Yanks have ‘best’ and ‘worst’ shortstop

BOSTON — Hit ‘em where they ain’t is ancient advice to baseball batters. Now statistics explain why it works.

Based on his time with the Texas Rangers, Alex Rodriguez is one of the game’s best shortstops, according to researchers led by Shane T. Jensen of the University of Pennsylvania. Rodriguez now plays third base for the New York Yankees.

Using a complex statistical method, researchers concluded that one of the worst at shortstop is A-Rod’s teammate, three-time Gold Glove-winner Derek Jeter. The findings were presented Saturday at the annual meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science.

That method involved looking at every ball put in play in major league baseball from 2002 through 2005 and recorded where the shots went. Researchers then developed a probability model for the average fielder in each position and compared that with the performance of individual players to see who was better or worse than average.

Comparing Jeter and A-Rod, Jensen said, “suggests the Yankees have one of the best defensive shortstops playing out of position in deference to one of the worst defensive shortstops.” A-Rod won two Gold Gloves as a shortstop before he came to New York in 2004.

The toughest outfielders to hit against were the Indians’ Jason Michaels, as well as Coco Crisp (now with the Boston Red Sox) and Gary Matthews Jr., currently playing for the Angels, they said.

The worst? Bobby Higginson, formerly of the Detroit Tigers; ex-Yankee Bernie Williams; and Wily Mo Pena, now with the Washington Nationals.

Success depended on a player’s range as well as good decision-making and positioning themselves well, said Jensen, an assistant professor of statistics at Penn’s Wharton School.

Jensen said balls put into play fell into two categories:

n—Grounders made up 42 percent. Fielding them required a player to move either left or right.

n Flies (33 percent) and liners (25 percent) make a fielder move left or right and either forward or backward.

Jensen said he expected fielders to do better running toward a fly to catch it. He was surprised that it turned out they were more successful moving backward. But it helped them that the ball was in the air longer.

Edward Aboufadel of Grand Valley State University in Allendale, Mich., said studies showed that outfielders try to run into a position where the ball appears to go straight up and straight down.

Some players, it seems, take a more direct route than others.

Jensen’s team of researchers found that most triples were hit to right field, where it is a much longer throw for the fielder.

Their final calculation came down to a measure called SAFE, Spatial Aggregate Fielding Evaluation. It calculated the number of runs a player saved or cost his team over a year. They used this to rank, and no doubt rankle, players.

Jensen said the group is now looking at the effect of the differences between ballparks on fielding.

The top three, and the worst, fielders (some of whom are no longer playing), based on the SAFE rankings, were:

n First base: Best, Ken Harvey, formerly with Kansas City; Doug Mientkiewicz, now with Pittsburgh; Eric Karros, formerly with the A’s and Dodgers; worst, Fred McGriff, formerly with Tampa Bay.

n Second base: Best, Craig Counsell of the Brewers; Brandon Phillips of the Reds; Chase Utley of the Phillies; worst, Enrique Wilson, who last played with the Cubs.

n Third base: Best, Damian Rolls, formerly with Tampa; Counsell; Placido Polanco of the Tigers; Worst, Travis Fryman, formerly with the Indians and Tigers.

n Shortstop: Best, Clint Barmes of the Rockies; Rodriguez; Jason Bartlett, traded from Minnesota to Tampa Bay in the offseason; worst, Jeter.

n Left field: Best, Crisp; Reed Johnson of the Blue Jays; Carl Crawford of Tampa Bay; worst, Higginson.

n Center field: Best, Michaels; Andruw Jones, now with the Dodgers; Darin Erstad, now with the Astros; Worst, Williams.

n Right field: Best, Matthews; Trot Nixon, who played with the Indians last year; Dustan Mohr, who last played for Tampa Bay; Worst, Pena.