Comment: America’s confused obsession with Mary Kay Letourneau

There was a faction of the population that was willing to treat the rape saga as a fairy tale.

By Monica Hesse / The Washington Post

Until reading that Mary Kay Letourneau had died this week at age 58, the last time I remember being shocked by her name was in 2009, after stumbling across an online flier promoting a “Hot For Teacher” night at a Seattle sports bar. The DJ was Vili Fualaau, the man Letourneau had raped when he was 12 or 13 and she was a 34-year-old teacher. The evening’s special guest star, in a plug that the bar obviously expected to play well with fans, was Mary Kay Letourneau.

By that point, she was sometimes going by Mary Kay Fualaau. She’d married her victim upon her 2004 release from prison. Their timeline — briefly, for those who weren’t glued to news in the mid-1990s — was as follows: In 1996, police found Letourneau in the back seat of a car with Fualaau, but she wasn’t arrested until nearly a year later when she was already pregnant with Fualaau’s daughter. Discharged from prison after serving only a few months, she immediately disobeyed court orders and saw him again. They conceived another child. Letourneau went back to prison, this time for six years.

“Entertainment Tonight” negotiated “exclusive access” to their wedding. The show meted out details about secret invitations and luxurious motor coach transportation. “Mary Kay and Vili trusted ‘ET’ and ‘The Insider’ to tell their story,” a producer gushed at the time.

If the fawning coverage seems nauseating to you, or at least head-spinning, then you have properly situated yourself with an unobstructed view the facts of this story. Letourneau was a rapist, but there was a faction of the population that was still willing to treat this as a fairy tale.

There were the newlyweds, then 43 and 22, posing with their two daughters in flower-girl white. A decade later, there was the couple again, celebrating their 10th anniversary with Barbara Walters. Letourneau loved watching Fualaau with their daughters, she told Walters in the interview. Fualaau was frustrated by accounts that portrayed him as a victim, he said. Letourneau hoped to teach again, she said, if only she could get off the sex-offender registry.

Every bit of this was confounding. Did Letourneau actually believe she should again be given access to children? Was Fualaau wrapped in protective self-denial, convincing himself that he’d been an equal participant in what was obviously a predatory relationship? Were we wrapped in denial, forcing a now 30-something man to be labeled a victim for the rest of his life?

For a while in the 1990s and early 2000s, pretty female teachers molesting their underage male students seemed like an epidemic. Christine McCallum and Christine Scarlett, Debra LaFave and Hope Jacoby. But then you started to wonder whether it really was an epidemic or whether tabloids just knew they could catch a lot of readers by trawling through the Myspace profiles of pouty social studies instructors and detailing how naughty they’d been. Female students abused by male teachers have encountered their own measure of victim blame but not usually accompanied by the same level of tittering: the implication that these horny teenage boys probably wanted it, and were lucky to get it.

“There are still people who are shocked and disgusted,” Walters said in an interview about her interview. “But, you know, they’ve been married 10 years.” It wasn’t clear what Walters considered to be the appropriate moral statute of limitations — the duration of time in which the marriage between a rapist and her victim eclipses the crime — but it seemed that in her mind, Letourneau and Fualaau had cleared it.

There was the couple, year after year. As societal conversations about sexual assault became more nuanced, Letourneau stuck stubbornly to the simpler narrative that they were star-crossed soul mates. Or maybe that this was a manifestation of every adolescent boy’s fantasy. Repeatedly, she insisted that he had been the pursuer (hot for teacher and all). When prompted, he agreed.

Would we believe it? Would we buy the idea that deeply disturbing origin stories can end with happily-ever-afters? Or would we always suspect that sometimes damage runs so deep that a happy ending is really just a victim telling himself, and Barbara Walters, what he needs to in order to make the story of his life — and the relationship that shaped it — make sense?

Eventually the relationship ended. The couple filed for legal separation, finally splitting residences last year. Letourneau got sick with cancer and died on Monday. A lawyer for the family told People magazine that Fualaau had been at her side. “He knew that this was Mary’s end coming, fast moving, and for her sake and the family’s sake, and for his sake, he came back up and was with her, and it meant the world to her.”

I couldn’t help but notice, back a few years ago, that it was Fualaau who had filed the court documents for separation.

By then they would have been married 14 years, a reputable length for any marriage. Fualaau was in his mid-30s, about the same age Letourneau had been when she encountered Fualaau in her sixth-grade classroom at Shorewood Elementary. On an Australian television program featuring the entire family, an interviewer asked Fualaau what he would say to his younger self.

“Don’t do it!” he said, laughing.

He added that he regretted nothing because he loved his daughters. They were college-aged at the time of the interview. Barely adults. Still years older than their father had been when he met Mary Kay.

Monica Hesse is a columnist for The Washington Post’s Style section, who frequently writes about gender and its impact on society. She’s the author of several novels, most recently, “They Went Left.” Follow her on Twitter @MonicaHesse.

Talk to us

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Sunday, Aug. 9

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Editorial: Debate regarding Snake River dams is far from over

If we are to avoid the extinction of salmon runs and orcas, talks regarding the dams should continue.

Viewpoints: Fighting a pandemic of disinformation

Rumors are a problem, but intentional disinformation can raise havoc with democratic institutions.

Commentary: State must do more to protect farmworkers’ health

State health and labor agencies must do more to enforce laws meant to protect workers during the pandemic.

Commentary: Wildlife killing contests aren’t good management

Competitions, such as those for killing coyotes, can work against the interests of ranchers and others.

Legitimate visa requests are ignored by State Department

As we work through this pandemic, one group of people being largely… Continue reading

How does assessor come up with home values for taxes?

I recently received my notice of property assessed value. The average tax… Continue reading

Wear your mask and leave decision to others

Many people have an opinion about mask wearing. Some are for it… Continue reading

Editorial cartoons for Saturday, Aug. 8

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Most Read