Alyssa and Hart Bleifuss own and operate the newly opened Pie Dive Bar in Snohomish. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)

Alyssa and Hart Bleifuss own and operate the newly opened Pie Dive Bar in Snohomish. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)

Pie Dive Bar opens in Snohomish. Yep, it’s exactly how it sounds.

Open a dive bar, but make it a late night pie bakery.

SNOHOMISH — If you want a Manhattan and a slice of banana bourbon cream pie at 10 p.m. on a week night, then belly up to Pie Dive Bar in downtown Snohomish.

Cofounders Alyssa and Hart Kingsbery opened the Twin Peaks-themed dive bar in early May. It marries the woodsy, airy musings of a lodge with the unglamorous, eclectic and homey energy of a dive bar. Also, some light fixtures are made out of old mattress wires.

Pie Dive Bar is nestled inside a nearly 100-year-old building (past Time Out Tavern frequenters will know the bar well). It smells like wood chips and golden flaky pie crusts. When you walk in, there will be a gorgeous pie case straight ahead, a jukebox to your right and a bartender yelling out, “Welcome! Make yourself at home.”

Take a whiff of the newly-installed cedar bar top when you sit down for one of Hart’s cocktails. You won’t look weird, I promise. And if you do look weird, who cares?

“There are a lot of ways to make an Old Fashioned,” Hart said, handing me a glass of bourbon, bitters and oil-expressed orange peel. “This is the best way.”

If you don’t want booze, non-alcoholic drinks are adorably priced at $3.14.

Foodwise, you’ll be greeted by a simple menu that gives you permission to have pie for both dinner and dessert.

Alyssa’s best-selling Thanksgiving provides a mouthful of turkey and all the fixin’s – rosemary potatoes, onions, celery, gravy, stuffing – without any politically hellbent, passive-aggressive family members. Instead, your companions here are good music, Hart’s painting of Agent Dale Cooper and the taxidermied goose that head baker Julie Baltzell shot a few years ago. His name is Honker.

The newly opened Pie Dive Bar in Snohomish. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)

The newly opened Pie Dive Bar in Snohomish. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)

Other savory flavors include chicken (or lamb) curry, enchilada, steak, shepherd’s or classic chicken pot pie. They each come with an arugula beet salad (I’m embarrassed to admit I don’t like beets, but I’m proud to say this salad made me a beatific convert).

For dessert, stay with the Twin Peaks theme and order a slice of sour cherry pie, or keep it Thanksgiving via chocolate bourbon pecan.

I tried Alyssa’s award-winning Humble Crumble pie (which she once made for Cake Boss star Buddy Valastro on Food Network’s “Bake You Rich”).

I’m still thinking about that slice, with its chunks of beautifully firm Granny Smith apples and a stream of marionberries, strawberries and raspberries. Your salivary glands will certainly be activated, but the pie’s tartness is balanced by a Rainier-sized mound of streusel. Add a dollop of whipped cream or ice cream for no extra charge.

You won’t find (or taste) tapioca, corn starch or other unnecessary ingredients in the sweet pies. Just fruit and some sugar, as it should be.

You also won’t find butter in the crust. I was initially surprised to learn this until Alyssa told me that leaf lard (meaning pig fat, so vegetarians: Be warned) makes for a far superior crumb. One bite of the tender, flaky and oh so sturdy crust, and I became a lard believer.

I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention the quiche-forward weekend brunch menu: Go meaty with the bacon and gruyere quiche Lorraine or the chilaquiles quiche (chilaquiche?). The veggie quiche has red peppers, kale, tomatoes and feta. They also serve biscuits (homemade, of course) and gravy. Finish it off with a slice of blueberry crumble.

Alyssa and Hart met during the pandemic. As their website sums up: “Hart tried Alyssa’s pie. Alyssa heard Hart sing. The rest was history.” They married last year and now have a baby on the way.

The couple had spotted a “for lease” sign while walking down First Street and immediately knew this was their next business venture. They completely renovated the space while paying homage to their favorite things: the Seattle music scene (Hart is a country rock musician), homemade pies, neurodiversity, craft cocktails, Twin Peaks and of course: dive bars.

Pot pies and sweet pies await customers at the newly opened Pie Dive Bar in Snohomish. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)

Pot pies and sweet pies await customers at the newly opened Pie Dive Bar in Snohomish. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)

The Kingsbery business is situated next to Snohomish Pie Co., but Alyssa isn’t worried about competition. In fact, because their hours of operation mostly differ, customers get up to 14 hours of delicious pie accessibility between the two businesses. Snohomish Pie Co. is also where Alyssa first learned how to bake pies at 15, under the watchful mentorship of founder Pamela Mack.

Pie Dive Bar isn’t Alyssa’s first pie-studded rodeo: She’s opened and sold Seattle Pie Company, The Pie Lady and Pie Wine Bar, to name a few.

“This is my mastery of all the pie bars I’ve built,” she said. “It’s a place for everybody. Blue collared guys, people on a date. It’s a melting pot.”

You could say Pie Dive Bar is a full-circle moment for Alyssa.

A pie-shaped, marionberry-stuffed full circle moment.

Prices: Pot pies are $13 a slice or $42 for a whole unbaked pie, and sweet pies are $9 a slice or $38 for a whole pie.

Pie Dive Bar

921 First St., Snohomish


Hours: 3 p.m. to 11 p.m. Tuesday to Thursday; 3 p.m. to midnight on Friday; 12 p.m. to 12 a.m. on Saturday, 12 p.m. to 9 p.m. on Sunday; closed Monday

Talk to us

More in Food & Drink

Stop by Nutty's Junkyard, located right off the Centennial Trail in Arlington, for juicy burgers and the crispiest onion rings that food reporter Taylor Goebel has ever tried. Photo taken Thursday, June 23, 2022. (Taylor Goebel / The Herald).
Beer, doughnuts, burgers and more: Take a bite out of Centennial Trail

Bike hard and eat hard with these delicious food and drink stops along the 30-mile Centennial Trail.

Cutline: Former Fuller’s Brewery head brewer John Keeling will be speaking at Foggy Noggin Brewing in Bothell on July 31.
Summer finally begins for craft beer aficionados

Here’s the scoop on beer-related events in Everett, Marysville, Bothell and Snohomish.

Sweet Radish's strip combo comes with hand-breaded chicken strips, crispy waffle fries, a buttery bun, their namesake sauce, coleslaw and an additional dipping sauce (or three). Friday, June 17, 2022. (Taylor Goebel / The Herald)
Sweet Radish is Everett’s favorite new chicken shop

PSA: Eat a chicken sandwich from Sweet Radish (formerly 9 Delicacies) as soon as possible.

The Grape & Grain in Everett is now serving coffee drinks, alongside its local beer and wine offerings. (Photo courtesy of Grape & Grain)
El Mariachi to open storefront, Sol Food closes, Scuttlebutt adds deli menu

In this week’s Nuggets, we say goodbye to Sol Food and hello to a new Lynnwood brewery.

Contestant chef Brian Madayag (left) of Edmonds and West Coast team captain Brooke Williamson on “Beachside Brawl.” (Food Network) 20220616
Edmonds chef reps Pacific Northwest on new Food Network show

Barkada owner Brian Madayaga will compete on a new Food Network series that premiers Sunday.

Lemongrass chicken skewers are best made on a grill, but can be made in the oven. (Photo by Tressa Dale/Peninsula Clarion
Lemon grass chicken skewers top off a day in the Hawaiian surf

The comforting dish pared well with sore muscles. It turns out surfing is very hard, and not for everyone.

Food forum
Cool down with these summertime drink recipes

Refresh yourself with two light, refreshing drink recipes.

Teresa Godfrey and Sandra Reichstetter work side by side at their new restaurant Thursday, June 9, 2022, at Cup & Crepe on Everett Mall Way in Everett, Washington. The two have been together for over 20 years. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
New Everett biz serves up vegan and gluten-free street crêpes

From strawberry cheesecake to pizza, Cup & Crêpe has a fun take on European street-style crepes.

Food forum
The Food Forum: A southwest salad recipe fit for a crowd

Have people coming over? This tasty salad goes together in no time flat.

Hops & Seed head brewer Dru Seed (left) and owner John Bigelow share a pint at the Hops Seed taproom. (Caleb Smith)
Catch Snohomish brewery Hops & Seed at state Brewers Festival

After a two-year hiatus, the festival returns this weekend, with several Snohomish County breweries participating.

Food forum
For a quick breakfast, try this simple granola recipe

Make this granola recipe your own with your choice of dried fruits, nuts and more.

The lumpia sub at Lasa Sandwiches & Pearls is stuffed with hearty meatballs doused in sweet chili sauce, crunchy shards of egg roll wrappers, then topped with cilantro and pickled papaya, pepper and carrot. Wednesday, June 2, 2022. (Taylor Goebel / The Herald).
6 quick global bites at south Snohomish County restaurants

These eateries serve up big flavors and diverse fare in a short amount of time.