Saunders: Convicted murderer’s claims work onlly on gullible

A California man on death row insisted DNA testing would clear him, until it put him at the crime scene.

By Debra J. Saunders / syndicated columnist

Kevin Cooper used to tell reporters that he wanted DNA testing, which didn’t exist when he went to trial, to prove that he was not guilty of the four 1983 murders that put him on California’s death row. If the tests implicated him, he said, he would drop his appeals.

In 2000, Cooper got those tests; and they nailed him.

DNA tests placed Cooper in the Chino Hills home of chiropractors Doug and Peggy Ryen, who were found dead with their daughter Jessica, 10, and houseguest Christopher Hughes, 11. The Ryens’ 8-year-old son Josh somehow survived after he was left for dead with a slit throat. At trial, Cooper had denied entering the Ryen home.

Cooper, who had escaped the California Institution for Men and was hiding out at an unoccupied house near the Ryen home, testified he didn’t drive the Ryen station wagon as he fled the scene of the crime; but DNA testing of cigarette butts established he had been in the family car.

Unphased, Cooper and his team of corporate lawyers came up with a new story; that the positive DNA test proved Cooper had been framed. How else could his DNA have been there?

And since it’s California, gullible politicians have gone along with this bogus version of events.

Gov. Gavin Newsom recently signed an executive order directing the law firm of Morrison and Foerster to conduct “an independent investigation” into Cooper’s case because prosecutors and defense hold “starkly different views regarding how the results should be interpreted.” Overwhelming evidence couldn’t compete with the NAACP and movie stars proclaiming Cooper’s innocence and blaming the conviction on racism, Criminal Justice Legal Foundation head Michael Rushford offered.

In 2004, when I worked at the San Francisco Chronicle, a group of high-profile lawyers sat with the editorial board and laid out an intriguing case about how an innocent man, Kevin Cooper, had been framed.

I looked into it. In short order, I talked to two men who had worked for Cooper’s defense team; only to reject his claim of innocence.

That never happens.

Investigator and former cop Paul Ingels had supported Cooper’s quest for DNA tests because he believed in following evidence where it leads. Later, when DNA tests put Cooper at the scene of the crime, Ingels told me in 2004, “It proves, beyond any shadow of a doubt, that Kevin Cooper was involved in the murders.” As for the defense team’s claim that Cooper was framed: “They’re just making this stuff up.”

Forensics ace Dr. Edward T. Blake, who boasted involvement in “more post-conviction exonerations than anybody in the world,” told me he resented how Cooper’s claim of being framed cast doubt on “a legitimate process that’s out there to save people who are actually innocent.”

Two guys who worked on the defense essentially say Cooper’s guilty; that’s something you won’t read in Nick Kristof’s Cooper-friendly New York Times columns.

Kristof writes that he cannot know for sure if Cooper is innocent, but he’s more than happy to repeat the defense smear against those who put Cooper away, presumably because he is Black and they are racists.

Kristof wrote that authorities disregarded three white suspects once they saw a mug shot of “a black man with a huge Afro who fit their narrative of an incorrigible criminal” with an arrest record going back to when he was 7.

Wrong, San Bernardino District Attorney Jason Anderson responded. Authorities interviewed three other suspects, including a one-time convicted killer whom Kristof identifies by his first name, Lee, but all three had alibis that checked out.

Defense attorneys won’t recognize the damning evidence. That’s to be expected.

What Californians should not accept is a governor who won’t stand up for victims, a jury verdict and the conclusion of post-conviction evidentiary hearings.

It’s been “38 years since our son was killed, and we still don’t have justice,” Christopher’s mother, Mary Ann Hughes, told me over the phone. Her husband, Bill, still has flashbacks of the moment he found his son’s lifeless body in the bloodied Ryen home.

“If it’s just going to be what the governor wants,” she added, “we might as well get rid of courts and trials.”

It’s clear Cooper won’t be executed, even though a jury sentenced him to death in 1985. To no one’s surprise, Newsom suspended California’s death penalty in 2019, and voters aren’t likely to elect a governor who will use it.

By letting this charade continue unchecked, Newsom has signaled that he doesn’t care if Cooper is guilty and he can’t be bothered to sort it out.

Debra J. Saunders is a fellow at the Discovery Institute’s Chapman Center for Citizen Leadership. Email her at

Talk to us

More in Opinion

RGB version
Editorial cartoons for Thursday, May 19

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Ferries pass on a crossing between Mukilteo and Whidbey Island. (Andy Bronson / Herald file)
Editorial: Up to graduates to take us where we want to go

A lack of workers has limited Amtrak and the state ferry system. Graduates need to train for those jobs.

Problem on Highway 99 isn’t speeders; it’s jaywalkers

The Everett City Council passing a resolution to lower speeds on Evergreen… Continue reading

Big difference between ‘my body, my choice’ camps

Regarding a recent letter to the editor regarding rights regarding abortion and… Continue reading

Comment: Laws aimed at trans kids make everyone less safe

Using laws as a weapon against trans kids and families will undermine trust in the justice system.

Comment: What Trump’s election scorecard says about GOP voters

His mixed record on primary endorsements means GOP voters aren’t zombies, but Trumpism isn’t dead.

Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, May 18

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

The COVID-19 ward at Providence Regional Medical Center Everett in May 2020. (Andy Bronson / Herald file) 20200519
Editorial: Even after 1 million deaths, covid fight isn’t over

Most of us have put away masks, but case counts are rising again and vigilance is still paramount.

Members of PRISM close out a dance off Friday afternoon at the Stanwood-Camano YMCA in Stanwood, Washington on March 3, 2022. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Editorial: Marysville board must keep focus on students’ needs

Discussion of LGBTQ clubs must tune out the culture war noise and focus on students and families.

Most Read