Commentary: Is any state fund safe during a budget year?

By Brendan Williams

In 2007, following a years-long legislative push, Washington state adopted a paid family leave law. Much fanfare accompanied the new law’s passage, to begin providing benefits Oct. 1, 2009. One advocacy group proclaimed it “a giant step forward for Washington’s mothers, fathers, children and families.”

There was a small catch, though — the law wasn’t funded.

It had passed the Senate on a bipartisan 32-17 margin with a small payroll tax, a tax that remained intact through the House policy committee I served on, before being gutted in the House at the behest of Gov. Chris Gregoire and House Speaker Frank Chopp. Both had suggested punting to voters. Many angry former Senate supporters then voted against the eviscerated bill. The Olympian put it well: “All sizzle, no steak — it’s a pretty lousy way to legislate.”

I agreed; finding this empty exercise way too mortifying to even mention to constituents, let alone brag about as we were urged to. The Legislature first voted in 2009 to delay implementation, doing so again in 2011 and 2013.

This year finally brought a funded law. With bemusement I read about its signing, where Chopp stood front-and-center crowing about “the largest expansion of Social Security in Washington state in the last 50 years” — and claiming he pushed it for 30 years. Credit really goes to those like Des Moines Sen. Karen Keiser, sponsor of the 2007 law who never gave up, Everett Rep. June Robinson, advocacy groups, and those in the business community who accepted the reform’s public appeal. As The Herald editorialized in February, “For a decade Washington state has had a paid family leave law — but in name only.”

Memories are short in politics, where each session sometimes seems like the movie “Groundhog Day.” Yet we must learn from the past lest we be bamboozled in the present. A similar pattern exists with regard to K-12 funding, with the Legislature again declaring the state’s “paramount duty” has — at long last — been met.

Yet what Chopp trumpeted as “a great victory for funding our public schools” is already being challenged before the Washington Supreme Court for its inadequacy under the court’s McCleary decision. The Seattle Public Schools that he represents declared, in an Aug. 25 press release, “The public is being told the Legislature solved the state’s education funding crisis. The truth is, they did not.” Similarly false claims have been made biennially since the McCleary litigation began, in 2007.

As tenuous as this year’s budget is it would not surprise me to see the new Family and Medical Leave Insurance Account tapped into someday to prop up the operating budget. Why not? That’s been the fate of the Tobacco Prevention and Control Account since 2009, even though, in passing I-773 to increase the cigarette tax, 66 percent of voters required the state to spend proceeds on smoking cessation. Indeed, the current state budget feasts upon $328 million in fund transfers, including a funding stream that voters, in 1988, had dedicated to toxic cleanup.

Time will tell if such trickery, in the long-term, makes progress more substantive than an unfunded law did over a decade’s time. Will that law’s long ordeal teach us anything?

Brendan Williams is an attorney, former state representative (2005-10), and frequent writer from Olympia.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

FILE — Supporters of President Donald Trump storm the U.S. Capitol in Washington, Jan. 6, 2021. The Supreme Court’s ruling that Trump enjoyed broad immunity from prosecution over official acts has opened the possibility that more evidence in his attempt to subvert the 2020 election could be revealed in public court filings — maybe even before the upcoming presidential election. (Kenny Holston/The New York Times)
Editorial: As important as voting is acceptance of voters’ will

Regardless of outcome, voters must acknowledge the result, then work within democracy’s framework.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Thursday, Nov. 7

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Our leaders must reconcile, work together

Never in my 16 cycles of voting have I seen our country… Continue reading

Time to move on and put personal over political

Since getting older I have grown tired of political opinions. The idea… Continue reading

Reform needed for flood insurance after disasters

A recent commentary in The Herald notes that the number of properties… Continue reading

Comment: Finding hope in the ‘good bones’ of a democracy

Despair is always an option; it’s going backward that we have to avoid.

Stephens: How could the Democrats lose against Trump?

You can start with their dismissiveness in recognizing the economic hardships of fellow Americans.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, Nov. 6

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Burke: Nothing beats a mystery for waiting out election results

When you’re waiting for the Electoral College numbers to drop, you might as well watch some bodies drop.

It’s troubled, but we need Boeing

Proud Boeing has lost its way, but we in the Pacific Northwest,… Continue reading

Herald staff have provided excellent coverage for election

Though I’ve meant to write applauding many excellent Letters to the Editor,… Continue reading

Sid Schwab isn’t only one baffled by Trump’s allure

Just back from a few days immersed in a four-part a cappella… Continue reading

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.