Crews walk the autoclave at the new 777x Composite Wing Center at Paine Field in Everett on May 19, 2016. (Kevin Clark / Herald file)

Crews walk the autoclave at the new 777x Composite Wing Center at Paine Field in Everett on May 19, 2016. (Kevin Clark / Herald file)

If aerospace jobs decline, should tax breaks be affected?

Five years ago a citizens commission asked lawmakers for guidance. It did again on Wednesday.

OLYMPIA — Five years ago, a citizens commission asked state lawmakers to decide whether tax breaks received by the Boeing Co. and other aerospace firms should be tied to the number of jobs provided, or not.

On Wednesday, the same panel asked again.

The five-member Citizens Commission for the Performance Measurement of Tax Preferences unanimously agreed tax preferences enacted in 2003 and extended in 2013 are providing good-paying jobs, lowering costs for business, and preserving the industry as a whole as lawmakers intended.

But commissioners were unable to assess if that suite of tax breaks is achieving a fourth goal, to “maintain and grow” the aerospace workforce. Employment in the industry is higher now than in 2003, but lower than in 2013. Absent a clear link between the tax breaks and job creation, they asked lawmakers — as they did in 2014 — for clarity.

“The tax preference continues to meet the majority of stated objectives,” commissioners concluded in a recommendation that will be sent to lawmakers. “However, the employment objectives are ambiguous. The commission recommends the Legislature clarify its position on employment levels.”

Initially the recommendation suggested lawmakers either set a baseline against which future employment levels could be compared, or come right out and say they don’t intend to do so. Following a short discussion, commissioners axed the language because they didn’t want to appear to be trying to box lawmakers into a corner.

“Just like five years ago, we’re still in the situation that when it comes to the employment objective we still do not have enough guidance on how to look at that issue,” commission chairman Grant Forsyth of Spokane said after the meeting.

The recommendation will be considered Dec. 4 by the Joint Legislative Audit Review Committee, a bipartisan and bicameral legislative panel.

Tying the number of aerospace jobs with the receipt of tax breaks is not a new conversation.

State lawmakers and then-Gov. Gary Locke enacted incentives for the aerospace industry in 2003 to land the 787 Dreamliner assembly line for Washington. Those tax preferences were to expire in 2024.

During a November 2013 special session, legislators and Gov. Jay Inslee agreed to a 16-year extension, to 2040, to help convince Boeing to build the 777X in the state. It is projected the extension will save aerospace firms close to $8.7 billion in tax payments, nearly all of it accruing to Boeing.

Boeing did choose to build its new plane in Everett. But it also shed thousands of jobs in the months following the 2013 special session, prompting the commission’s calls for clarity.

Legislation introduced in 2015 and 2016 would have tied Boeing’s continued receipt of tax breaks to its employment levels. But those bills did not receive a vote.

The commission last reviewed the aerospace tax preferences five years ago. A report prepared by the state’s legislative auditor this year described a stronger and more stable aerospace industry. But it again concluded that without more data it could not be determined if the tax preferences encouraged hiring or prevented greater losses of jobs.

At a September hearing on the report’s findings, commissioners were urged to ask lawmakers to set goals for job creation and enact changes allowing portions of tax breaks to be “clawed back” by the state when those goals are not met. Business leaders insisted that it was unnecessary.

“By any objective measure, Washington’s aerospace tax incentives are working as intended,” Boeing spokesperson Paul Bergman said following the meeting.

As the auditor’s report pointed out, aerospace employment is up 38% since the incentives were enacted in 2003, he said.

“These are good jobs with average wages over $100,000 and benefits that exceed those provided by other industries,” he said.

On Wednesday, commissioners made a point in their recommendation of not wanting to make too big a deal about employment levels.

”Regardless of how the Legislature clarifies this issue, the Legislature must be very cautious in how it interprets and responds to employment changes as a factor in the preference’s efficacy,” they said.

“The industry, like manufacturing in general, are rapid adopters of new technology that enhances productivity. This has the potential to significantly lower the labor input over time. Also, business cycle events, which are outside the industry’s control, may lead to significant declines in employment that can persist for several years,” they said. “Given the above, employment changes by themselves are insufficient for evaluating the preference’s efficacy.”

Commissioners acknowledged afterward that the grounding of Boeing’s 737Max, and other current events, weighed on their minds as they contemplated the right tone to take in the recommendation.

“I believe the lawmakers understand that this issue is flagged. It is hard to measure without knowing their intent,” said Commissioner Andi Nofziger-Meadows of Edmonds. “But (employment level) is such a complex factor that it cannot be the only measurement. It has to be one of many.”

Jerry Cornfield: 360-352-8623; jcornfield@herald net.com. Twitter: @dospueblos

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

The Victorian home sits on Whidbey Island. (Alyse Young for The Washington Post)
Whidbey couple thought they found their dream home — then came the bats

The couple had no recourse after unknowingly buying a home infested with thousands of bats.

The Snohomish County Jail is pictured on Thursday, Oct. 26, 2023, in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Report reveals cause of Everett man’s death in Snohomish County Jail

Terry Crusha was booked into the jail on May 17. He died three days later, part of a string of deaths there.

Boeing workers file into Angel of the Winds Arena to vote on the latest contract proposal from the company on Monday, Nov. 4, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Boeing Machinists prepare to go back to work after strike ends

After voting no twice, 59% of union members approved the latest contract.

Twede’s Cafe is pictured at the corner of Bendigo Boulevard and North Bend Way on Sunday, June 9, 2024, in North Bend, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Relive ‘Twin Peaks’ with cherry pie and damn fine coffee at Twede’s Cafe

The North Bend cafe, known as Double R Diner on the campy cult-classic, serves up nostalgia and a damn good breakfast.

From left to right, Lt. Cmdr. Lyndsay Evans and Lt. Serena Wileman. (Photos provided by the U.S. Navy)
Remains of Whidbey Island pilots to return this week

Lt. Cmdr Lyndsay Evans and Lt. Serena Wileman died in a crash on Oct. 15.

Everett
Everett men arrested in huge bust of Seattle drug ring

On Wednesday, investigators searched 31 locations, but suspects from Lynnwood and Edmonds remained at large, officials said.

“I Voted” stickers cover a table at the entrance to the Snohomish County Auditor’s Office on Tuesday, Nov. 5, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Margin narrows between Muzzall and St. Clair in WA Senate race

Meanwhile, a Lake Stevens school bond remained short of the 60% threshold in Wednesday’s results.

From left to right, Dave Larson and Sal Mungia.
WA Supreme Court race is incredibly close

Just 0.05% separated Sal Mungia and Dave Larson on Tuesday. More votes will come Wednesday.

Snow is visible along the top of Mount Pilchuck from bank of the Snohomish River near Rotary Park on Wednesday, May 10, 2023 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Everett initiative asks: Should the Snohomish River have legal rights?

Initiative 24-03 proposes legal standing to prevent environmental damage. Opponents say it’ll lead to unnecessary lawsuits.

Nora Xue, 24, fills out her ballot at the Snohomish County Auditor’s Office on Tuesday in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
5 big takeaways from election night in Snohomish County

The most expensive legislative contest was close. School funding plans were failing. And incumbents were largely cruising.

Carli Brockman lets her daughter Carli, 2, help push her ballot into the ballot drop box on the Snohomish County Campus on Tuesday, Nov. 5, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Washington’s capital gains tax survives repeal effort

Voters were opposing Initiative 2109 by 63.2% to 36.8%, as of Tuesday.

x
Edmonds woman, 82, accused of hate crime, disrupting Trump rally

The incident reportedly came Monday, the day before Donald Trump would again become president-elect.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.