South Whidbey cop killer is still appealing 1987 conviction

Darrin Hutchinson murdered two Island County deputies 34 years ago at the county jail in Coupeville.

By Jessie Stensland / Whidbey News-Times

A man who shot and killed two deputies in the Island County jail 34 years ago is still trying to appeal his murder convictions.

Representing himself, Darrin R. Hutchinson filed a petition for writ of habeas corpus and a motion for a report of proceedings this year in Island County Superior Court.

Judge Carolyn Cliff denied both.

Since 1987, Hutchinson has filed at least three personal restraint petitions in various courts, a federal petition for habeas corpus and several other appeals and related motions.

Hutchinson was initially successful with the state Court of Appeals, which vacated his convictions in 1997. The state Supreme Court, however, reversed the lower court’s decision and upheld his conviction.

On Nov. 14, 1987, Hutchinson — a South Whidbey resident known to law enforcement — shot and killed two Island County deputies, William Heffernan and John Saxerud, in the Breathalyzer room at the county jail in Coupeville following his arrest on a driving violation. Hutchinson had concealed a .32-caliber pistol.

After the shooting, Hutchinson took a key from Saxerud’s pocket, stole a patrol car and later drove it into a ravine. He was arrested a short while later walking to his parents’ house and confessed to the murders, saying he shot the deputies because they had assaulted him.

His trial was complicated when his attorney disclosed that Hutchinson might put forward a diminished capacity defense; the attorney advised Hutchinson not to submit to a psychiatric exam by the prosecutor’s expert, even after the trial judge and the state Supreme Court ruled that he had to.

In response, the judge sanctioned Hutchinson by excluding three mental health experts who would have testified regarding his diminished capacity defense.

On June 30, 1989, a jury found Hutchinson guilty of two counts of aggravated first-degree murder. He was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

In 1997, the Court of Appeals reversed the conviction, finding the trial judge erred in excluding the defense experts from testifying and in allowing an outdated jury instruction regarding self defense.

Then the state Supreme Court reinstated the conviction, finding that the exclusion of the witnesses was an appropriate sanction and that a different jury instruction made up for the shortcomings of the first.

The U.S. Supreme Court denied his petition for a writ of certiorari.

Hutchinson, however, hasn’t given up on his appeals from behind bars at the Clallam Bay Corrections Center.

This story originally appeared in the Whidbey News-Times, a sister publication to The Herald.

Talk to us

More in Local News

People wait in line for amusement park tickets during opening day of the Evergreen State Fair on Thursday, Aug. 26, 2021 in Monroe, Wash. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
At limited capacity, Evergreen State Fair draws 181,000

Organizers say this year’s visitors enjoyed experiencing the fair with “a little more shoulder room.”

In 2023, the Department of Transportation will widen a two-mile stretch of Highway 531 from 43rd Avenue NE to 67th Avenue NE. (WSDOT)
Smokey Point road improvements won’t be done before industrial center

Amazon, NorthPoint are coming but the state will not begin widening Highway 531 until 2023.

Construction continues at the site of the former Kmart for 400 apartments. and is slated for completion in 2023. Photo on September 14, 2021. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Coming soon to Everett, 430 apartments at former Kmart site

DevCo, Inc. is building six-story apartments “for the workforce” on Evergreen Way, near Boeing Freeway.

Federal vax rules apply to half of Snohomish County workers

The Labor Department hasn’t issued guidance yet, but here’s what we know so far.

Police: Mill Creek man, 63, accidentally shot by son

Detectives believe the dad was mistaken as an intruder. The injuries are not life threatening.

Man found dead in homeless camp Friday in Mountlake Terrace

His identity and cause of death are pending.

Family identifies Marysville woman found dead at Stevens Pass

Officials are investigating the death, which they called a homicide.

Marilla Sargent presents Amit Singh, Edmonds College president, a check supporting the Project Home Association at Edmonds College. (Edmonds College)
HomeStreet Bank gives $5,000 for Edmonds College students facing homelessness

HomeStreet Bank donated $5,000 to Edmonds College’s Project Home Association, which provides… Continue reading

South Whidbey public records advocate blasts cities’ responses

Eric Hood has collected about $1 million in Public Records Act lawsuits.

Most Read