Jury’s $40 million award stands in cooked-heart case

A California manufacturer of medical devices “chose to cross their fingers and roll the dice,” gambling with people’s lives, a Snohomish County Superior Court judge said Wednesday.

Judge Linda Krese said it amounted to “reckless disregard for the safety of others” when Edwards Lifesciences Inc. failed to warn users about dangers of a machine that malfunctioned and literally cooked a man’s live heart in 2004.

Krese let stand a March 10 jury verdict awarding $40.1 million, mostly to a Mount Vernon family. Paramjit Singh’s heart was burned so badly it would not function and he received a heart transplant.

The judge declined to reduce both compensatory and punitive damages to Singh, his wife and their three children. The jury also awarded Providence Everett Medical Center $310,000.

Krese also turned down an Edwards motion for a new trial.

The jury ruled that Edwards, of Irvine, Calif., bears almost all the blame for what happened to Singh, 54, because it didn’t tell doctors about flaws in the device that could cause overheating under certain circumstances.

The judge said the company also made a corporate decision not to recall the devices, thus risking people’s lives.

The award is believed to be the largest civil jury verdict ever in Snohomish County, and one of the largest in the state.

Singh went into Providence in October 2004 for relatively routine heart bypass surgery. A monitor made by Edwards malfunctioned, turned off fail-safe devices and caused a catheter inserted into Singh’s heart to reach temperatures up to 500 degrees.

The machine was supposed to monitor blood flow and other conditions.

After the surgery, doctors couldn’t restart Singh’s burned heart. Singh was kept alive with blood-pumping machines and received a heart transplant at University of Washington Medical Center 11 weeks later.

The jury heard testimony over five weeks and deliberated four days before announcing a decision. The testimony included information that Singh has already has had significant health problems stemming from the heart transplant and likely will have more.

During the trial, Edwards lawyers admitted responsibility for Singh’s injuries but maintained that Providence shared responsibility. The jury found that Providence was only 0.01 percent responsible.

Edwards is expected to appeal, lawyers said.

On Wednesday, Edwards lawyer Paul Esposito of Chicago argued that the judge should not have allowed an instruction on the law that told jurors to disregard whether either Singh or Edwards had insurance. Esposito said that instruction drew attention to the possibility that an insurance carrier might pay, not Edwards.

“We’re paying more because of this instruction,” Esposito said.

He maintained that the dollar awards were excessive, and that it was wrong for the jury to conclude Edwards’ actions were “despicable,” which led to punitive damages of more than $8 million.

Singh lawyer Robert Gellatly of Seattle told the judge that the “jury verdict was well within the evidence” at trial. Singh “has endured horrendous injuries, horrendous damages.”

The machine should not have malfunctioned, and Edwards was gradually fixing the problem as machines came back for maintenance, said another Singh lawyer, Andrew Hoyal of Seattle.

“Edwards knew what the problem was. They knew what could happen,” Hoyal said. “This was worse than reckless behavior.”

Reporter Jim Haley: 425-339-3447 or jhaley@heraldnet.com.

Talk to us

More in Local News

Traffic will be rerouted from a closed section of 220th Street SW just west of I-5 for overnight road repairs Wednesday and Thursday. (Sound Transit)
Overnight work to close 220th Street SW and southbound I-5

Contractor crews plan to repair 220th and need to close the freeway for light rail work.

This condo on Norton Ave. in Everett was sold Friday, June 18. (Sue Misao / The Herald)
Snohomish County home values soar in latest assessment

Lack of affordable housing put the squeeze on buyers and drove up home prices across Snohomish County.

With credit scores out, will insurers cut or hike your rate?

Lack of affordable housing squeezed buyers and drove up home prices across Snohomish County.

Lynnwood man is challenging the legality of his imprisonment

The Island County Jail inmate was temporarily sent to a state prison and allegedly held in solitary confinement.

Chris Stack and Samantha Soule film a scene of their movie, "Midday Black, Midnight Blue," on the Coupeville wharf June 14. (Photo by Karina Andrew/Whidbey News-Times)
Indie film crew: Whidbey residents are ‘generous and welcoming’

The movie makers are shooting scenes for a full-length feature at various sites around the island.

Harry Lee Jones Jr.
Man gets 31½ years for shooting Everett motel guest 12 times

Harry Lee Jones Jr., 27, beat and then shot a Farwest Motel guest in 2018 while two accomplices looted his room.

Everett's Patrick Hall was among people who put up signs in March to save the Longfellow School building.  He is now part of an advisory task force looking at options for the building, which the Everett School District had planned to tear down.  (Dan Bates / The Herald)
National register listing could be next for old Longfellow

But the designation wouldn’t stop the Everett School District from tearing down the former school.

Cars make their way across US 2 between Lake Stevens and Everett as wildfire smoke makes downtown Everett barely visible on Friday, Sept. 11, 2020. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Wildfire smoke: A burning health issue is getting worse

As the hazardous haze increases during fire seasons, it’s time to get serious and prepare, experts say.

Photo courtesy Laura Thompson 

Madison Thompson and her dog Stella.
Whidbey teen, golden retriever make top 8 in NY kennel show

Madison Thompson was one of the youngest competitors in her division of 80 kids.

Most Read