Seattle Mariners general manager Jerry Dipoto answers questions during the annual pre-spring training media event, Thursday, Jan. 24, 2019 in Seattle. (Steve Ringman/The Seattle Times via AP)

Seattle Mariners general manager Jerry Dipoto answers questions during the annual pre-spring training media event, Thursday, Jan. 24, 2019 in Seattle. (Steve Ringman/The Seattle Times via AP)

POLL RESULTS: Readers unimpressed by Mariners’ rebuild

More than 70 percent of voters gave Seattle a C or worse for the first half-season of rebuilding.

It seems Seattle Mariners watchers aren’t impressed by how the team’s rebuild has begun.

This week’s Seattle Sidelines poll asked readers to get their grading pens out. The Mariners admitted before the season began that this would be a rebuilding year. They emphasized that by trading away a slew of core players during the offseason in exchange for prospects, then flipped more veterans once the season began.

Therefore, results this season are less important than how the team sets itself up for success in the future. So instead of grading the first half of the season, this week’s poll asked readers to grade the Mariners for their first half-season of rebuilding. Here are your marks:


Merge the two together and readers think the Mariners need tutoring help. More than 70 percent of responders gave Seattle a C or lower, with 39 percent handing out a C and 33 percent marking down to D/F. Twenty-three percent gave the Mariners a B, while just 5 percent rated Seattle an A.

First, let’s address the discrepancy between the Twitter and blog polls. The marks on the blog were somewhat better than on Twitter. The original blog post detailed some of the things that have gone right and wrong with regards to rebuilding over the first three months of the season, and I suspect seeing those details laid out influenced the blog voters in a more positive direction compared to the voters on Twitter, who had no details to work with.

That said, while the marks were somewhat higher on the blog, they still weren’t great — more than half gave the Mariners a C or lower.

I have to say, I find this surprising.

I get that the Mariners are having the type of season that’s become all too familiar since Seattle last made the playoffs in 2001. The Mariners are in last place in the American League West, have essentially been eliminated from postseason contention prior to the all-star break, and good luck naming who happens to be in the bullpen on any given day.

But I have to ask: What did people expect? The Houston Astros are the gold standard for baseball rebuilds, with a team on track for its third straight 100-win season. But to make this happen the Astros had to suffer through three straight 100-loss seasons from 2011-13. If a team is going to rebuild, it’s going to go through some pain, and this Seattle team isn’t anywhere near as bad as those Houston teams were at their nadir.

And I think the team has taken steps to create optimism for the future, something the organization has been sorely missing. For the first time in a long time the Mariners have both youngish major-league players who are producing, as well as prospects worth getting excited about.

I don’t know that the execution of the early stages of the rebuild have been flawless, and I have serious doubts about general manager Jerry Dipoto’s stated timeline of the window for contention opening in 2021. But the moves to replenish the minor-league system, along with the payroll flexibility Seattle will have beginning next year, makes me think Seattle has at least laid some groundwork.

Feel free to disagree, and I understand if you don’t trust Dipoto to be the one to successfully navigate Seattle through a rebuild. But in my opinion, what we saw the first half of the season indicates the rebuild is off to a solid start.

Talk to us

More in Sports

M’s beat Astros to keep faint playoff hopes alive

Seattle wins 3-2 and will need to sweep the Athletics and get some help to reach the postseason.

Irvin’s injury thrusts Seahawks rookie Brooks into spotlight

The linebacker, who was Seattle’s top pick in the 2020 draft, will start Sunday against Dallas.

Meet the 9 new members of the Snohomish County Sports HOF

The class includes legendary teams, athletes, coaches and voices from the area.

In this Oct. 14, 2014, file photo, the Seattle Seahawks’ Richard Sherman (25) talks with New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady after the Seahawks won 24-23 at CenturyLink Field. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)
POLL: What’s your favorite Seahawks-Patriots game?

The two franchises have played some doozies since Russell Wilson arrived as Seattle’s quarterback.

Seattle Seahawks quarterback Russell Wilson warms up before an NFL football game against the New England Patriots, Sunday, Sept. 20, 2020, in Seattle. The Seahawks won 35-30. (AP Photo/Stephen Brashear)
Russell Wilson is NFL’s MVP — no doubt about it

After stunning performances in the Seahawks’ first two games, he’s proven he’s the league’s best player.

County Hall of Fame Class of 2020: Duane Lewis

The longtime Lynnwood track and field coach won three state team titles over 46 terrific seasons.

Sounders fall to rival Timbers on early Chara goal

Seattle’s two-game win streak comes to an end with a 1-0 loss on the road to Portland.

Seahawks’ Metcalf wins battle against one of NFL’s best

The rising Seattle wide receiver went toe-to-toe with the Patriots’ Stephon Gilmore on Sunday night.

Clark’s buzzer-beat lifts Storm over Lynx in Game 1

Seattle beats Minnesota 88-86 in the first game of the best-of-five semifinal series.

Most Read