Hall-of-Fame voter says Edgar Martinez worthy of induction

Hall-of-Fame voter says Edgar Martinez worthy of induction

The Mariner great is one of 10 players ex-Herald baseball writer Kirby Arnold voted for this year

When it comes to the subject of Edgar Martinez, Kirby Arnold is as knowledgeable as anyone.

Arnold was The Herald’s Seattle Mariners beat writer from 1999-2011, meaning he had the privilege of watching Edgar Martinez swing the bat on a daily basis right up until Martinez retired in 2004. He saw Martinez lead the American League with a .447 on-base percentage in 1999, win the league’s RBI crown in 2000 with 145, and play a central role in the Mariners winning a record-tying 116 regular-season games in 2001.

Arnold also has a say in who gets into the Baseball Hall of Fame. As a member of the Baseball Writers Association of America (BBWAA), Arnold has been a Hall of Fame voter since he became eligible in 2009. The BBWAA allows a 10-year grace period after a writer is no longer actively covering a team, meaning Arnold has continued to vote even though he’s retired from being a full-time baseball reporter.

So with the BBWAA set to announce the results of this year’s Hall of Fame voting on Wednesday, what’s Arnold’s judgment on Martinez’s credentials? It’s a no-doubter: Edgar belongs in.

Arnold was among the first of the 400-plus eligible voters to make his Hall of Fame ballot public this year, and Martinez’s name was one of the first he checked — just as it has been in all nine years Edgar has been on the ballot.

“To me, he was the best right-handed hitter I’ve ever seen with my own two eyes,” Arnold said in a phone conversation from his winter home in Arizona. “I was very lucky to cover him on a daily basis during the best parts of his career. To see how he went about hitting was phenomenal.”

Martinez, more than any other player, is straddling the line of whether he’ll achieve election this year. Ryan Thibodaux runs a Twitter account dedicated to tracking Baseball Hall of Fame voting, and of the 202 ballots (about 48 percent of the estimated total) made public through Monday morning, Martinez was named on 79.7 percent of them. The threshold for achieving enshrinement is 75 percent, meaning so far Edgar is in.

However, those who follow Hall of Fame voting trends say voters who are more selective tend to reveal their ballots later in the process. Therefore, most projections have Martinez right at the cutoff point, meaning it could go either way.

Arnold has strong feelings about which side of that line Martinez belongs on.

“If you look at Edgar Martinez, he compares favorably with some of the best ever to play the game,” Arnold said. “I look at WAR (wins above replacement), I look at Jay Jaffe’s JAWS Report and give a lot of legitimacy to his numbers. The big argument against Edgar getting into the Hall of Fame is that he was only a DH and some voters hold that against him. But Jay Jaffe looked into the numbers, and WAR is a stat that to a great degree penalizes a player for not playing in the field. Yet Edgar’s numbers are so good that he’s easily up there with players in the Hall of Fame.”

One might argue that Arnold’s views are slanted by his proximity to Martinez’s career. But Arnold’s support of Martinez is consistent with his overall views about who belongs in the Hall of Fame.

First, Arnold is a large-Hall proponent. There is a contingent of writers who are small-Hall voters, believing it should be extremely difficult to get into the Hall of Fame. Writers are allowed to vote for a maximum of 10 players each year — there were 33 names on this year’s ballot — but are not required to use all 10 of their votes. Small-Hall voters often limit their vote to four or five players. Arnold has the opposing view, checking 10 boxes each time he’s voted, and in a large-Hall view Edgar belongs.

Arnold is also a staunch believer in taking character into account. The BBWAA’s election rules state: “Voting shall be based upon the player’s record, playing ability, integrity, sportsmanship, character and contributions to the team(s) on which the player played.” Therefore, Arnold does not vote for players for whom there is evidence of using performance-enhancing drugs, such as Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens. Both Bonds and Clemens have seen their vote totals gradually increase as perspective of their worthiness changes.

“I still always maintain that those guys knew what they were doing, they knew they were cheating if nothing else the spirit of the game,” Arnold said. “I’ve talked to a few guys who used steroids and they said they felt they had to do it for competitive reasons and knew it could affect their legacy down the road, and that was a chance they were willing to take.

“But when you factor in character, sportsmanship, integrity, Edgar checks all of those boxes as well as anybody. He’s one of the best guys I’ve ever seen in a clubhouse.”

Will Martinez make it this year?

“I don’t know,” Arnold said. “But a lot more people have come around this year who didn’t vote for Edgar in the past. I wouldn’t be surprised if he doesn’t make it this year, but he’ll probably make it next year if he doesn’t this year. Anyone who supports Edgar has to be pleased with the numbers this year.”

And come Wednesday, those Martinez supporters may have more to celebrate than just an increased vote total.

Follow Nick Patterson on Twitter at @NickHPatterson.

Talk to us

More in Sports

The Silvertips' Koen Macinnes stops a shot during a game against the Blazers on Saturday, Feb. 12, 2022, at Angel of the Winds Arena in Everett. (Kristin Ostrowski / Everett Silvertips)
Tips trade netminder, add 11 players through drafts

Everett sent Koen MacInnes to Regina for picks. Forward Julien Maze headlines the draft haul.

White line on Green grass sport field for sport concept
Prep results for Thursday, May 19

Postseason prep results for Thursday, May 19: (Note for coaches/Scorekeepers: To report… Continue reading

Marysville-Getchell celebrates their 8-1 victory over Everett High School at Phil Johnson Ball Field in Everett, Washington on May 19, 2022.(Kevin Clark / The Herald)
3A district softball: M. Getchell, Arlington, Monroe advance to state

Marysville Getchell earns its 1st state berth in program history. Arlington and Monroe also punch their tickets.

Snohomish's Evalyn Messina holds the championship trophy Thursday evening at Phil Johnson Ball Field in Everett, Washington on May 19, 2022. The Bruins defeated the Panthers 14-7 to claim the NW District 1 3A Championship title. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Another milestone: Cascade softball rolls past Snohomish for district crown

The Bruins continue their breakthrough season and blast 7 homers to beat the Panthers 14-7 in the 3A District 1 title game.

Boston Red Sox's Trevor Story is congratulated after his second two-run home run of the night, during the third inning of the team's baseball game against the Seattle Mariners at Fenway Park, Thursday, May 19, 2022, in Boston. (AP Photo/Charles Krupa)
Story hits 3 homers, Red Sox power past M’s

Seattle’s pitchers struggle in a 12-6 loss at Fenway Park.

Pro skateboarding competition coming to Everett in August

Street League Skateboarding’s championship tour will be at Angel of the Winds arena for two days.

Skyline’s Ryan Grace is swarmed by teammates after striking out a batter to complete a 10-inning complete game win against Jackson Wednesday, May 18, 2022, during a Class 4A matchup at the Phil Johnson Ballfields in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Jackson softball falls to Skyline in 10-inning bi-district marathon

The T-wolves lose a 3-2 extra-inning heartbreaker in the 4A District 1/2 semis, but still have 2 more chances to reach state.

Bonney Lake's James O'Callaghan stands dejected as Edmonds-Woodway's Victor Ibarra, far right, celebrates Edgar Cabrera’s goal in the second half Tuesday evening at Edmonds-Woodway High School in Edmonds, Washington on May 17, 2022. The Warriors won 3-1. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Edmonds-Woodway advances to state soccer round of 16

Forced into a 3A state play-in game, the Warriors put on a clinic in a 3-1 win over Bonney Lake.

White line on Green grass sport field for sport concept
Prep results for Wednesday, May 18

Prep results for Wednesday, May 18: (Note for coaches/Scorekeepers: To report results… Continue reading

Most Read