Jury awards $1 million to former Edmonds HR director

SEATTLE — A federal jury awarded Edmonds’ former human resources director $1 million in damages Friday, finding that she was fired wrongfully and defamed by the mayor at the time.

Debi Humann had worked for the city more than a dozen years before being forced out in the fall of 2011. Her lawsuit named former Mayor Mike Cooper as a defendant, in addition to the city.

“I got fired illegally for doing my job,” Humann said Saturday.

Humann maintained that Cooper sent her packing just days after she told him she was cooperating with a state audit of his executive assistant’s timesheeets. She and other city employees doubted that Kimberly Cole actually worked the number of hours reported. Cooper had signed off on the time sheets.

After Humann’s termination, Cooper made statements to the news media about how his trust in her had deteriorated. One read, in part, that he “no longer had confidence in her ability to do the job and work effectively with me.”

Humann soon filed a whistleblower complaint challenging her termination and seeking her job back.

Cooper was campaigning at the time to keep the mayor’s job, but lost in a blowout that November. Dave Earling, the current mayor, took nearly 65 percent of the vote.

Cooper, a former Democratic County Councilman and state House member, had been appointed mayor of Edmonds in 2010. He’s now the director of the Mountlake Terrace Senior Center.

Reached Sunday, Cooper said he wasn’t ready to comment on the case.

Almost immediately upon taking office, Earling fired Cole from her $79,000-per-year job. The new mayor also hired Humann back, but she was laid off two weeks later because the City Council had cut the HR director’s job from the budget.

Cole’s work troubles weren’t limited to Edmonds. She was kicked off the Lynnwood City Council in 2012 for attendance problems. Questions about poor attendance also had dogged her at the County Council where she worked as Cooper’s legislative aide before going to work for him in Edmonds.

Cole now lives in New Jersey and appeared at the trial remotely by video, according to coverage on the My Edmonds News website.

Humann filed her federal lawsuit in January 2013. The trial took place in downtown Seattle and stretched over three weeks. Witnesses included a who’s who of Edmonds politics, including Earling, former Mayor Gary Haakenson, council members and top-level city employees.

A judge threw out two of Humann’s claims, but kept four others.

The jury began deliberations Friday morning and delivered their verdict that afternoon. Damages of $1,035,351 were for a combination of back pay, future economic damages, impairment to her reputation and emotional distress from defamation.

Earling said the city was “disappointed in the outcome.”

“It’s simply time to put this issue behind us and get back to running the city,” he said.

Jayne Freeman, a defense attorney for the city, said they had yet to decide whether to appeal.

While they didn’t win the case, Freeman said they did convince the judge to throw out claims alleging violations of due process and Humann’s civil rights. Nevertheless, those claims ended up prolonging the trial, she said.

“This case has always really been an unemployment case,” Freeman said. “It always was and should have been about her (Humann’s) termination.”

Humann was represented by Seattle attorneys Beth Barrett Bloom and Jillian M. Cutler.

“Debi Humann is exactly the kind of government employee we want guarding our taxpayer dollars,” Bloom said in a statement. “She did the right thing at great personal cost.”

Humann, on Saturday, said she felt relieved. She hoped the verdict would reassure other city employees.

“I had heard from a number of people after I was fired that nobody was going to step up if they had to report something for fear they would be fired,” she said.

Humann grew up in Edmonds and still lives there. As a human resources director named Humann, she was once featured in a Daily Herald series about aptonyms, or names that aptly suit their owners.

Until her ouster, she said, the working atmosphere at the city, mostly under former mayor Haakenson, had been one of respect between management and staff.

“The employees were valuable, the city listened to them and we reacted appropriately,” she said. “That was the culture.”

She said hopes that culture has been restored.

Noah Haglund: 425-339-3465; nhaglund@heraldnet.com.

Talk to us

More in Local News

Zachary Robbins
Marysville superintendent could start a month early

A June start means Zachary Robbins could weigh in on a $13.5 million budget shortfall and a parental consent policy for clubs.

Driver dies after rollover crash at Smokey Point

The deceased man, 25, reportedly sped off from police before crashing into a nearby utility pole. A woman, 19, was injured.

Epic Ford on the corner of 52nd Street and Evergreen Way in Everett is closed. The dealership has been in business for more than 50 years. (Janice Podsada / The Herald)
After 50 years, Everett’s Epic Ford dealership closes shop

It opened in 1971, when gas guzzling muscle cars like the Ford Mustang still ruled the road.

Nuno Taborda
Former Rolls Royce executive to lead Everett aerospace firm

magniX, which builds electric aircraft motors, has hired Nuno Taborda as its next CEO.

Smokey Point Boulevard stretch closed for crash investigation

The road was closed between 136th Street NE and 152nd Street NE after a possibly fatal collision.

The Mountain Loop Highway between Darrington and Granite Falls remains closed beyond Barlow Pass. (Snohomish County)
Oops, Mountain Loop Highway only partly open

A miscommunication led Snohomish County to misstate how much of the road is open.

Monroe High School with (inset) a Facebook video screenshot from Nov. 10, 2021, which showed a white student repeatedly using racial slurs in a confrontation with a Black student.
‘It makes me angry’: Black students in Monroe report persistent racism

“Please help stop this racism,” a first-grade student told the Monroe school board Monday. Other kids reported racist slurs.

Destiny Conner, 13, takes tags off of clothing at the new Volunteers for America storefront on Monday, May 16, 2022 in Sultan, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
At Sultan’s only thrift store, teens learn teamwork, job skills

Teens with the Sky Valley Youth Coalition “stepped up and created the store” on Main Street.

Joshua Freed
Ex-Bothell mayor accused of misleading real estate investors

One Snohomish couple sued Joshua Freed after losing a $300,000 investment in a development project.

Most Read