Richard Aboulafia, vice president of analysis for Fairfax, Virginia-based Teal Group, speaks Wednesday at South Seattle College in Seattle during a news conference to release a study conducted by his company and commissioned by the Gov. Jay Inslee’s Choose Washington New Middle-Market Airplane Council. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)

Richard Aboulafia, vice president of analysis for Fairfax, Virginia-based Teal Group, speaks Wednesday at South Seattle College in Seattle during a news conference to release a study conducted by his company and commissioned by the Gov. Jay Inslee’s Choose Washington New Middle-Market Airplane Council. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)

Report’s message to Boeing: Build the 797 here in Washington

Unsurprisingly, a new study says the state is the best in the U.S. for aerospace manufacturing.

SEATTLE — The numbers look good. Washington, by far, is the most competitive state in the U.S. for aerospace manufacturing.

That’s according to a new report released Wednesday at a gathering of state political, business and labor leaders, including Gov. Jay Inslee, at South Seattle College.

“Washington isn’t No. 1 in everything, but Washington was on top by a very healthy margin,” Richard Aboulafia, vice president of the Teal Group, told The Herald before the announcement.

But numbers can’t always tell the whole story. The report didn’t delve into murkier, less quantifiable, topics — for instance, political climate or labor issues.

“We’re not qualified to address those,” said Aboulafia, considered one of the world’s top aerospace industry experts. “It’s our job to provide the numerical analysis.”

Instead, the “Aerospace Competitiveness Economics Study” measured key factors such as electricity costs, the percentage of state residents with engineering degrees — “anything that could be quantified” — using public and government sources, said Aboulafia. He described the study as “objectively vigorous.” The state hired his Fairfax, Virginia, firm for $55,000 to produce the report.

The study found that — in order — Washington, Ohio, North Carolina, Kansas and Colorado offer “the most competitive environments for the manufacture of aerospace equipment.” And those other states were distant runners up. “This isn’t a close call,” Gov. Jay Inslee said at a news conference here Wednesday. “We win this going away.”

The report was commissioned by the governor’s Choose Washington New Middle-Market Airplane Council. It’s a coalition of local and state government officials, including Snohomish County Executive Dave Somers; labor unions; and business and education groups, including the Aerospace Futures Alliance. The council hopes to help convince the Chicago-based Boeing Co. that the best place to build its next passenger airplane model is in Washington.

Washington Gov. Jay Inslee (center) speaks Wednesday in front of an airplane engine at South Seattle College during a news conference to release a study commissioned by the governor’s Choose Washington New Middle-Market Airplane Council. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)

Washington Gov. Jay Inslee (center) speaks Wednesday in front of an airplane engine at South Seattle College during a news conference to release a study commissioned by the governor’s Choose Washington New Middle-Market Airplane Council. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)

Boeing’s so-called middle-market airplane, informally dubbed the 797, would fit somewhere between the largest 737 and the smallest 787, filling a niche left by the discontinuation of the Renton-built 757. The aerospace giant began discussing the plane openly last June at the Paris Air Show.

Washington’s strengths are many, the report says. “What makes it especially competitive is its advantages beyond aerospace experience,” including Washington’s low energy costs, high port shipping capacity, low insurance losses, high patents per capita, high private investments in research and development, the lack of a state individual income tax and low manufacturing taxes.

While the state is an obvious aerospace industry leader and has other general advantages, there is work to do. Aboulafia pointed to two areas in which the state could improve: education and infrastructure, especially roads. Both issues are easily addressed, he told those attending Wednesday’s news conference.

On another level, the report serves as a signal to Boeing. State and local leaders are ready to come to the table to build the sort of consensus that marked the state’s work to land the 737 Max project (Boeing at the time was not certain to build that new generation of the airplane in Renton) and avoid what Aboulafia called the “far more confrontational” debate over where the company would build the 777X. Boeing chose Everett after state lawmakers in 2013 approved a suite of tax incentives that were expected to save the aerospace giant more than $8 billion through 2040.

News conference replay

Still, it’s not clear what metrics Boeing will be weighing if it decides to produce the 797.

“They haven’t disclosed anything,” Aboulafia said.

For its part, Boeing says it is far from being ready to talk about how it might proceed with the 797. When asked Wednesday, the company provided a written statement:

“Boeing recognizes Washington’s efforts to quantify the significant impact the aerospace industry has on the state’s economy. However, it’s premature to provide comment at this time as we have not begun the formal process of site selection for the New Mid-Market Airplane. We will do so in due course but until then we continue to work to close our business case. Our business case efforts do not represent a program launch nor do they indicate when we will decide on next steps.”

Asked about offering additional incentives to Boeing to convince it to produce the new airplane in Washington, Inslee replied: “We are providing the best place to build an airplane in the world today — and that’s a pretty good incentive.”

The state’s favorable aerospace tax structure, supply chain and workforce are “a great incentive package,” the governor said.

The state is not approaching this as a “supplicant,” Inslee said, but with confidence in what the Washington offers.

Jon Holden, president of International Association of Machinists and Aerospace Workers District 751, said one of the study’s most innovative features was its ranking of labor costs.

“The Teal Report looks not just at the basic cost of the labor, but they also looked at the output of that labor,” Holden said. “What they found is that Machinists and engineers here in Washington are more efficient and productive. We produce more aerospace output per dollar cost of labor than almost anywhere else.”

The study found that “every $1 paid to workers in Washington’s aerospace industry generates $11 in revenue, translating into the fourth-lowest unit labor costs in the nation.”

“The report shows where we can make improvements,” said Brian Bonlender, director of the state Department of Commerce. “We’ll be taking a hard look at what we and our partners can do to improve our competitiveness.”

Produced by the Teal Group and research firm Olympic Analytics, the report was paid for by the Machinists and another union, the Society of Professional Engineering Employees in Aerospace.

Janice Podsada: 425-339-3097; jpodsada@heraldnet.com.

Highlights

Washington is the second-most competitive state in the nation for labor, material, energy and construction costs.

The state ranks second in a report category called labor and education, which measures the availability of aerospace workers, the population’s level of educational attainment and a state’s spending on K-12 education.

One of every 29 Washingtonians holds an engineering degree, the second-highest rate in the nation.

The state has more aerospace workers than California, which is five times Washington’s size, and twice as many as Texas, which has three times the population.

Washington had the third-fastest per-capita gross domestic product growth in the nation over the past five years.

The state has the third-highest number of patents per capita and the fifth-highest rate of research and development in the nation.

Washington has the fifth-lowest taxes in the nation as measured by the report’s taxes-and-incentives category.

Washington offers seven tax incentives to aerospace businesses, with the 330 users of those tax incentives reporting $327 million in annual savings.

Talk to us

More in Herald Business Journal

Commercial Aircraft Interiors General Manager James Barnett stands in a warehouse aisle of 777 overhead bins at the company's new building on Monday, May 20, 2019 in Arlington, Wash. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
12 Snohomish County aero firms get $19M for job protection

The Aviation Manufacturing Jobs Protection grants could save 2,280 Washington jobs for up to six months.

FILE - The logo for Boeing appears on a screen above a trading post on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange, Tuesday, July 13, 2021. Despite the pandemic's damage to air travel, Boeing says it's optimistic about long-term demand for airplanes. Boeing said Tuesday, Sept. 14, 2021 that it expects the aerospace market to be worth $9 trillion over the next decade. That includes planes for airlines and military uses and other aerospace products and services. (AP Photo/Richard Drew, file)
Pandemic hasn’t dimmed Boeing’s rosy prediction for planes

The company is bullishly predicting a $9 trillion market over the next decade.

Washington August jobless rate was 5.1%; 16,800 jobs added

August’s rate was the same as July’s rate, and increased even as COVID-19 cases surge.

Boeing moving 150 jobs from Washington and California to Texas

The affected jobs are in the company’s global parts distribution unit.

School-age lead Emilee Swenson pulls kids around in a wagon at Tomorrow’s Hope child care center on Tuesday, Sept. 7, 2021 in Everett, Washington. A shortage of child care workers prompted HopeWorks, a nonprofit, to expand its job training programs. Typically, the programs help people with little or no work experience find a job. The new job training program is for people interested in becoming child care workers. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
HopeWorks to offer career training for child care workers

The Everett nonprofit hopes to train workers as child care centers struggle to hire staff.

Genna Martin / The Herald
David Barney, owner of Barney's Pastrami on Evergreen, has changed the last names of the dozens of celebrities who's photos hang on the wall of his restaurant to Barney.  The newly named celebrities include Humphrey Barney, Uma Barney, Marilyn Barney, Olivia Newton-Barney and Stevie Ray Barney.  
Photo taken 11252014
Where’s Barney? His pastrami shop has served its last hoagie

Even the Evergreen Way deli’s landlord is looking for him. David Barney has vanished.

Tasty and healthy asian food - spicy ramen with wheat noodle, meat, eggs and onion in white pot with chopsticks. Vector illustration of traditional korean cuisine for menu, recipe books or printing
You voted: The best Vietnamese food in Snohomish County

Even during a pandemic, folks still have their favorites.

‘Fulfillment center’ proposed along Bothell Everett Highway

Amazon denies that it’s involved in the project. But permitting documents include the company name.

A drawing of the giant Funko Pop! balloon depicting Baby Yoda, which will wind through the streets of New York during this year’s Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade. (Funko) 20210912
It’s OK to Pop! this balloon: Funko to join the Macy’s parade

Funko’s incarnation of Baby Yoda will float by in this year’s Thanksgiving Day event.

The Home Depot in Lynnwood on Sept. 3, 2021. (Andrea Brown / The Herald)
Lawsuit: Home Depot doesn’t give workers enough breaks

The suit could cover at least 10,000 employees across the retailer’s 45 locations in Washington.

Its business as usual in spite of construction starting on the Harvey Airfield runway on Thursday, Sept. 9, 2021 in Snohomish, Washington.  Planes use the grass/dirt runway as the asphalt runway gets a new facelift. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
Harvey Field runway gets a makeover, the first in 40 years

Aviation-related federal revenue is covering the cost. The Snohomish airport has been family-owned since 1944.

Heather Van Slageren waits for a Community Transit bus to Stanwood at the Lynnwood Transit Center on September 8, 2021. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
As offices reopen, some former ‘super commuters’ aren’t happy

After a pandemic respite working at home, they dread resuming a one-way commute of 90 minutes or more.