On Russell Wilson, fake punts, and the 49ers-Pats buzzkill

There was plenty to like about the Seahawks’ 50-17 win over Buffalo, which gave the Seahawks a second 50-point game in as many weekends, a first since 1950.

From Marshawn Lynch going over 100 yards while averaging better than 11 yards per carry for the second straight week, to the defense playing takeaway, starting with K.J. Wright’s big, momentum changing interception to Earl Thomas’ interception that he returned 57 yards (running about 150)—and how in the world was that Earl Thomas’ first career touchdown? The guy is a pick-six waiting to happen—to the strong play of unproven cornerbacks Jeremy Lane and Byron Maxwell, who more than held their own filling in for corners missing from action because of injuries and suspension.

But as has been the case quite often in the second half of the season, the biggest reason why the Seahawks were victorious Sunday was the play of rookie quarterback Russell Wilson, who passed for 205 yards and a touchdown, and rushed for a Seahawks quarterback-record 92 yards and three scores. Last week, the Seahawks somehow managed to scored 58 points while having their quarterback be something of an afterthought—that’s how bad Arizona was a week ago—but this time Wilson was in charge. It’s easy to forget now that Seattle’s day started with Wilson getting sacked, but he followed that by completing all four attempts on the drive, including passes to Sidney Rice and Zach Miller that allowed Seattle to convert twice on third-and-seven. The drive ended with Wilson scoring on a 14-yard run. Wilson’s first rushing TD of the year, and the first of three he would finish with that day, came on a zone-read option play, a weapon that has become more and more a part of Seattle’s offense as the season has gone on. And one encouraging element of Wilson’s rushing success is that he’s doing it without taking a lot of hits. The biggest concern with having a running quarterback is the risk of injury (just ask Washington, which played without Robert Griffin III Sunday because of a knee injury suffered while running last week), but while rushing for 92 yards, Wilson took remarkably little contact by sliding, by getting out of bounds, or by getting into the end zone.

So just how good was Wilson’s day? Well he had a passer rating of 104.4, which is pretty darn good, but that doesn’t fully tell the story of his day because of how dangerous he was running the ball.

According to ESPN’s QBR, which tries to paint a more complete picture of a quarterback’s performance, Wilson was not just good, he was for a day anyway, the best quarterback the NFL has seen this season. First, here’s how ESPN describes QB:

Total QBR is a quarterback rating that takes into account all of a QB’s significant contributions (passing, rushing, sacks, fumbles, penalties) to his team’s scoring and winning and summarizes them into one number on a 0-100 scale, where 50 is average. Since 2008, the team with the higher QBR has won 86 percent of the time.

And Wilson’s QBR on that 0-100 scale was a gaudy 99.3. That’s the best total QBR in a single game this season, and this wasn’t just one isolated impressive performance for Wilson. Since Week 8, Wilson’s QBR of 87.9 is the best in the league in that span.

So yeah, the rookie is playing some pretty darn good football these days.

One big play that the Seahawks had Sunday, however, might have been a bit regrettable. With a 30-point lead in the fourth quarter, the Seahawks used a fake punt to pick up a first down. Last week, the Seahawks were accused by some of running up the score against Arizona. I defended their play-calling, as did many others. And while it is fair to say that there is nothing wrong with keeping your foot on the gas at the NLF level, regardless of the score, a fake punt in that situation is a little hard to defend.

That’s probably why Carroll didn’t try to defend it after the game. Instead he explained that they had an automatic fake call in their game plan if the Bills showed a certain look that the Seahawks had seen while studying film during the week. That finally happened in the fourth quarter, and

“It was something I could have called off and I didn’t,” Carroll told reporters. “… I should have stopped it in the sense that it looked bad.”

Ultimately, I don’t have a big problem with an NFL team staying aggressive with big lead. Just look at what happened in New England last night when the Patriots quickly erased a 28-point lead in the second half. That being said, teams do have to live with the consequences. If the Seahawks find themselves down on their luck in a couple of years and teams run it up on them, they’ll have no grounds to complain. If a key player gets hurt in the fourth quarter with the game already out of reach, Carroll would have to answer for that. Or if a frustrated opponent takes a cheap shot, the Seahawks shouldn’t be too surprised.

Then again, how crazy is it that we’re even having this conversation two weeks in a row? For most of this season, the Seahawks were playing games that went down to the last possession week after week. Now we’re asking if they’re being bullies two weeks in a row? Strange.

And as impressive as Seattle’s win was, Sunday wasn’t quite a perfect for the Seahawks. For that, they needed some help from the Patriots, who have been almost unbeatable at home this time of year under Bill Belichick. I say almost, because the Patriots finally lost a December home game when the Seahawks so badly needed some help. Has New England beaten the 49ers, the Seahawks would be hosting San Francisco with a chance to take over the NFC West lead. Instead, the Seahawks’ only hope of winning the division is that they win out and the 49ers lose their final game against the dreadful Arizona Cardinals.

Yet even if a division title is now unlikely, the Seahawks are in good shape to make the playoffs. One more win in its next two games gets Seattle into the postseason, and as recent playoff history has shown us, being hot going into the playoffs is more important than seeding (the past two Super Bowl winners, the Giants and Packers, were both Wild Card teams). So even if the Seahawks don’t win the West, that doesn’t mean fans can’t dream big.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Sports

X
Prep roundup for Monday, Dec. 2

Snohomish, Jackson, Kamiak girls hoops teams open with wins.

Archbishop Murphy’s Jevin Madison runs the ball while having his jersey pulled during the 2A semifinal game against Tumwater on Saturday, Nov. 30, 2024 in Tumwater, Washington.  (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Archbishop Murphy’s run ends in state football semifinal

The Wildcats fall 42-0 to No. 1 Tumwater

Seahawks defensive end Leonard Williams celebrates after his 92-yard pick-6 in Seattle’s 26-16 win over the New York Jets at MetLife Stadium on Dec. 1, 2024. (Photo courtesy of Edwin Hooper / Seattle Seahawks)
Seahawks win ‘crazy game’ in New York

Seattle owns sole possession of first place in the NFC West with a road win over the Jets.

Wyoming scores late to upset Cougars in regular-season finale

WSU loses third straight, awaits bowl game destination.

Ryan Nembhard’s passing highlights Gonzaga’s Bahamas trip

Bulldogs point guard dishes out Thirty-nine total assists to set Battle 4 Atlantis record.

New York Jets quarterback Aaron Rodgers (8) and offensive tackle Carter Warren (67) leave the field after the Jets lost to the Seattle Seahawks, 26-21, Sunday, Dec. 1, 2024, in East Rutherford, N.J. (Andrew Mill / Tribune News Services)
Rodgers looks his age in loss to Seattle

Jets quarterback may have played his worst game for New York.

Archbishop Murphy senior Jevin Madison, who has rushed for 1,668 yards this season, at football practice on Wednesday, Nov. 27, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Archbishop Murphy gets its football groove back

Coach Joe Cronin, running back Jevin Madison lead the Wildcats’ resurgence.

Seahawks defensive end Leonard Williams (99) celebrates during a stop of the Arizona Cardinals at Lumen Field on Nov. 24, 2024 (Photo courtesy of Rod Mar / Seattle Seahawks)
Leonard Williams ‘dominant’ play stems from Seahawks changes

Coach Mike Macdonald giving teams different looks opened the door for the defensive end.

Kimberly Beard, the top-ranked high school hammer thrower in the country, prepares to release during a track and field event. (Photo courtesy of Donna Beard)
Mukilteo’s Kimberly Beard ranked as best prep hammer thrower

The King’s High School junior’s mark of 186 feet, 6 inches topped all competitors in U.S.

Washington Huskies running back Jonah Coleman runs away from the Weber State defense at Husky Stadium on August 31,2024. (Photography Courtesy of Scott Eklund / Red Box Pictures / Washington Athletics)
Jonah Coleman announces he will return to UW

The star running back has rushed for more than 1,000 yards this season for the Huskies.

Lake Stevens’ Laura Eichert leaps in the air to hit the ball during the 4A district semifinal game on Thursday, Nov. 14, 2024 in Lynnwood, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Lake Stevens’ Laura Eichert named state volleyball tournament MVP

The junior outside hitter led the Vikings to the Class 4A state semifinals.

Amid WSU defense’s struggles, offense has done it part

Cougs quarterback John Mateer has been unable to overcome defense’s shortcomings.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.