fours, winning eight times. None of the previous 11 tournaments featured a Final Four without at least one No. 2 seed or better.

Maybe one low seed enlivens the party every now and then. No problem. The system generally works.

This? This is a Monty Python sketch.

What you want from your NCAA tournament is, obviously, a matter of interpretation and taste. CBS reports ratings are up from the 2010 tournament by 13 percent. It’s the most-watched tournament since 2005, the network says. Clearly, fans aren’t turned off by anarchy, aren’t aghast at an order of (Toby) Veal.

And that’s fine. And maybe it’s the sharpest reflection of a season with few dominant teams, if any. On the state of college basketball, Connecticut coach Jim Calhoun said Monday that “everybody can beat everybody.”

But even in a season of ordinary, some teams are super-ordinary. And an event that intends to produce a national champion — in one humble, likely grumpy and possibly batty opinion — by extension intends to brand the winner the best team in the land.

So the best team doesn’t always win. Since they began tracking these things, just one overall No. 1 seed has won the tournament. But a really, really good team with a legitimate argument for “best team” status almost always wins. Only two of the last 11 national champions landed outside the top seven in the final Associated Press pre-tournament poll.

Connecticut and Kentucky are close, coming in ranked No. 9 and No. 11, respectively. The Huskies have Kemba Walker and invigorating young talent. And the Wildcats have NBA talent and one loss, in overtime, since Feb. 12. But Kentucky also had the third-best conference record in the SEC. Connecticut finished .500 in the Big East.

One of those teams, or VCU or Butler, will win the national title. And, undoubtedly, people will watch and cheer in droves. And it will be almost impossible to argue with a straight face that the winner is the best team in the country.

It’s a blip, a malfunction in an otherwise satisfactory system. The teams in this Final Four deserve to be there, absolutely. But they deserve it because they succeeded in a specific format, not because they’re the pinnacle of what college basketball offered. It’s a less-than group for a less-than showcase.

“May the best team win,” Calhoun said, “and it doesn’t need to have pedigree attached to it.”

The best team won’t win. It might not even be close.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Sports

Baltimore Ravens defensive coordinator Mike Macdonald talks with the media after practice at Under Armour Performance Center. The Seattle Seahawks hired Macdonald on January 31, 2024. (Kevin Richardson / Tribune News Service)
Seattle Seahawks roster breakdown: One thought on Geno Smith and every position group

The next phase of Mike Macdonald’s debut season as head coach of… Continue reading

Jurrangelo Cijntje pitches 2022 MLB Draft Combine held at Petco Park on Wednesday, June 15, 2022 in San Diego, CA. Cijntje, from Mississippi State, was the Mariners’ first pick in the 2024 MLB Draft. (Nelvin C. Cepeda / The San Diego Union-Tribune)
Mariners lean on college players, pitchers with ‘power arms’ as MLB draft concludes

Seattle’s 20 selections include 19 college players and one high schooler.

Jurrangelo Cijntje pitches at the 2022 MLB Draft Combine held at Petco Park on Wednesday, June 15, 2022 in San Diego, CA. Cijntje, from Mississippi State, was the Mariners’ first pick in the 2024 MLB Draft. (Nelvin C. Cepeda / The San Diego Union-Tribune)
Mariners go college route on second day of draft, take 2-way player Grant Knipp

Seattle chose youth and selected eight college players.

Tyler Cronk performs in the slam dunk competition during the Everett 3on3 tournament in downtown Everett, Washington on Sunday, July 14, 2024. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Recap, videos and photos: 2024 Everett 3on3 was another slam dunk

Everett alumni place second; skills contests, food trucks and vendors were also in full swing this past weekend to celebrate the basketball tournament’s third edition.

View of T-Mobile Park from the Press Club. Ben Ray / The Reporter
T-Mobile Park at 25: Mariners fans share favorite ballpark memories

The venue turned a quarter of a century on Monday

Kamiak High School’s Victor Sanchez Hernandez Jr. puts on a University of Washington football helmet. Sanchez Hernandez, a three-star defensive end who’s heading into his senior season, committed to the Huskies. (Photo courtesy of Victory Sanchez Hernandez Jr.)
High school football recruiting: Here’s how Washington’s 2025, 2026 classes are shaping up

TNT sports reporter Jon Manley spoke with national recruiting editor Brandon Huffman.

From left to right: Arlington’s Kierra Reese and Stanwood’s Ellalee Wortham, Ava DePew and Presley Harris. The foursome, called “Awesome Mix 12,” won the High School Elite division in 2023 and returned to Spokane Hoopfest this year to claim the Women’s Competitive division title. (Photo courtesy Sarah Reese)
Winter Wesco rivals, summer hoopfest champions

Arlington’s Kierra Reese and Stanwood’s Ava DePew, Presley Harris and Ellalee Wortham teamed up to win back-to-back 3-on-3 titles.

Louisville guard Hailey Van Lith found little room between South Carolinas Destiny Littleton (11) and Laeticia Amihere. (Carlos Gonzalez / Star Tribune)
These Olympians in the 2024 Paris Games have ties to Washington state

Nineteen athletes competing in France are from The Evergreen State.

Once an MLB bust, Mill Creek’s Travis Snider now hopes to change toxic culture

When Snider made it to the big leagues in 2008 at just 20 he was one of the game’s top prospects, touted as the Blue Jays’ next great hitter.

UW Husky rowing will be well-represented in Paris at 2024 Olympics

The U.S. eight competes in heat racing on July 29 with finals on Aug. 3.

Golden Knights center Chandler Stephenson (20) skates with the puck during the third period of an NHL hockey game against the Flames at T-Mobile Arena on Saturday, Jan. 13, 2024, in Las Vegas. (Ellen Schmidt / Las Vegas Review-Journal)
Chandler Stephenson’s deal about broader Kraken goals rather than dollar value

The former Golden Knights centerman signed a seven-year deal for $6.25 million with Seattle last week.

Seattle Mariners catcher Cal Raleigh (29) celebrates his two-run home run with a trident as he high fives teammates during the first inning against the Texas Rangers on Tuesday, April 23, 2024, in Arlington, Texas. (Elías Valverde II / Tribune News Service)
Statistics show just how terrible Mariners’ offense has been | Analysis

Seattle leads the AL West, but situational hitting has been a setback.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.