One-size-fits-all test isn’t the answer

Evidently, Mr. Gordon Dewey of Granite Falls thinks we are doing a disservice to our children by opting them out of taking a flawed test (Letters, April 29: “Kudos to those who are opting out”), that somehow missing one test is going to negate their years of education. Can he really believe that one test will make or break a child’s education? Wow, he must think the WASL is the answer we have all been searching for to help our kids learn how to be successful in the world. It isn’t.

I know that the teachers and students in Granite Falls (and elsewhere) are working hard to pass this test. Kids wouldn’t be stressed out over it if they weren’t taking it seriously. Teachers are trying their best to prepare them for passing. Graduation will soon depend upon a student’s ability to pass. When Mr. Dewey’s child needs workers, there shouldn’t be any problem gathering a workforce – last year’s passing rate for Granite Falls High School 10th graders was 36.7 percent. There will be plenty of kids without diplomas to work for his child after 2008.

Having a non-compliant “zero” on a transcript is better than “failure to meet standards” on it, in my opinion. There is no such thing as a standard child.

Standards and accountability? We’re all for them. An unproven, wasteful, flawed, one-size-fits-all test? No.

Rachel DeBellis

Marysville

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Sunday, Feb. 15

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Getty Images
Editorial: Lawmakers should outline fairness of millionaires tax

How the revenue will be used, in part to make state taxes less regressive, is key to its acceptance.

A horse near transmission lines in Houston, Sept. 20, 2023. Texas has grown to be the second-largest solar power producer in the country. (Annie Mulligan / The New York Times)
Comment: Two energy roads, different futures for world’s climate

The paths for fossil fuels and renewables are set, with countries choosing diverging road maps.

The Buzz: In celebration of bunnies, from Bugs to Bad

We can’t help but see some characteristics shared between Elmer Fudd and Donald Trump.

Comment: Revolutionary War fought by ordinary men and women

Early battles, such as at Moore’s Creek Bridge, and won by volunteer loyalists inspired others to join the fight.

Restore state funding to vital childcare support program

Childcare is not optional. It is part of our infrastructure, just like… Continue reading

Comment: Our response when federal disaster help is a disaster

With federal emergency aid in doubt, the state, localities and communities must team up to prepare.

Comment: Tire dust killing salmon; state must bar chemical’s use

A chemical called 6PPD produces a toxin that kills coho. A ban by 2035 can add to efforts to save fish.

Comment: Hosptials staying true to Congress’ drug discounts

Nonprofit hospitals aren’t abusing the 340B pricing program. The fault lies with profit-taking drugmakers.

Forum: The long internal battle against our unrecognized bias

Growing up where segregation was the norm forced a unconscious bias that takes effort to confront.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.