An abandoned smelter chimney, a legacy of what once was the world’s largest copper mining operation, looms over the Anaconda valley in southwest Montana. (Louise Johns / For The Washington Post)

An abandoned smelter chimney, a legacy of what once was the world’s largest copper mining operation, looms over the Anaconda valley in southwest Montana. (Louise Johns / For The Washington Post)

A tiny Montana town’s toxic-waste battle reaches high court

The plaintiffs say federal law does not override Montana’s constitutionally guaranteed right to a “clean and healthful environment.”

  • By Kathleen McLaughlin The Washington Post
  • Sunday, December 1, 2019 4:53pm
  • Nation-World

By Kathleen McLaughlin / The Washington Post

OPPORTUNITY, Mont. — For a century, this tiny town has breathed beneath the long shadow of a colossal chimney. In fact, a mining behemoth created Opportunity specifically to prove it was safe to live in the path of the dark plume of smoke that billowed from the company’s copper smelter.

The plant is long shuttered, but the big stack looms 585 feet tall, the largest free-standing masonry structure in the world. Studies long ago shattered the company’s safety claims by linking high levels of arsenic and lead to serious health threats. These days, Opportunity is defined by its struggle to force powerful corporate and government interests to clean up the dangerous waste left behind.

After more than a decade of court battles, the Supreme Court on Tuesday will hear residents’ case against the property’s current owner. Theirs is more than just a David vs. Goliath confrontation — a rural community of 700 against Arco, a subsidiary of the oil giant BP — because of its potential for upending one of the nation’s key environmental laws.

Opportunity and its even smaller neighbor, Crackerville, want the justices to uphold a Montana Supreme Court ruling that found federal Superfund law does not override this state’s constitutionally guaranteed right to a “clean and healthful environment.” Arco, which appealed the decision, says it has already spent $470 million to reduce arsenic levels in the area. The towns say an additional $58 million is needed to lower those levels far more drastically.

The outcome of Atlantic Richfield Co. v. Christian holds significance well beyond this scenic valley in southwest Montana. Arco, as it is now known, argues that allowing individuals to sue in state court for greater cleanup than federal regulators require would nullify a key component of the Superfund program.

“The decision threatens the integrity of every future [Superfund] settlement EPA enters,” Arco has warned. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce and several industry groups agree, predicting “chaos” for sites nationwide should Opportunity prevail.

“It’s a really long struggle,” said Serge Myers, who in the early 2000s helped spearhead a citizens’ movement that led to the lawsuit. He is now a 74-year-old great-grandfather. “We only have one lifetime, and the corporations have forever. We just want our yard to be clean and healthy for our kids.”

For Myers, the dormant smelter stack represents the best job he ever had. He worked nearly 17 years at the Anaconda Copper Mining Co. plant, which was the lifeblood of the city of Anaconda and outlying communities. He started there in the early 1960s and moved through a series of jobs until the company sold its properties to Arco in 1977.

“The money was good, we were all union members. By the time it ended, I had five weeks of vacation a year and good benefits,” Myers recalled. “We had good jobs. We knew it was under smoky skies, but it was just part of the life, I guess. In smeltering cities, you just deal with it.”

Though the plant’s operations had slowed, Arco still stunned the region when it shut down the entire operation in November 1980 and eliminated the 1,000 remaining jobs. Even so, the people of Opportunity couldn’t have foreseen that the legal fight over toxic waste would outlive many of them. Myers guesses that a dozen of the nearly 100 residents who brought the lawsuit have died.

“I certainly thought we’d be treated better by the company than what we were,” he said.

Opportunity and Crackerville are part of the country’s biggest Superfund complex, toxic relics from the century of copper mining. The ore lay under nearby Butte and was extracted through a massive maze of tunnels and later an open pit; Anaconda, 30 miles away with plentiful water, got the giant smelter that processed the ore.

In the aftermath of the closure, as the region reeled economically and socially, residents began to piece together how much environmental damage the mega-mining had done.

Things got even worse around 2005, when bigger and much wealthier Missoula, 110 miles away, jumped to the front of the cleanup line as a dam with dangerous levels of toxic sludge was removed. Some 2.2 million cubic yards of waste were shipped back up the Clark Fork River and heaped on an already problematic dump site just outside Opportunity.

Robin Saha, an environmental studies professor at the University of Montana, began working with residents as troubles started to pile up. Cancer-causing arsenic and other heavy metals had infiltrated the land and nearby streams, and dust storms — their contents unknown — plagued the town.

Myers had collected reams of evidence on the waste but had no experience in getting the attention of environmental groups or government. Saha and a team of graduate students helped Opportunity organize.

“Usually we think of environmental justice involving communities of color being dumped on,” he said. “Environmental justice is also about low-income and communities that lack the know-how and resources to stand up for themselves. That description fit Opportunity to a T.”

The core issue now in court is arsenic. In the early years, residents shared stories of mass sickness and death among livestock. In more recent times, they’ve worried over land where grass just wouldn’t grow. Shaun Hoolahan, a petroleum engineer who grew up here but has lived all over the world, points to the benign tumors on his dog’s belly as he describes how she used to lie on a bare spot of his yard.

“That’s got me wondering, what’s really safe,” he said.

In their suit, residents are asking Arco to reduce arsenic levels in soil throughout the community to pre-contamination levels, around 10 times lower than the EPA-approved cleanup that brought them down to 250 parts per million. The company has pushed back against further remediation, saying “respondents’ soil-excavation plan risks spreading currently contained arsenic everywhere.”

If the state court ruling is upheld, Arco contends, “At any time, any landowner on any Superfund site could decide to shred EPA’s cleanup plans and impose different, and potentially detrimental, multimillion-dollar cleanups. The entire community would be hostage to the whims of a small minority of dissatisfied landowners.”

Hoolahan, who moved home to care for elderly parents, worries about both the safety of the town and the stigma attached to living in a Superfund site. Opportunity lies in the shadow of the stunning Pintlar mountain range, within easy distance to pristine hiking trails, lakes and skiing, but it’s never become a recreational hub or a place with strong property values. Hoolahan rubs his forefingers and thumb together — the symbol of money — as he talks about the reason.

“If this were Palm Springs, it would be a whole different matter,” he said.

People here are wary of the Supreme Court’s involvement, in part because the attorney arguing Arco’s case was a prominent supporter of Justice Brett Kavanaugh’s nomination last year. While such connections are not unusual in Washington, it does add to a decades-long list of actions that have made Opportunity residents feel like the deck is stacked against them.

No matter what the justices conclude, one of the residents’ lawyers stresses that Opportunity’s effort won’t end. According to Justin Stalpes, there are other legal avenues yet to pursue.

“The people of Opportunity,” Stalpes noted, “have been fighting the powers that be since the inception of the town.”

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Nation-World

FILE - Britain's Queen Elizabeth II looks on during a visit to officially open the new building at Thames Hospice, Maidenhead, England July 15, 2022. Buckingham Palace says Queen Elizabeth II is under medical supervision as doctors are “concerned for Her Majesty’s health.” The announcement comes a day after the 96-year-old monarch canceled a meeting of her Privy Council and was told to rest. (Kirsty O'Connor/Pool Photo via AP, File)
Queen Elizabeth II dead at 96 after 70 years on the throne

Britain’s longest-reigning monarch and a rock of stability across much of a turbulent century died Thursday.

A woman reacts as she prepares to leave an area for relatives of the passengers aboard China Eastern's flight MU5735 at the Guangzhou Baiyun International Airport, Tuesday, March 22, 2022, in Guangzhou. No survivors have been found as rescuers on Tuesday searched the scattered wreckage of a China Eastern plane carrying 132 people that crashed a day earlier on a wooded mountainside in China's worst air disaster in more than a decade. (AP Photo/Ng Han Guan)
No survivors found in crash of Boeing 737 in China

What caused the plane to drop out of the sky shortly before it was to being its descent remained a mystery.

In this photo taken by mobile phone released by Xinhua News Agency, a piece of wreckage of the China Eastern's flight MU5735 are seen after it crashed on the mountain in Tengxian County, south China's Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region on Monday, March 21, 2022. A China Eastern Boeing 737-800 with 132 people on board crashed in a remote mountainous area of southern China on Monday, officials said, setting off a forest fire visible from space in the country's worst air disaster in nearly a decade. (Xinhua via AP)
Boeing 737 crashes in southern China with 132 aboard

More than 15 hours after communication was lost with the plane, there was still no word of survivors.

In this photo taken from video provided by the Ukrainian Presidential Press Office, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy speaks to the nation in Kyiv, Ukraine, Sunday, Feb. 27, 2022. Street fighting broke out in Ukraine's second-largest city Sunday and Russian troops put increasing pressure on strategic ports in the country's south following a wave of attacks on airfields and fuel facilities elsewhere that appeared to mark a new phase of Russia's invasion. (Ukrainian Presidential Press Office via AP)
Ukraine wants EU membership, but accession often takes years

President Volodymyr Zelenskyy’s request has enthusiastic support from several member states.

FILE - Ukrainian servicemen walk by fragments of a downed aircraft,  in in Kyiv, Ukraine, Friday, Feb. 25, 2022. The International Criminal Court's prosecutor has put combatants and their commanders on notice that he is monitoring Russia's invasion of Ukraine and has jurisdiction to prosecute war crimes and crimes against humanity. But, at the same time, Prosecutor Karim Khan acknowledges that he cannot investigate the crime of aggression. (AP Photo/Oleksandr Ratushniak, File)
ICC prosecutor to open probe into war crimes in Ukraine

U.N. human rights chief Michelle Bachelet confirmed that 102 civilians have been killed.

FILE - Refugees fleeing conflict from neighboring Ukraine arrive to Zahony, Hungary, Sunday, Feb. 27, 2022. As hundreds of thousands of Ukrainians seek refuge in neighboring countries, cradling children in one arm and clutching belongings in the other, leaders in Poland, Hungary, Bulgaria, Moldova and Romania are offering a hearty welcome. (AP Photo/Anna Szilagyi, File)
Europe welcomes Ukrainian refugees — others, less so

It is a stark difference from treatment given to migrants and refugees from the Middle East and Africa.

Afghan evacuees disembark the plane and board a bus after landing at Skopje International Airport, North Macedonia, on Wednesday, Sept. 15, 2021. North Macedonia has hosted another group of 44 Afghan evacuees on Wednesday where they will be sheltered temporarily till their transfer to final destinations. (AP Photo/Boris Grdanoski)
‘They are safe here.’ Snohomish County welcomes hundreds of Afghans

The county’s welcoming center has been a hub of services and assistance for migrants fleeing Afghanistan since October.

FILE - In this April 15, 2019, file photo, a vendor makes change for a marijuana customer at a cannabis marketplace in Los Angeles. An unwelcome trend is emerging in California, as the nation's most populous state enters its fifth year of broad legal marijuana sales. Industry experts say a growing number of license holders are secretly operating in the illegal market — working both sides of the economy to make ends meet. (AP Photo/Richard Vogel, File)
In California pot market, a hazy line between legal and not

Industry insiders say the practice of working simultaneously in the legal and illicit markets is a financial reality.

19 dead, including 9 children, in NYC apartment fire

More than five dozen people were injured and 13 people were still in critical condition in the hospital.

15 dead after Russian skydiver plane crashes

The L-410, a Czech-made twin-engine turboprop, crashed near the town of Menzelinsk.

FILE - In this March 29, 2018, file photo, the logo for Facebook appears on screens at the Nasdaq MarketSite in New York's Times Square. Facebook prematurely turned off safeguards designed to thwart misinformation and rabble rousing after Joe Biden defeated Donald Trump in the 2020 elections in a moneymaking move that a company whistleblower alleges contributed to the deadly Jan. 6, 2021, invasion of the U.S. Capitol. (AP Photo/Richard Drew, File)
Facebook, WhatsApp, Instagram in hourslong worldwide outage

Something made the social media giant’s routes inaccessable to the rest of the internet.

Oil washed up on Huntington Beach, Calif., on Sunday, Oct. 3, 2021. A major oil spill off the coast of Southern California fouled popular beaches and killed wildlife while crews scrambled Sunday to contain the crude before it spread further into protected wetlands. (AP Photo/Ringo H.W. Chiu)
Crews race to limited damage from California oil spill

At least 126,000 gallons (572,807 liters) of oil spilled into the waters off Orange County.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.