The Seattle Mariners’ Keon Broxton knocks his helmet off after striking out looking as New York Yankees catcher Austin Romine, back left, heads to the dugout in the second inning of a baseball game Monday, Aug. 26, 2019, in Seattle. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)

The Seattle Mariners’ Keon Broxton knocks his helmet off after striking out looking as New York Yankees catcher Austin Romine, back left, heads to the dugout in the second inning of a baseball game Monday, Aug. 26, 2019, in Seattle. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)

POLL RESULTS: The Mariners’ season is deemed a failure

More than half the voters awarded the rebuilding Seattle a D or F for the 2019 campaign.

Regardless of the season’s intention, it seems the majority of Seattle Mariners fans deem 2019 a failure.

The Mariners’ season came to an end last Sunday, as Seattle once again finds itself watching the postseason from afar. The Mariners finished 68-94, which put Seattle in last place in the American League West, a whopping 39 games behind division champion Houston. It also represented a 21-game dropoff from 2018, when Seattle went 89-73, yet still missed the postseason. As a result, the Mariners’ playoff drought reached 18 years, which is the longest among teams in all of America’s major professional leagues.

However, that kind of dropoff was fully expected this season. Mariners general manager Jerry Dipoto admitted this would be a rebuilding year after the team traded off most of its core players during the offseason. And although the results at the major-league level were not good, there were positive developments in the minors that could make Seattle’s future much brighter than it seemed this time last year.

Therefore, this week’s Seattle Sidelines poll asked readers to grade the Mariners’ 2019 season. Here’s what you came up with:


Put it all together and more than half the voters — 51 percent — gave the Mariners a D or F. Another 32 percent said Seattle deserved a C, while 15 percent deemed the season a B, and a mere 2 percent gave it an A.

So it seems not many Mariners observers were swayed by the apparent progress made in the rebuilding effort.

On one hand, I get this. This was not a fun season for following the big-league club. The team began the season 13-2, providing a false sense of hope, then fell off the reality cliff. There were only a handful of players who fans had built any attachment to, and we were forced to watch the most significant of those — longtime ace pitcher Felix Hernandez — continue his decline into ineffectiveness. By the end of the season it was nearly impossible to identify who was on the roster.

The fans showed how they felt by not showing up. Seattle’s attendance was 1,791,720, more than 20 percent fewer than 2018 and the lowest since 2013. While Hernandez’s probable final start for the Mariners was much celebrated, T-Mobile Park was less than half full for the occasion, and the team drew just 16,819 for the season finale. So I get it when people are dismissive of the season.

But for me, I have to evaluate the season based on what the team was trying to accomplish, and the fact was the Mariners’ goal wasn’t to win this season. Seattle’s goal this season was to see what it could do to get better in the future, and the combination of trades and player development put the Mariners in what appears to be a much better position to contend in future years. Seattle created payroll flexibility, and the minor-league system went from dead last to top third in the span of one calendar year, with three players — Jarred Kelenic, Logan Gilbert, Julio Rodriguez — who are now legitimate grade-A prospects. In my opinion, given the goals of the season, the Mariners had a fantastic 2019.

But based on the poll results, it appears my opinion is in the distinct minority.

More in Sports

Everett High girls wrestling has remarkable global diversity

The Seagulls feature internationally born wrestlers from 8 different countries and 3 continents.

Former Cascade High star reaches a one-year deal with Cubs

Steven Souza Jr. agrees to a $1 million contract, but can earn an additional $2 million in bonuses

Furious rally lifts Stanwood wrestling over Snohomish

Stanwood won 5 of the final 6 bouts to win 41-39, and 3 teams can still win the Wesco 3A North.

Glacier Peak’s Aaliyah Collins attempts a layup against Lake Stevens on Tuesday, Jan. 28 at Glacier Peak High School in Snohomish. (Katie Webber / The Herald)
Glacier Peak girls beat Lake Stevens, extend win streak to 10

Maya Erling scores 25 points as the Grizzlies win 66-50 to take a commanding lead in Wesco 4A.

Coco Gauff coming to Everett as part of U.S. Fed Cup team

The 15-year-old tennis sensation is on the U.S. squad for next week’s match against Latvia.

Changes coming for Wesco after statewide reclassification

Wesco 4A will be down to just five teams as Cascade, Monroe and Mount Vernon drop to 3A.

Former E-W sharpshooter has Whitman women hoops thinking big

Mady Burdett is 1 of the top 3-point shooters in NCAA D-III basketball, and a standout for the Blues.

Two local players survive the Seattle Dragons’ final cut

The XFL franchise trims its roster to 52 players in advance of its inaugural season

Silvertips notes: Key divisional clash coming Friday

Silvertips look to close the gap on the first-place Portland Winterhawks

Most Read