Kate Lunceford has complaints about the use and treatment of trees in new construction in Bothell. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)

Kate Lunceford has complaints about the use and treatment of trees in new construction in Bothell. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)

League of Women Voters has a new mission: Defend urban trees

With a focus on climate change, the Snohomish County branch wants to preserve the urban tree canopy.

This is the second of three Daily Herald stories looking at how climate change threatens our urban trees and highlights their value in helping us cope with it.

EVERETT — Looking for a way to combat climate change, the League of Women Voters of Snohomish County decided to protect urban trees.

As she assessed Snohomish County’s tree permitting process, Kate Lunceford found herself looking ruefully at a row of evergreens that had been chopped off at 4 feet, a developer’s plans showing sidewalk-shading lindens that were never planted, and a dozen Western red cedars that were planted 12 feet apart even though each tree’s canopy is destined to spread out 25 feet.

She concluded the county’s tree code was insufficient and unenforced.

“It was kind of laughable,” Lunceford said.

Lunceford spearheads the nonprofit group’s tree campaign. Members chose the subject because trees pull planet-warming carbon dioxide from the air and store it. They also reduce the impacts of extreme weather by providing shade, releasing cooling vapor and slowing stormwater runoff.

The campaign’s goals are to support policies designed to protect tree canopy, boost public awareness of its value, and find partners to take up the cause.

The League took a big policy step when members convinced Snohomish County Councilmember Megan Dunn to sponsor the addition of an updated tree policy to the 2024 Comprehensive Plan.

It wasn’t a tough sell.

“They had me at ‘Hello,’” Dunn said.

She proposed an amendment to the comprehensive plan’s natural resources section.

The biggest improvement to county policy, Dunn believes, would be a new emphasis on tree protection as a way of coping with the climate crisis. The update also would represent “a mindset change — to start to consider our tree canopy from a holistic and comprehensive standpoint.”

Often, council members hear about trees when residents are upset about a planned development. As an example, Dunn mentioned Frognal Estates, for which land has been cleared south of Mukilteo.

“Frognal was a controversial project that got a stay, then was appealed. It was something that raised awareness about the lack of protection for trees and quality of life,” she said.

Site preparation for housing development was under way June 8 at the property known as Frognal Estates near Edmonds. (Chuck Taylor / Herald file)

Site preparation for housing development was under way June 8 at the property known as Frognal Estates near Edmonds. (Chuck Taylor / Herald file)

The County Council must decide by Feb. 22 whether they will include the amendment in the draft 2024 plan. Next comes environmental review and the chance for public comment. The process can be followed on the Comprehensive Plan Update page, https://bit.ly/SnoCo2024.

Dunn’s amendment began as a document provided by the League of Women Voters and was modified with input from the county’s Planning and Development Services Department. Modeled after the 2008 Evergreen Community Act, its stated purposes include replacing “the policies and regulations that are not adequately protecting our urban trees and our environment.”

The amendment calls for the creation of a county urban forestry plan, and aims to protect trees on county-owned lands and along transportation corridors. But its potential for new regulations on land development is likely to get the most scrutiny. An estimated 95.5% of population growth in the next 20 years is expected to be within the county’s unincorporated urban growth areas. There is built-in tension between providing enough housing and protecting landscapes.

County tree permits are like construction permits. They must be acquired before a development is approved. Snohomish County didn’t require them until 2009. Initially, permitting rules focused on retaining trees that were on-site or preserving nearby trees to make up for any losses.

Fir trees were chopped at four feet at a 2017 housing development in Bothell. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)

Fir trees were chopped at four feet at a 2017 housing development in Bothell. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)

Builders found the rules burdensome. Among other complaints to the county, they argued that tree inventories cost too much. And that developers were avoiding heavily forested sites because it was too hard to comply with the rules. Planning department staffers became concerned the permit process would keep the county from reaching its goal of increasing housing in urban growth areas to protect rural and resource lands from development.

So, in 2014, the county changed the rules. Now, developers must present plans that show a certain percentage of tree canopy will be present 20 years after construction. For example, developments with 10 or more lots will eventually need 30% tree cover.

“We’re big believers in the approach Snohomish County has taken,” said Mike Pattison, government affairs manager for the Master Builders Association of King and Snohomish Counties. “There is administrative authority over tree planning. There is oversight. It’s not done willy-nilly.”

Plus, he said, builders are required to take out bonds assuring the trees’ survival. “We’re on the hook financially.”

(Snohomish County)

(Snohomish County)

To see if the permit system is working, the League of Women Voters reviewed the 10 biggest developments approved in 2017. An arborist went along on three of the visits. Lunceford wrote a report documenting that trees weren’t given enough space, weren’t planted properly or weren’t species that would live beyond 20 years, defeating the 30% canopy goal. In only one instance, she said, was a problem so bad that the county took action.

She thinks planning department officials have good intentions when it comes to site plan review and oversight, “but nobody’s got the staff.”

Michael Dobesh, permitting division manager, said the permitting planning group usually consists of 10 people. He doesn’t think it would help to have more staff. David Killingstad, manager of long-range planning, noted that permit enforcement is driven not by inspections, but by complaints.

Trees at a 2017 housing development in Bothell are outgrowing supporting cables. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)

Trees at a 2017 housing development in Bothell are outgrowing supporting cables. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)

A property owner who removes a tree probably knows nothing about the agreement to protect it. The American National Standards Committee for Tree Care recommends that a maintenance plan be handed off from builder to owner. “That rarely happens,” said committee member Tom Smiley, a Washington arboricultural researcher.

Consulting arborist Scott Baker would like to see local governments send every home buyer a letter saying, “Congratulations on your new home. Here is what your builder agreed to do.” Then again, he wonders if tree protection should even be “dumped on” owners. Maybe the urban forest should be considered a utility and managed for the common good, said Baker, co-founder of Seattle-based Tree Solutions.

That approach would likely collide head-on with the perspective of property rights activists.

Lunceford is keenly aware of such differing opinions. Everybody loves trees, she said, but nobody wants to be told what to do with them.

Julie Titone is an Everett writer who can be reached at julietitone@icloud.com. Her stories are supported by the Herald’s Environmental and Climate Reporting Fund. To contribute, go to HeraldNet.com/climatedonate.


About this series

This three-part Daily Herald series looks at how climate change threatens our urban trees and highlights their value in helping us cope with it.

Part 1: Two of the Pacific Northwest’s most iconic trees, the Western red cedar and hemlock, are most stressed by new extremes in heat and rainfall. As regional conditions rapidly evolve, experts are changing their advice about what to plant.

This story: A local campaign to protect urban trees finds permitting regulations for developers sorely lacking. Its efforts may result in a more tree- and climate-friendly Snohomish County Comprehensive Plan.

Part 3: What’s a forest garden? A great way to grow edibles during a time of climate change, says a conservation planner. A Bothell man incorporates the idea into his all-out effort to turn a yard into a climate-friendly food system.

Environmental Reporting Fund

If you’d like to see more stories like this, donate to The Daily Herald’s Environmental and Climate Change Reporting Fund in partnership with Journalism Funding Partners. Go to heraldnet.com/climatedonate.

Talk to us

More in Local News

Angelica Montanari and daughter Makena, 1, outside of the Community Health Center of Snohomish County Everett-Central Clinic on Thursday, Feb. 2, 2023. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Providers at Community Health Center of Snohomish County vote to form a union

Providers expressed hope for improving patient care and making their voices heard with management.

Granite Falls
Two suspects charged in motorhome shooting near Granite Falls

Bail was set at $2 million for each of the suspects, Dillon Thomas, 28 and David Koeppen, 37.

Logo for news use, for stories regarding Washington state government — Olympia, the Legislature and state agencies. No caption necessary. 20220331
Supreme Court rules state’s new capital gains tax is legal

The 7-2 ruling clears the way for collection of payments starting next month. The tax is expected to bring in $500 million a year.

NO CAPTION NECESSARY: Logo for the Cornfield Report by Jerry Cornfield. 20200112
A thumbs up for capital gains, kind words for the Senate budget

It’s Day 75. Here’s what’s happening in the 2023 session of the Washington Legislature

A residential home is demolished at what will be the site of a new Lake Stevens Library on Wednesday, March 22, 2023 in Lake Stevens, Washington. (Sophia Gates / The Herald).
Site clearing begins for new Lake Stevens library

The initial work on Chapel Hill property brings dream of a new library closer to reality.

Rep. June Robinson, D-38
Schools, housing, salaries score big in Senate Dems $70B budget

The proposed spending plan also spends money to fight climate change, help abortion providers and study police pursuits

Dr. J. Matthew Lacy, Chief Medical Examiner for Snohomish County, answers preliminary questions from the state regarding his qualifications and experience as a medical examiner during the trial of Richard Rotter on Thursday, March 23, 2023, at Snohomish County Superior Court in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
At Rotter trial, debate breaks out over graphic autopsy photos

A judge ruled some close-ups of Everett officer Dan Rocha’s injuries could be used, while others were ruled out.

In this side-by-side image, the Totem Diner and Pacific Stone Company signs put on a flirty display for all to see Wednesday, March 22, 2023, in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Signs of love on Rucker Ave: blushing rocks, scrambled eggs, a coffee date

Messages on display on Totem Family Diner and Pacific Stone Co. signs reveal “secret crushes.” More updates expected.

Brenda Mann Harrison
Encounters with a tow truck driver and a dentist

The value of local journalism shows up in unexpected conversations.

Most Read