POLL RESULTS: Griffey still considered greatest Mariner

Ken Griffey Jr. bested new Hall of Famer Edgar Martinez by more than three-to-one in the voting.

Edgar Martinez is finally a Hall of Famer. However, that wasn’t enough to make him No. 1 in Seattle Mariners fans’ eyes.

This week’s Seattle Sidelines poll, in honor of Martinez being elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame, asked readers which player was the greatest Mariner of all time. But Martinez’s enshrinement wasn’t enough to knock Ken Griffey Jr. off the top step of the pedestal.

Here’s how you voted:


Add it all together and Griffey was still the landslide choice as greatest ever Mariner, claiming 67 percent of the vote. Martinez came in a distant second at 20 percent, while Ichiro brought in 12 percent. Hernandez, Johnson, Rodriguez and “other” combined garnered just 1 percent of the vote, so we can infer that not having their individual names in the Twitter portion of the poll didn’t have a major effect on voting.

This is an interesting result to me. Certainly there’s nothing wrong with Griffey being the choice. He’s a Hall of Famer himself, he was an incredibly popular player and he played a big role in saving baseball in Seattle.

But I have to admit to being a little surprised that Griffey bested Edgar by more than three-to-one. This poll was based on what the players did while playing for Seattle, and from a statistical standpoint Griffey and Edgar were almost dead even in terms of Baseball-Reference.com wins above replacement with the Mariners, with Griffey at 70.6 and Martinez at 68.4. Edgar is also beloved in the Puget Sound region because he played his entire career in Seattle — heck, the name of the street beside T-Mobile Park is named after him. With Edgar being in the headlines because of the Hall of Fame vote, I thought me may see a bump in votes sent his way. If we did, then the sentiment prior to Edger getting into the Hall of Fame was pretty much all in favor of Griffey.

I was also interested in how the voting at the bottom of the poll was going to go. With Twitter only allowing four poll answer options, I had to think long and hard before going with Ichiro as the third named choice. I could think of strong arguments for having any of Hernandez, Johnson or Rodriguez as the third choice instead of Ichiro, but I decided to stick with the raw WAR total. The voting, with Ichiro at least getting a relevant portion of the vote both on Twitter and on the blog, suggests that was the right decision.

Finally, I have to admit to being glad that Rodriguez at least got one vote. I know he’s hated in this area, but I’ve never fully understood why. Sure, he jilted the Mariners, but so did Griffey and Johnson in their own way — and in Johnson’s case it was worse as he tanked half a season to force a trade, whereas Rodriguez just took what was by far the biggest contract offer when he became a free agent. Yet Griffey and Johnson are still revered in Seattle. Even with Rodriguez only playing a fraction of his career with the Mariners, he’s still probably the greatest Mariners player in terms of peak value, and there was at least one voter (it wasn’t me) who acknowledged that.

Talk to us

More in Sports

Everett Community College’s Trojan mascot (left) poses with Everett Silvertips mascot, Lincoln. (Provided photo)
Silvertips, EvCC announce partnership to house players

Everett’s billeting program is on hold to respect health and safety protocols forced by the pandemic.

Gonzaga forward Corey Kispert (24), looks to drive against Pacific forward Jeremiah Bailey (13), during the first half of an NCAA college basketball game in Stockton, Calif., Thursday, Feb. 4, 2021. Gonzaga won 76-58. (AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli)
Edmonds native Kispert named WCC player of the year

Former local hoops stars Paisley Johnson Harding and Jordyn Edwards also received All-WCC honors.

Everett High School graduate Jayden White (right), a University of Washington freshman, poses next to throws coach Andrew Ninow after breaking the Huskies' school record in the weight throw last Friday. (Photo by Jamie Mitchell)
Community sports roundup: Everett H.S. grad breaks UW record

Jayden White broke UW’s weight throw record, highlighting a success-filled week for local athletes.

FILE - Washington's Asa Turner (20) celebrates with Kamren Fabiculanan (31) after Turner intercepted a pass in the final minute of an NCAA college football game against Oregon State in Seattle, in this Saturday, Nov. 14, 2020, file photo. Washington won 27-21. Washington has pulled out of the Pac-12 football championship game due to COVID-19 issues in the Huskies program, and Oregon will now play No. 13 USC for the conference title on Friday instead.  Washington (3-1) announced Monday, Dec. 14, 2020, it is withdrawing from the championship game after determining the Huskies did not have at least 53 scholarship players available and did not meet the minimum number of scholarship athletes at specific positions.(AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File)
Washington’s 2021 football schedule released

Huskies head coach Jimmy Lake is hopeful that fans will be allowed as soon as the spring game May 1.

Washington State running back Deon McIntosh (3) celebrates after scoring against Utah during the first half of an NCAA college football game Saturday, Dec. 19, 2020, in Salt Lake City. (AP Photo/Rick Bowmer)
Washington State’s 2021 football schedule released

The Cougars open the season with three straight home games and six of their first eight in Pullman.

Granite Falls' Kaleb Roberts rushes with Sultan's Kaden Harwick closing Friday night in Sultan on February 26, 2021 (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Friday night lights finally back on

Granite Falls beats rival Sultan in OT in the area’s first prep football game in more than 15 months.

High School football teams across Snohomish County are closing in on their first game in over a year. (Herald file photos)
Prep football: Key games and the area’s complete schedule

The first H.S. football game in the county in over a year is set to take place this coming Friday.

A Marysville Pilchuck football player sports a spear on his helmet as the Tomahawks took on Snohomish in the Wesco 3A Championship Friday evening at Quil Ceda Stadium on November 1, 2019. School district leaders may soon need to consider dropping Marysville Pilchuck High School’s mascot, the Tomahawks. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Should Marysville Pilchuck High drop the name ‘Tomahawks’?

A state bill would ban Native American mascots and symbols from schools — unless there is tribal permission.

Dawn Trudeau (Seattle Storm)
13 years ago this month, they bought the Seattle Storm

Dawn Trudeau and her partners didn’t foresee the challenges — or the championships — that were in store.

Most Read