Rapid reaction to Edgar falling short of the Hall of Fame

The Mariners legend may not have made it this year, but signs are positive for next year.

It was a rough day for Seattle Mariners fans.

Edgar Martinez, perhaps the most beloved player in franchise history, fell just short of election to the Baseball Hall of Fame on Wednesday. Martinez was named on 297 of the 422 ballots cast by members of the Baseball Writers Association of America, good for 70.4 percent, which is just short of the 75 percent needed for election. Edgar came up 20 votes short.

For a Seattle fan base that’s been reeling, with the franchise missing the playoffs for the 16th straight year and then losing out on Japanese free agent Shohei Ohtani after going all-in, having Martinez fall short feels like another gut punch. It was particularly difficult considering Martinez was above the 75-percent mark throughout the tracking of publicly-released ballots prior to the announcement, but slipped under the bar at the last second. This was Martinez’s ninth year on the ballot, meaning he now has just one more year to get elected.

But allow me to inject a ray of light into the gloom. This year’s results still indicate Edgar will likely get in next year. Consider:

  • Martinez’s momentum continues to surge forward. Remember, Edgar received just 27.0 percent of the vote in 2015. He stepped up to 43.3 percent in 2016, 58.6 percent last year and now 70.4 percent this year. His trend line remains strong, and he continues to mirror the path of Tim Raines, who received 46.6, 55.0 and 69.8 percent in his seventh, eighth and ninth years on the ballot before getting over the line in his final year last year with 86.0 percent.
  • There will be less competition for votes next year. Chipper Jones, Vladimir Guerrero, Jim Thome and Trevor Hoffman all got in this year, which takes them off next year’s ballot. Meanwhile, the only name coming onto the ballot next year who’s certain to get heavy voting is Mariano Rivera. Fewer truly legitimate candidates works in Edgar’s favor.
  • Players suspected of using performance-enhancing substances, like Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens, had been making strides in recent years. But their progress stalled this year, meaning they won’t necessarily draw any more votes away from Martinez.

The one thing working against Martinez is the fact that he played the majority of his career as a designated hitter, and there’s a faction of voters who disqualify him for not playing in the field. I suppose it could be possible Edgar has squeezed out all the votes he can from those who are amenable to the DH. But I sincerely doubt that, and if any of those voters are inclined to vote for David Ortiz when he becomes eligible, they’ll have some explaining to do if they didn’t vote for Edgar.

But regardless of whether (when) Edgar gets into the Hall of Fame, he’s always going to be this guy:

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Sports

Mountlake Terrace and Arlington players all leap in the air for a rebound during the game on Tuesday, Dec. 10, 2024 in Mountlake Terrace, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Terrace boys basketball wins rematch over Arlington 47-46

Hawks weather a 20-turnover night against their rivals.

X
Prep roundup for Tuesday, Dec. 10

Prep roundup schedule for Tuesday, Dec. 10: (Note for coaches/scorekeepers: To report… Continue reading

Vote for The Herald’s Prep Athlete of the Week for Dec. 1-7

The Athlete of the Week nominees for Dec. 1-7. Voting closes at… Continue reading

Seahawks defensive tackles Byron Murphy II (91) and Johnathan Hankins (97) celebrate after a defensive play against the Arizona Cardinals at State Farm Stadium on Sunday, Dec. 8, 2024. (Photo courtesy of the Seattle Seahawks)
Seahawks meeting challenge to go into playoff ‘death mode’

Can Seattle sustain postseason mentality for the remainder of regular season?

Seahawks unsure when Kenneth Walker III will return

Backup running back Zach Charbonnet enjoyed a career day in Walker’s absence Sunday.

Japan starting pitcher Roki Sasaki (14) pitches against Mexico during the second inning of a semifinal game at the World Baseball Classic at loanDepot Park on Monday, March 20, 2023, in Miami. (Matias J. Ocner / Miami Herald / Tribune News Services)
Mariners making Japanese ace Roki Sasaki ‘a priority’

Jerry Dipoto optimistic about chance to woo Roki Sasaki to Seattle

Seahawks receiver Jake Bobo (19) celebrates with running back Zach Charbonnet (26) after a touchdown during the Seahawks 30-18 victory at State Farm Stadium on Sunday, Dec. 8, 2024. (Photo courtesy of the Seattle Seahawks)
Seahawks put together complete game, beat Arizona

Seattle wins its fourth straight by beating the Cardinals in all phases.

Stanwood (red) and Monroe (white) each huddle before a league game at Monroe High School on Dec. 7, 2024. (Qasim Ali / The Herald)
Stanwood girls basketball survives Monroe in OT

Spartans outscore Monroe 14-1 in OT to deny the Bearcats.

Cougars lose 15 players in transfer portal’s first day open

Keeping quarterback John Mateer will be a key for WSU

Gonzaga drops to No. 8 in poll

Bulldogs slip one spot after overtime loss to Kentucky.

X
Prep roundup for Saturday, Dec. 7

Zia-Daye Anderson scores 35 points for Kamiak girls and Grady Rohrich leads boys with 31.

Seahawks linebacker Ernest Jones IV (13) celebrates his interception with teammates in a 30-18 win over Arizona at State Farm Stadium on Sunday, Dec. 8, 2024. (Photo courtesy of Edwin Hooper / Seattle Seahawks)
Dave Boling: Seahawks have the foundation of a new LOB

‘Baby Boomers’ are coming into their own during four-game winning streak.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.