Why is the NFC so bad?

NEW YORK — Maybe they should put two AFC teams in the Super Bowl this season.

The search for someone worthy of playing for the NFL title sure looks easy in that conference, where the Patriots, Jets, Steelers, Ravens, Colts, Texans and Titans are dangerous, and sometimes dominant. Over in the NFC, even the losing teams still talk bravely about making the playoffs.

When head coach Mike Singletary claims his 49ers (1-6) still have a shot at the postseason, it would be heresy in the AFC. In the NFC, well, who knows?

“There’s no doubt in my mind that somehow, some way, we will regroup and keep fighting,” Singletary said. “We’re going to make a season of it, and I still believe we can go to the playoffs. I still believe we can get those things done.”

It will take a long string of wins, but nothing crazier than getting to 9-7, perhaps even 8-8 in the mediocre NFC West. Fortunately for the 49ers, their two remaining AFC opponents are underachieving San Diego and Denver, both 2-5.

NFC teams are 12-17 against the AFC so far and have not beaten a first-place AFC opponent yet. The conference’s supposed best squads — the Cowboys, Giants, Saints, Packers and Vikings — are 3-7 against the AFC.

Of course, they are not competing for spots in the playoffs with AFC teams. And while the prospect of the first division winner with a losing record remains remote, it’s possible a .500 record could take the NFC North or NFC West.

The NFC has not measured up in the Super Bowl for more than a decade, losing seven of the past 10. Yet, just a year ago, the Saints, Vikings, Cowboys, Eagles and Packers all won at least 11 times — only the Colts and Chargers managed that many wins in the AFC.

So what’s gone wrong in the NFC?

Plummeting Powerhouses

No defending division champion is alone in first place in either conference, but at least the Patriots (5-1) are tied with the Jets atop the AFC East, and the Colts (4-2) are a half-game in back of Tennessee in the AFC South. Combined, the 2009 NFC division winners are 10-15.

Turnovers have been particularly damaging, with the Cardinals at minus-7, the Vikings at minus-6, the Saints at minus-5 and the Cowboys at minus-2.

Minnesota’s usually strong passing game ranks 24th even with the addition of wide receiver Randy Moss. Brett Favre’s physical woes at 41, plus his off-field problems, have exacerbated the Vikings’ collapse.

Drew Brees, who threw just 11 interceptions in leading New Orleans to its first NFL title last season, already has 10 and the Saints have no running game. Arizona is using an undrafted rookie quarterback and has been outscored 160-98.

Key Injuries

No team has established itself because no team is whole. Sure, AFC clubs haven’t been perfectly healthy, but the most damaging injuries have occurred in the NFC.

Washington’s starting running back, Ryan Torain, began the season on the practice squad. The Giants, probably the conference’s top team so far, have seen key starters Mathias Kiwanuka, Keith Bulluck and Aaron Ross hobbled on their defense, center Shaun O’Hara and tight end Kevin Boss on offense. And they have lost to the Colts and Titans.

Philadelphia has shuffled quarterbacks as neither Kevin Kolb nor Michael Vick has steadily been available.

That’s just in the NFC East.

Half of Green Bay’s regular defense has been hurt at times. Minnesota still hasn’t had top receiver Sidney Rice. New Orleans is missing running backs Pierre Thomas and Reggie Bush.

Coaching Concerns

Carolina is ready to part with John Fox despite his 76-60 record, one NFC title and another loss in the conference championship game heading into 2010. So the Panthers allowed him to become a lame duck in the final year of his contract.

Singletary already has fired his offensive coordinator, and communication is better between the league and the players association than it is among 49ers coaches.

Chicago, while tied atop the NFC North with Green Bay (4-3), can’t protect QB Jay Cutler in new offensive coordinator Mike Martz’s offense and coach Lovie Smith and his staff are clueless about how to use replay challenges. The Bears have lost 12 of their past 15 replay challenges.

Brad Childress and Favre aren’t getting along. Jerry Jones and Wade Phillips might be getting along too well.

Not surprisingly, there’s still plenty of optimism from just about everyone in the inferior conference.

“The scary thing is I don’t think we’ve ever played on all cylinders in regards to offense, defense and special teams,” Packers linebacker Clay Matthews said. “But you see little flashes here and there.”

And maybe more than flashes. Or maybe Buccaneers coach Raheem Morris is overly optimistic about his 4-2 team.

“We’re the best team in the NFC,” Morris said after a last-minute 18-17 win over St. Louis — a week after the Bucs lost 31-6 at home to New Orleans. “Yeah, I said it. We’re the best team in the NFC.”

Even if, like their brethren, they aren’t quite Super Bowl worthy.

Talk to us

More in Sports

Marysville Pilchuck’s Christian Van Natta lifts the ball in the air to celebrate a turnover during the game against Marysville Getchell on Friday, Sept. 16, 2022 in Marysville, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Prep football roundup for Friday, Sept. 22

Prep football roundup for Friday, Sept. 22: (Note for coaches/scorekeepers: To report… Continue reading

Lynnwood teammates mob senior Abbie Orr (4) after her impressive dig led to a point against Jackson during a volleyball match Thursday, Sept. 14, 2023, at Lynnwood High School in Bothell, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Lynnwood volleyball team continues rise to prominence

After ending a 20-year state drought last season, the Royals are surging again and have vaulted to No. 3 in Class 3A in the new WSVCA poll.

Jackson High’s Ben Lee lunges to get to the ball against Kamiak on Thursday, Sep. 22, 2022, at the Kamiak Tennis Courts in Mukilteo, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Prep boys tennis season preview: Players and teams to watch

A look at the area’s top athletes and teams on the tennis court this fall.

Austin Roest prepares to take a wrist shot during the first day of Silvertips training camp on Thursday, August 31, 2023, at Angel of the Winds Arena in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Dad is an NHL bigwig, but Silvertips’ Roest carving his own path

The 19-year-old forward and son of Stanley Cup-winning executive Stacy Roest leads the Silvertips into the 2023-24 season.

Rich Haldi. (County Sports Hall of Fame photo)
County Sports Hall of Fame Class of 2023 bio: Rich Haldi

The WSU alum and longtime EvCC athletic administrator helped found the Snohomish County Sports Hall of Fame.

Vote for The Herald’s Prep Athlete of the Week for Sept. 11-17

The Athlete of the Week nominees for Sept. 11-17. Voting closes at… Continue reading

Arlington junior quarterback Leyton Martin throws a short pass during the second quarter of the season opener against Kamiak on Friday, Sep. 1, 2023, at Arlington High School in Arlington, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
3 games to watch in Week 4 of the prep football season

An in-depth look at the best games the area has to offer, plus a full schedule of the local action in Week 4.

Lakewood High School.
Refs blown call means Lakewood football game will restart in 3rd quarter

The Cougars dispute an incorrectly spotted ball by officials on a penalty-riddled play in the 3rd quarter. The game will resume from that point in Week 10.

Longtime Edmonds School District wrestling coach John Casebeer was also a member of the Snohomish County Wrestling Officials Association for 27 years. (County Sports Hall of Fame photo)
County Sports Hall of Fame Class of 2023 bio: John Casebeer

The 1963 Edmonds graduate spent 30 successful years as a wrestling coach in the Edmonds School District.

Most Read