Checking in with the latest in the CHL minimum wage lawsuit

I suspect many of you have heard at least some rumblings of the civil suit involving the WHL, OHL and CHL that was in court last week in Calgary where nearly 400 former players are looking to certify the suit as a class action suit that seeks to pay players minimum wage among other benefits associated with being employees rather than amateur student-athletes.

The last time I referenced the ongoing lawsuit on the blog was back in December (it’s at the bottom of the post) and I touched on it briefly with Andy Eide on our “ThunderTips” podcast. I haven’t written anything about it this week because I wanted to make sure I had a solid grasp on all many facets of the suit before I posted anything. I have no background in the labor laws that govern teams in five states and at least five provinces (so far the QMJHL isn’t part of the suit) in two different countries. Suffice to say I’m certainly no expert, so what I’ll try to do here is summarize what’s happened so far and link to as many different sources as I can for your perusal.

First, some background: you might recall that Washington state in 2015 determined that CHL players competing for the four Washington teams were, in fact, amateur student-athletes and therefore not subject to minimum wage laws. Then last February the British Columbia government somewhat covertly did the same thing that you can also read about here. This is all due to a lawsuit originally filed in Calgary and Toronto back in October of 2014.

At the end of October 2016, a judge in Calgary ordered the WHL, OHL and CHL to hand over their books and financial records to determine if any or all of the teams are profitable. Remember, the CHL has balked at paying minimum wage saying it would bankrupt a number of smaller-market franchises.

In January the first analysis of the teams’ financial records by KMPG indicated that less than half the WHL/OHL teams operated at a profit and that only a handful of teams turned a significant profit. More importantly, the team names were not specified leaving speculation as to which teams were actually profitable.

However, during last week’s certification hearing the judge ordered the financial statements and tax returns unsealed in addition to a player development contract between the NHL and WHL. Lawyers for the players then were allowed to hand out two reports that differed from KPMG, as Rick Westhead of TSN reported. (Be sure to read Westhead’s story. He’s been the best source I’ve found so far on this issue).

There are now some questions about various fees paid to team employees (not the players) and how teams that are consistently shown to operate at a loss still sell for millions of dollars. Meanwhile, over at Sportsnet Gare Joyce had this analysis piece in which he references a lengthy enterprise story he wrote several weeks ago about this situation.

Finally, colleague Brandon Rivers of Dub Network posted this Q&A with the parent of a WHL player offering a different perspective. It’s anonymous, but still worth a read.

So there you have it. I posted a lot of links with a lot to read through, but hopefully this should give you a pretty good idea of what’s going on. If the court allows the class action and ultimately sides with the players it could mean a major shift in Canadian junior hockey. As I said at the beginning I’m certainly no expert so feel free to email me or tweet at me if you feel like I missed something important. I’ll be continuing to closely monitor developments in this case and posting when appropriate.

For the latest Silvertips news follow Jesse Geleynse on Twitter.

Talk to us

More in Sports

Cascade’s Aidan Kopra and Stanwood’s Gary Grisham wrestle for a loose ball during a game Thursday, Dec. 8, 2022, at Cascade High School in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
GALLERY: Big 4th quarter lifts Stanwood boys over Cascade

The Spartans outscore the Bruins 33-18 in the final quarter to rally for a 64-54 win.

X
Prep roundup for Thursday, Dec. 8

Prep roundup for Thursday, Dec. 8: (Note for coaches/scorekeepers: To report results… Continue reading

X
Vote for The Herald’s Prep Athlete of the Week for Nov. 28-Dec. 4

The Athlete of the Week nominees for Nov. 28-Dec. 4. Voting closes… Continue reading

Washington guard Jamal Bey drives with the basketball against Colorado guard Luke O'Brien during the first half of an NCAA college basketball game, Sunday, Dec. 4, 2022, in Seattle. (AP Photo/Caean Couto)
Washington, Gonzaga set to meet for first time since 2018

UW travels to face No. 18 Gonzaga on Friday night. It will be the Bulldogs’ first game against a state foe in two years.

FILE - Washington head coach Kalen DeBoer paces the sideline during the first half of an NCAA college football game against Arizona State in Tempe, Ariz., Saturday, Oct. 8, 2022. DeBoer earned AP All-Pac-12 coach of the year honors on Thursday, Dec. 8. (AP Photo/Ross D. Franklin, File)
UW’s DeBoer named AP Pac-12 Coach of the Year

Six Huskies and one Cougar are named to either the first or second All-Pac-12 teams.

Seattle Seahawks running back Tony Jones Jr. runs with the ball during the second half of an NFL football game against the Los Angeles Rams Sunday, Dec. 4, 2022, in Inglewood, Calif. (AP Photo/Marcio Jose Sanchez)
Seahawks backfield depth getting tested entering stretch run

Tony Jones Jr., claimed off waivers in October, could play a key role for the team over the next couple of games.

Kaitlin Hawayek and Jean-Luc Baker of USA perform during the ice dance free dance of the ISU figure skating Grand Prix Espoo 2022 competition in Espoo, Finland, Saturday, Nov. 26, 2022. Hawayek and Baker came second in the event.  (Mikko Stig/Lehtikuva via AP)
Community roundup: Baker qualifies for Grand Prix Final

Plus, Meadowdale grad Rover Stewart is named the NWAC Athlete of the Year, Aussie football is coming to Lake Stevens and more.

Seattle Mariners players including, from left, Cal Raleigh, Paul Sewald, J.P. Crawford, Eugenio Suarez and Adam Frazier celebrate after a baseball game against the Chicago White Sox, Tuesday, Sept. 6, 2022, in Seattle. The Mariners won 3-0. (AP Photo/Stephen Brashear)
Have the Mariners done enough to keep pace in the rugged AL West?

Seattle has a wide gap to close if it wants to catch the Astros. Meanwhile, the Rangers and Angels are bolstering their rosters.

Seattle Seahawks wide receiver Tyler Lockett (16) runs with the ball as Los Angeles Rams safety Nick Scott defends during the second half of an NFL football game Sunday, Dec. 4, 2022, in Inglewood, Calif. (AP Photo/Marcio Jose Sanchez)
Seahawks WR Lockett moves up team record books

The consistent veteran is now third in all-time receptions and second in receiving TDs.

Most Read