Brady better than Joe Cool?

Memo to Joe Montana fans: There are some rules of etiquette, if and when it becomes necessary to pass the Greatest Quarterback Ever torch to the fans of Tom Brady.

n Never pass the torch lit-end first.

n Never pass it by hurling the torch into the recipient’s beer pitcher, nacho platter or automobile fuel tank.

These are emotional and trying times for FOJ (Fans o’ Joe). Brady and his Patriots are favored to win the Super Bowl, which would make Brady 4-for-4 in the biggest game, the same as Montana.

That would cause talk. Discussion. Debate. Forgetting about the New England area, the rest of the football world will be giving serious consideration to proclaiming Brady the best ever.

Not that Montana owns the official title. Put it to a vote and you would get plenty of action on Johnny Unitas, Roger Staubach, Troy Aikman, Terry Bradshaw (the only other member of the 4-for-4 Super Bowl club), Bart Starr, Sammy Baugh and, you bet, Steve Young.

But it’s going to come down to Joe vs. Tom, isn’t it?

Let’s look at some of the similarities:

n Both starred at Midwestern colleges (Montana at Notre Dame, Brady at Michigan) after working their way up the depth charts.

n Montana was drafted in the third round, the No. 82 pick overall; Brady was a sixth-round pick, No. 199.

n Both played for coaches named Bill who were accused of cheating. Bill Belichick admitted video spying on opponents. Everyone knows Bill Walsh was way over the IQ cap.

n Both are Bay Area guys. Joe was adopted by 49ers fans, and still lives in the neighborhood; Brady went to Serra High in San Mateo, Calif.

n Both played for teams that enjoyed an unfair edge. The 49ers had an owner willing to spend any amount to stock a deep team. Steve Young as your backup? The Patriots outsmart and outspend most teams. See: offseason pick-ups Randy Moss, Wes Welker, Adalius Thomas!

(This has to kill Joe’s backers: The Patriots will have the 49ers’ top draft pick this year, in return for a Patriots’ pick last year, No. 28 overall, which the 49ers used to draft Joe Staley. So Montana’s team has given Brady’s team a huge boost.)

n Both survived bumpy romances. When Montana and his first wife divorced, she wrote a book. Ouch. When Brady took up with a new girlfriend, his lovely parting gift from his former girlfriend was a son. Awkward. Both men rebounded well, each winding up with a woman from the entertainment world, neither of whom is likely to be described as “plain.”

n Both play their best under pressure. They become calm, easy-going, almost nonchalant. Must be very disconcerting to opposing players.

But there are differences between the two, and soon the debate will begin.

Pro Joes: What about Brady’s three interceptions against the Chargers?

Pro Toms: What about Brady’s record 10 consecutive postseason wins?

Stats will be hurled back and forth like cream pies. Brady will have won his fourth Super Bowl at age 30, while Montana won his fourth at 33. Brady quarterbacked his 100th NFL victory in 126 tries; it took Montana 142 games to get his 100th win.

Montana’s Super Bowl stats are brain boggling. So is Brady’s recent 26-for-28 playoff performance against Jacksonville, with two drops.

The debate will start with stats, but the real fighting (verbal, one hopes) will take place at a higher level, where stats are the crutch of the small-minded, where we get beyond the Hillary versus Barack yammering and enter a grander sphere.

We start talking about presence, leadership, aura and mystical gifts.

This is where discussions break out over facial expressions, over presence. (The Brady bunch takes a hit here if the Patriots get gunned down in Arizona by deer-in-the-headlights Eli Manning.)

It’s Thor versus Zeus.

Zeus, of Greek mythology, was the sender of thunder, lightning, wind and rain. Thor was the Norse and German god of thunder, and he swung a mean mjolnir (short-handled hammer).

This is where you get the big question: If it all came down to one game, which guy would be your quarterback?

I’m not saying Montana will be voted off his throne by consensus, should the Patriots win. I’m just saying there will be a battle.

Historically in these debates, the player who gets to hurl the most recent thunderbolt tends to have the advantage. See: Michael Jordan as Greatest Ever over Magic Johnson, Julius Erving, Bill Russell, etc.

But if there’s one thing Montana taught his followers, it’s that you never give up. You stay cool.

Or as Montana once reminded his troops late in a tight Super Bowl: “Hey, isn’t that John Candy?”

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Sports

Glacier Peak freshman Aliyah Jazmin (right) positions herself in front of Shorewood junior Karmin Kasberg during the Grizzlies' 77-46 win against the Stormrays at Glacier Peak High School on Dec. 9, 2025. (Joe Pohoryles / The Herald)
Glacier Peak girls basketball rolls past Shorewood

The new-look Grizzlies remain undefeated with 77-46 win on Tuesday.

Shorewood’s Maya Glasser reaches up to try and block a layup by Shorecrest’s Anna Usitalo during the 3A district playoff game on Friday, Feb. 14, 2025 in Shoreline, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Shorecrest girls pick up first win in nailbiter

Anna Usitalo’s 24 points paced the Scots on the road.

Shorewood outlasts Jackson in tight meet

Prep boys wrestling roundup for Tuesday, Dec. 9: (Note for coaches/scorekeepers: To… Continue reading

Kamiak and Shorecrest sweep multi-team meets

Prep boys swimming roundup for Tuesday, Dec. 9: (Note for coaches/scorekeepers: To… Continue reading

Seahawks center Jalen Sundell (61) blocks for running back Kenneth Walker III in a game against the Arizona Cardinals on Sunday, Nov. 9, 2025 at Lumen Field in Seattle, Washington. (Photo courtesy of the Seattle Seahawks)
Jalen Sundell returns to Seahawks practice, position unclear

Jalen Sundell is returning. To play what position? Coach Mike Macdonald said… Continue reading

Vote for The Herald’s Prep Athlete of the Week for Nov. 30 – Dec. 6

The Athlete of the Week nominees for Nov. 30-Dec. 6. Voting closes… Continue reading

Seattle Seahawks receiver Jaxon Smith-Njigba scores a touchdown against the Atlanta Falcons at Mercedes-Benz Stadium on Sunday, Dec. 7, 2025. (Photo courtesy of the Seattle Seahawks)
Soaring Seahawks eye NFC’s top playoff seed

At 10-3, the Seattle Seahawks are practically a lock to be one… Continue reading

Michael Rangel-Smathers pours in 36 for Marysville Pilchuck

The Tomahawks put the clamps on crosstown-rival Marysville Getchell in 67-41 win Monday.

Jackson forward Avery Cooke’s double-double dooms Monroe

Senior Mya Mercille’s 24 points stand out in Bearcats’ 55-45 loss on Monday

Harry Ford of the Seattle Mariners poses for a portrait during photo day at the Peoria Sports Complex on Feb. 20, 2025, in Peoria, Arizona. (Steph Chambers/Getty Images/TNS)
Former AquaSox catcher was ‘pretty sad’ to get traded.

Opportunity awaits with the Nationals without Big Dumper blocking Harry Ford’s MLB path.

Brandon Montour (62) of the Seattle Kraken reacts as Marcus Johansson (90) of the Minnesota Wild celebrates his goal with Matt Boldy (12) of the Minnesota Wild during the third period at Climate Pledge Arena on December 08, 2025 in Seattle, Washington. (Steph Chambers / Getty Images / The Athletic)
Late goal hands Kraken sixth straight loss

The big hit on Mats Zuccarello in the first period… Continue reading

Archbishop Murphy’s EJ Manning yells after winning the 2A state championship game against Tumwater at Husky Stadium on Saturday, Dec. 6, 2025 in Seattle, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Archbishop Murphy football wins first state title since 2016

The No. 1 Wildcats take down No. 2 Tumwater 35-20 for their fourth state title on Saturday night.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.