POLL RESULTS: Calling timeout wasn’t a mistake for Seahawks

A majority of voters were OK with calling timeout on the Rams’ fourth-down play, but it was close.

Was it a mistake for the Seattle Seahawks to call timeout before the Los Angeles Rams’ fourth-down play in last Sunday’s 33-31 loss at CenturyLink Field? It was close, but a majority of the voters say it wasn’t.

This week’s Seattle Sidelines poll asked readers to weigh in on Pete Carroll’s timeout decision. With 1 minute, 39 seconds remaining the Seahawks, trailing by two points, stopped the Rams just short on third-and-1. Seattle used its last timeout to stop the clock, and during the timeout Los Angeles took its punt team off the field and sent its offense back on to go for it. Jared Goff converted the first down on a quarterback sneak, and the Rams were able to run out the clock.

There was much furor on social media about Carroll’s decision to call timeout, so I wanted the gauge how fans felt about the decision, asking readers whether calling timeout was a mistake. Here’s how you voted:

Add the two together and 53 percent of the voters said calling timeout wasn’t a mistake, while 47 percent said it was. It was a close vote throughout.

The main argument I’ve seen as to why calling timeout was a mistake is that the Rams were going to punt, and that by calling timeout it gave Los Angeles coach Sean McVay the opportunity to change his mind and go for it.

I have yet to see McVay say definitively that he would have punted had Seattle not called timeout. However, there’s been plenty said about how the offensive players talked McVay into going for it on fourth down, and one can speculate as to whether the offense would have had the opportunity to talk McVay into going for it had a timeout not been called.

For his part, Carroll has stood by his decision to call timeout, calling it, “The right way to do it.” Carroll spoke about how it made sense given the clock situation, and mentioned that the Seahawks had stopped the Rams three times in 1-yard situations previously during the game.

Personally, I had no issues with calling timeout in that situation. From a clock-management standpoint, the choice was either to get the ball back with 1:30 remaining and no timeouts, or get the ball back with 1:00 with one timeout remaining. A team has some control of the clock when it has the ball, but no control of the clock when it doesn’t. So by my thinking those 30-odd seconds, with the offense able to hustle to the line of scrimmage after plays and with the option to spike the ball to stop the clock, were more valuable to have on offense than the timeout.

As for letting the Rams change their mind about punting, had the Seahawks’ defense held Seattle would have had the ball needing less than 10 yards to get in range for the game-winning field goal — and no one is questioning whether using the timeout was a mistake. The objections seem to me to be largely results based rather than process based.

The majority of the voters in this poll agreed with me, but it was a slim majority. It illustrates how clock management and timeout management in football are not as cut and dried as they may seem.

Talk to us

More in Sports

WIAA sets new deadline for spring sports championships

The organization says if school returns by May 4 it will still hold “some sort of culminating event.”

The Seattle Mariners’ Ken Griffey Jr. smiles from beneath a pile of teammates who mobbed him after he scored the winning run in the bottom of the 11th inning of Game 5 of the American League Division Series against the New York Yankees on Oct. 8, 1995, at the Kingdome. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson, File)
POLL RESULTS: 1995 is the season for positive M’s memories

More than two-thirds of voters said their best Mariners memories come from Seattle’s first playoff run.

Former Washington football coach Jim Lambright dies at 77

He spent nearly four decades with the Husky program as a player, assistant coach and head coach.

Mariners’ Gonzales on no opening day: ‘It’s definitely weird’

The Seattle starter says he’s encouraged by MLB’s coronavirus deal, but hopes pitchers are protected.

UW coach Lake still hopeful for football in fall

‘I think we are going to have a season and I think it’s going to be a memorable one,’ the new coach says.

UW’s Stewart declares for NBA draft

The freshman sensation led the Huskies in scoring, rebounding and blocks in his only season at UW.

Seahawks bring back Mayowa to help pass rush

A member of Seattle’s 2013 Super Bowl team, the 28-year-old had seven sacks last season for the Raiders.

Wimbledon canceled for 1st time since WWII

The virus forces the cancellation of the tennis event for the first time for any reason other than war.

Seahawks cut ties with safety Thompson, tight end Dickson

The moves create an additional $5 million in cap space as Seattle searches for pass-rush help.

Most Read