New York Giants cornerback James Bradberry (left) and defensive back Logan Ryan, right, break up a pass intended for Seattle Seahawks wide receiver DK Metcalf on Sunday. (Elaine Thompson / Associated Press)

New York Giants cornerback James Bradberry (left) and defensive back Logan Ryan, right, break up a pass intended for Seattle Seahawks wide receiver DK Metcalf on Sunday. (Elaine Thompson / Associated Press)

Seahawks’ unwillingness to keep it simple costs them a game

A quarterback sneak on a fourth-and-inches play probably would have earned Seattle a first down. But no — they called a pass play, which failed.

Russell Wilson described it as “probably one of the most key parts of the game.”

The Seattle Seahawks, trailing the New York Giants by three points midway through the third quarter of their meeting Sunday at Lumen Field, faced fourth-and-inches from their own 48-yard line. The Giants had just generated their first real offense of the game to take the lead, and the Seahawks were desperate to answer and regain momentum. The decision to go for it was a no-brainer.

But as Wilson dropped back to pass I gently shook my head in resignation. Regardless of the result of the play, I just couldn’t understand why the Seahawks are unable to figure out something so simple.

Would someone please break into Seahawks offensive coordinator Brian Shottenheimer’s office, find Seattle’s playbook, and paste a page with the quarterback sneak drawn up on it to the inside of the front cover?

Seattle suffered an awful loss Sunday, falling 17-12 at home to a 4-7 Giants team forced to start a quarterback who hadn’t won a game since 2014, and it’s possible the game hinged on Seattle’s continued unwillingness to use football’s most simple play.

The past two weeks Seattle’s play calling in critical short-yardage situations has come into question. Last week against Philadelphia it was a pair of unsuccessful fourth-and-2 calls, allowing the Eagles to hang around before the Seahawks eventually won 23-17. Against the Giants it was a rollout pass call that the Giants sniffed out to force an incompletion and turn the ball over on downs.

In Sunday’s situation, a lot of second guessing could have been averted had the Seahawks simply called a quarterback sneak.

Countless studies have concluded that in short-yardage situations, the quarterback sneak is by far the most effective play. A 2019 study by Sports Info Solutions found that since 2015 the quarterback sneak had an 88% success rate when used on third-and-1 or fourth-and-1, while no other play was better than 73%, causing the researcher to label the quarterback sneak as the most underutilized play in football. The Wall Street Journal in 2018 came to the same conclusion. Heck, even Yale University looked at the subject in 2015, finding that on fourth-and-1 quarterback sneaks had a 20% better conversion rate than all other plays.

But the Seahawks seem particularly stubborn about using the quarterback sneak.

Looking over the game logs from this season, I counted 16 plays in which the Seahawks ran an offensive snap on third-and-1 or fourth-and-1, which are the typical quarterback-sneak scenarios. Eight times Seattle called a running back’s number, succeeding five times for a 62.5% success rate. Seven times the Seahawks called a pass play, succeeding just three times for a 42.9% success rate. The one quarterback sneak? It resulted in a touchdown for a 100% success rate.

Those numbers track with the studies, but it’s a small sample size. So I decided to look at Seattle’s opponents in those situations, too. The Seahawks’ opponents have faced 33 third-and-1s and fourth-and-1s this season in which they ran an offensive play. The opponent called a quarterback sneak just four times — so it’s not like Seattle is the only team that seems to have an anti-quarterback-sneak bias — but it worked on all four occasions. Of the other 32 attempts, 25 were different types of runs, which were converted 18 times for a 72% success rate. There were just four pass plays, but all four were successful for a 100% success rate.

Therefore, between the Seahawks and their opponents the tabulation is thus: pass plays were successful 63.6% of the time, runs were successful 69.7% of the time, and quarterback sneaks were successful 100% of the time.

The answer seems painfully obvious to me.

I understand there are rationalizations against using the sneak. It requires the quarterback to line up under center instead of in the shotgun, a formation that is becoming less and less frequent, therefore potentially signaling to the defense that the QB sneak is coming. And at 5-foot-11 Wilson won’t fall as far forward as his taller compatriots. But both those can be explained away. Seattle is a team that lines up behind center plenty, and Wilson makes up for his lack of height by having the quickness to dart into small gaps in the line — the Sports Info Solutions article notes that Drew Brees, another short quarterback, was 23-for-23 on QB sneaks during its study period.

After the game Seattle coach Pete Carroll was asked why he hasn’t handed the ball off to Chris Carson in those situations the past two weeks (I happen to think that was the wrong question). Carroll answered by saying, “We wanted the ball in Russ’ hands, to give him a chance. He had all kinds of options, and it didn’t work.”

But on a quarterback sneak the ball is in Wilson’s hands.

“It was fourth-and-1 right in the middle of the field and we didn’t get it,” Wilson lamented about the failed conversion against the Giants. “If we get that, the whole game may change.”

If the Seahawks would just do the simple thing and run the quarterback sneak, it might just change games in Seattle’s favor — and also spare Carroll the headache of spending his postgame presser answering questions about play calling.

Follow Nick Patterson on Twitter at @NickHPatterson.

Talk to us

More in Sports

The Everett Elite Flag Football 14-under team practices Sunday morning at Harbour Pointe Middle School in Mukilteo, Washington on January 16, 2022. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Community roundup: 3 Jackson grads to D-I baseball tournament

Plus, Jayden White is headed back to the NCAA track and field nationals, the Silvertips sign their first-round picks and more.

Vote for The Herald’s Prep Athlete of the Week for May 22-28

The Athlete of the Week nominees for May 22-28 Voting closes at… Continue reading

Washington's Sami Reynolds runs the bases against McNeese during an NCAA softball game on Saturday, May 20, 2023, in Seattle. (AP Photo/John Froschauer)
Local softball stars Reynolds, Mahler set for WCWS

Washington’s Sami Reynolds (Snohomish) and Stanford’s River Mahler (Monroe) each play prominent roles on their Pac-12 teams.

The Mariners’ Cal Raleigh smiles as a teammate throws bubblegum at him during an interview after Raleigh hit a single to drive in the winning run against the Yankees during the 10th inning of a game Wednesday in Seattle. (AP Photo/Lindsey Wasson)
Raleigh’s RBI single in 10th gives M’s 1-0 win over Yankees

George Kirby pitches one of the best games of his young career with eight shutout innings in Seattle’s 1-0 win.

AquaSox top Hops on wild pitch in 11th inning

Everett edges Hillsboro 3-2 in a game with strong pitching on both sides.

Alberto Rodriguez.
Rodriguez puts on power display, leads AquaSox to series win

The 22-year-old outfielder mashed 11 extra-base hits, including six home runs, as Everett took five of seven from Eugene.

Daniel Kim, left, and Ben Borgida, right, chat between holes during the Snohomish County Amateur golf tournament at the Everett Golf and Country Club in Everett, Washington on Monday, May 29, 2023. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Kim soars to 4-shot win in 92nd Snohomish County Amateur

The WSU freshman and Kamiak graduate’s 12-under final total was the historic tournament’s lowest since at least 2010.

New York Yankees' Aaron Judge gestures after hitting a solo home-run against the Seattle Mariners during the seventh inning of a baseball game Tuesday, May 30, 2023, in Seattle. (AP Photo/Caean Couto)
Judge strikes again, Mariners lose to Yankees

Seattle falls 10-2 for a second consecutive lopsided loss.

Cooper Cummings from the United States celebrates after winning a men's downhill during the Cheese Rolling contest at Cooper's Hill in Brockworth, Gloucestershire, Monday May 29, 2023. The Cooper's Hill Cheese-Rolling and Wake is an annual event where participants race down the 200-yard (180 m) long hill chasing a wheel of double gloucester cheese. (AP Photo/Kin Cheung)
Arlington High School grad is the big cheese after winning UK race

Cooper Cummings, who grew up in Lake Stevens, defeated a world record-holder in Cooper’s Hill Cheese Rolling and Wake.

Most Read