Seahawks head coach Pete Carroll has a 112-63-1 record in his 11 years in Seattle. ( Ted S. Warren / Associated Press)

Seahawks head coach Pete Carroll has a 112-63-1 record in his 11 years in Seattle. ( Ted S. Warren / Associated Press)

Pete Carroll should stay — and reexamine the way he does things

It’s time for the highly successful Seahawks coach to re-evaluate what’s best for the team.

During his end-of-season press conference, Seattle Seahawks coach Pete Carroll uttered words that drew a collective groan from the fan base.

“We have to run the ball better. Not even better, we have to run it more.”

Cue the avalanche of furious and indignant tweets declaring Carroll an out-of-touch dinosaur.

With the NFL becoming more of a passing league every year, with the analytics crowd shouting that the numbers say teams should favor the pass over the run, and with Seahawks quarterback Russell Wilson providing a taste of what’s possible when he’s allowed to cook, Carroll’s words were the last ones a large and loud portion of the fan base wanted to hear.

Even Carroll acknowledged that: “We have to dictate what’s going on with the people that we’re playing, and (running the ball is) one of the ways to do that. And I know the fans aren’t really jacked about hearing that.”

For some this was the final straw. It’s time for the Seahawks to dump Carroll in favor of a more progressive coach, they say. Thanks for your service Pete, but it’s time to go.

To those who feel that way I have one thing to say: Please stop. But I would also tell Carroll it’s time for some serious introspection.

First off, firing Carroll is a terrible idea. In his 11 years as Seattle’s head coach Carroll has a 112-63-1 record, five division titles, nine playoff qualifications, two Super Bowl appearances and one Super Bowl win. His winning percentage with the the Seahawks (.639) is better than the career winning percentages of Hall of Fame coaches like Bill Walsh, Joe Gibbs and Bill Cowher.

Carroll’s done so well that I think the fans forgot Seattle doesn’t have some inalienable right to be a winning franchise. Carroll’s accomplishments in 11 years are equal to the previous 34 seasons combined, when the Seahawks won six division titles, made the playoffs 10 times and had one Super Bowl loss. I’m old enough to remember the long playoff droughts, when there were plenty of good seats available at late-season games. Yes, it can get worse. Much worse.

It’s also important to acknowledge that coaching is about more than Xs and Os. It’s also about player management. Carroll is renown for being a players’ coach, someone who allows his charges to express themselves rather than forcing them to toe the NFL line. Good players want to play for Carroll — look at the likes of Jadeveon Clowney and Jamal Adams angling for trades specifically to Seattle — and that’s been a big advantage for the Seahawks.

But as well as Carroll has done during his tenure with the Seahawks, it doesn’t mean he’s infallible, and the time has come for Carroll to examine the way he does things and re-evaluate what is best for the team.

Carroll has won in Seattle behind a philosophy of ball security, limiting explosive plays and field position. It’s a conservative strategy that tends towards running the ball on offense, bending but not breaking on defense, and punting on fourth-and-short. The problem is the league has evolved. The rules have changed to favor the passing game, and defenses can’t get away with the same type of tactics that worked in 2013.

Before the playoffs began I examined the teams that reached the Super Bowl the past five years to see what characteristics they had in common. The thing they most had in common? The ability to score points, as nine of the 10 teams were in the top five in the league in scoring. Look at the teams that won the past weekend in the divisional round of the playoffs: Green Bay, Buffalo, Kansas City and Tampa Bay. Those were four of the top six teams in the league in scoring. When Carroll says, “I don’t mind winning 20-9, I don’t mind winning 17-14,” well, that’s just not how championship teams do it in today’s NFL.

Part of Carroll’s reasoning for needing to run the ball more is that defenses adjusted during the season, switching to two deep safeties to take away the long ball. He said that by running the ball more defenses will be forced to move one of those safeties closer to the line of scrimmage, thus opening up more deep passing lanes. Maybe that will work, but maybe not. Many successful defenses are willing to give up modest gains to prevent big ones, then get tough when the opposition has a condensed field, forcing them to settle for field goals. Defenses like … the Seahawks.

Carroll has a big decision to make on offense after the team parted ways with offensive coordinator Brian Schottenheimer over “philosophical differences.” The theory is that Schottenheimer wasn’t on board with the run-the-ball-more plan, and that Carroll will hire a replacement who is. I urge Carroll to pause a moment, reassess what works in today’s NFL, and choose someone who will hand the tongs back to Wilson.

But whoever Carroll hires, even if it’s a wishbone specialist, I suggest you take a deep breath and smile. The Seahawks are still in their golden era, and no one has had more to do with that than Carroll.

Follow Nick Patterson on Twitter at @NickHPatterson.

Talk to us

More in Sports

The Everett Elite Flag Football 14-under team practices Sunday morning at Harbour Pointe Middle School in Mukilteo, Washington on January 16, 2022. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Community roundup: 3 Jackson grads to D-I baseball tournament

Plus, Jayden White is headed back to the NCAA track and field nationals, the Silvertips sign their first-round picks and more.

Washington's Sami Reynolds runs the bases against McNeese during an NCAA softball game on Saturday, May 20, 2023, in Seattle. (AP Photo/John Froschauer)
Local softball stars Reynolds, Mahler set for WCWS

Washington’s Sami Reynolds (Snohomish) and Stanford’s River Mahler (Monroe) each play prominent roles on their Pac-12 teams.

Alberto Rodriguez.
Rodriguez puts on power display, leads AquaSox to series win

The 22-year-old outfielder mashed 11 extra-base hits, including six home runs, as Everett took five of seven from Eugene.

Vote for The Herald’s Prep Athlete of the Week for May 22-28

The Athlete of the Week nominees for May 22-28 Voting closes at… Continue reading

Daniel Kim, left, and Ben Borgida, right, chat between holes during the Snohomish County Amateur golf tournament at the Everett Golf and Country Club in Everett, Washington on Monday, May 29, 2023. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Kim soars to 4-shot win in 92nd Snohomish County Amateur

The WSU freshman and Kamiak graduate’s 12-under final total was the historic tournament’s lowest since at least 2010.

New York Yankees' Aaron Judge gestures after hitting a solo home-run against the Seattle Mariners during the seventh inning of a baseball game Tuesday, May 30, 2023, in Seattle. (AP Photo/Caean Couto)
Judge strikes again, Mariners lose to Yankees

Seattle falls 10-2 for a second consecutive lopsided loss.

Cooper Cummings from the United States celebrates after winning a men's downhill during the Cheese Rolling contest at Cooper's Hill in Brockworth, Gloucestershire, Monday May 29, 2023. The Cooper's Hill Cheese-Rolling and Wake is an annual event where participants race down the 200-yard (180 m) long hill chasing a wheel of double gloucester cheese. (AP Photo/Kin Cheung)
Arlington High School grad is the big cheese after winning UK race

Cooper Cummings, who grew up in Lake Stevens, defeated a world record-holder in Cooper’s Hill Cheese Rolling and Wake.

Jackson High School is awarded the 2023 WIAA class 4A softball championship trophy in Richland, Wash., on Sat., May 27. (TJ Mullinax/for The Herald)
Jackson wins state title over GP after game called by weather

The Timberwolves win 5-1 to hoist their third state softball trophy since 2018 after a game that ended in unusual fashion.

Lake Stevens’ Grant Buckmiller takes a peek at the clock as he runs to the title in the 4A boys 200 meter dash during the WIAA State Track and Field Championships on Saturday, May 27, 2023, at Mount Tahoma High School in Tacoma, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
State track: Lake Stevens sprinter Buckmiller blazes to multiple titles

Also, Kamiak’s Kalia Estes and Jaedyn Chase claim championships and more on local title winners and state placers.

Most Read