Voters disagreed with Seattle Seahawks coach Pete Carroll’s decision to punt rather than go for it on fourth-and-short Sunday against the Los Angeles Rams. (AP Photo/Chris Szagola)

Voters disagreed with Seattle Seahawks coach Pete Carroll’s decision to punt rather than go for it on fourth-and-short Sunday against the Los Angeles Rams. (AP Photo/Chris Szagola)

POLL RESULTS: Carroll shouldn’t have punted vs. the Rams

More than three-quarters of responders said the Seahawks should have gone for it on fourth-and-short.

It’s not unanimous, but it’s close. Readers think Pete Carroll should have gone for it.

It was a pivotal moment in the Seattle Seahawks’ 23-16 loss to the Los Angeles Rams on Sunday at SoFi Stadium. Seattle trailed 17-13 early in the third quarter, and the Seahawks faced fourth-and-inches at their own 42-yard line. Seattle originally lined up to go for it, but only tried to draw the Rams offside, and eventually took a delay-of-game penalty before punting.

Would it have been a better decision to go for it at that juncture? That was the subject of this week’s Seattle Sidelines poll.

Add up the votes from the poll posted on the blog and the poll posted on Twitter and it’s a runaway. More than three-quarters of the voters — 78% — said Seattle should have gone for it. Just 10% agreed with the decision to punt, while 12% deemed the situation a toss-up.

Hindsight, as they say, is 20/20, and it’s easy to say the Seahawks should have gone for it now, since the Rams scored on the ensuing possession anyway and Seattle ultimately lost the game. No one will ever know what would have ensued had the Seahawks run a play.

But even at the time of the decision — before L.A. scored its TD — there was heavy internet clamor about the decision. Seattle’s defense had been run over by the Rams in the first half, and the Seahawks were fortunate to be within four points at halftime. The thought was Seattle needed all the points it could get to keep pace with the Rams because the defense hadn’t provided any reason to believe it could stop L.A. In addition, fans figured fourth-and-inches shouldn’t scare a team that came into the game with the top-ranked offense in the NFL, even without No. 1 running back Chris Carson available.

This notion was seconded the number crunchers. The Athletic’s Ben Baldwin, a die hard analytics guy based in Seattle, created a “4th down decision bot,” which calculated that going for it would have added 3.9% to Seattle’s win probability and rated it a “strong” recommendation for going for it. EdjSports, a sports analytics organization, calculated that the decision to punt decreased the Seahawks’ pre-snap game-winning chance by 6%.

The decision really was a reversion to type for Carroll. Carroll has been notoriously conservative in those type of situations since taking over the Seahawks in 2010, believing in the importance of field position. He seemed to change his tune this season amidst the “let Russ cook” phenomenon. But this instance was a throwback, and he defended the decision vigorously, both in the immediate aftermath of the game and the day after.

But let’s face it, the voters are right on this one. Several possessions later the Rams showed exactly what is needed in these situations, when Jared Goff’s quarterback sneak didn’t get much, but it was enough to convert fourth-and-short.

Carroll and the Seahawks paid the price for not taking that high-percentage shot, and the cost may have been a loss in a crucial NFC West matchup.

Talk to us

More in Sports

The Everett Elite Flag Football 14-under team practices Sunday morning at Harbour Pointe Middle School in Mukilteo, Washington on January 16, 2022. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Community roundup: 3 Jackson grads to D-I baseball tournament

Plus, Jayden White is headed back to the NCAA track and field nationals, the Silvertips sign their first-round picks and more.

Vote for The Herald’s Prep Athlete of the Week for May 22-28

The Athlete of the Week nominees for May 22-28 Voting closes at… Continue reading

Washington's Sami Reynolds runs the bases against McNeese during an NCAA softball game on Saturday, May 20, 2023, in Seattle. (AP Photo/John Froschauer)
Local softball stars Reynolds, Mahler set for WCWS

Washington’s Sami Reynolds (Snohomish) and Stanford’s River Mahler (Monroe) each play prominent roles on their Pac-12 teams.

The Mariners’ Cal Raleigh smiles as a teammate throws bubblegum at him during an interview after Raleigh hit a single to drive in the winning run against the Yankees during the 10th inning of a game Wednesday in Seattle. (AP Photo/Lindsey Wasson)
Raleigh’s RBI single in 10th gives M’s 1-0 win over Yankees

George Kirby pitches one of the best games of his young career with eight shutout innings in Seattle’s 1-0 win.

AquaSox top Hops on wild pitch in 11th inning

Everett edges Hillsboro 3-2 in a game with strong pitching on both sides.

Alberto Rodriguez.
Rodriguez puts on power display, leads AquaSox to series win

The 22-year-old outfielder mashed 11 extra-base hits, including six home runs, as Everett took five of seven from Eugene.

Daniel Kim, left, and Ben Borgida, right, chat between holes during the Snohomish County Amateur golf tournament at the Everett Golf and Country Club in Everett, Washington on Monday, May 29, 2023. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Kim soars to 4-shot win in 92nd Snohomish County Amateur

The WSU freshman and Kamiak graduate’s 12-under final total was the historic tournament’s lowest since at least 2010.

New York Yankees' Aaron Judge gestures after hitting a solo home-run against the Seattle Mariners during the seventh inning of a baseball game Tuesday, May 30, 2023, in Seattle. (AP Photo/Caean Couto)
Judge strikes again, Mariners lose to Yankees

Seattle falls 10-2 for a second consecutive lopsided loss.

Cooper Cummings from the United States celebrates after winning a men's downhill during the Cheese Rolling contest at Cooper's Hill in Brockworth, Gloucestershire, Monday May 29, 2023. The Cooper's Hill Cheese-Rolling and Wake is an annual event where participants race down the 200-yard (180 m) long hill chasing a wheel of double gloucester cheese. (AP Photo/Kin Cheung)
Arlington High School grad is the big cheese after winning UK race

Cooper Cummings, who grew up in Lake Stevens, defeated a world record-holder in Cooper’s Hill Cheese Rolling and Wake.

Most Read