In this April 9, 2019 photo, state representatives listen to speakers on the House floor at the Capitol in Olympia. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File)

In this April 9, 2019 photo, state representatives listen to speakers on the House floor at the Capitol in Olympia. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File)

Legislature sees records requests spike since court ruling

House and Senate administrators in Washington are working through how to deal with the influx.

By Rachel La Corte / Associated Press

OLYMPIA — After several years of not releasing the work records of lawmakers, House and Senate administrators in Washington are working through how to deal with the influx of requests they’re receiving now that the state Supreme Court has ruled legislators are fully subject to the same disclosure laws as other elected officials.

Lawmaker public record requests were fulfilled as recently as 2010, but over the years administrators started citing various changes made to statutes in previous years, which they said exempted lawmakers, even though the measures did not say that. The state Supreme Court disagreed with lawmakers’ assertion in a December ruling.

While seven of the nine justices agreed the offices of individual lawmakers are subject to the Public Records Act, six of them ruled that the Legislature is only subject to a more-limited scope of records available through the House clerk and the secretary of the Senate.

While media and open government advocates hailed the resumption of the release of lawmaker records, there was concern the limited scope allotted to records held by the House clerk and secretary of the Senate could allow for some records to still be withheld. That issue came up in the state Supreme Court ruling, with the lead opinion stating that “the specter of a ‘black hole’ of legislative public records is overblown.”

“The standard governing whether an entity must disclose a public record is whether the record requested is ‘prepared, owned, used, or retained’ by that entity, not simply whether that entity possesses the record at the time of the request,” Justice Susan Owens wrote.

But in a separate opinion in that ruling, Justice Debra Stephens warned of the potential that sexual harassment and misconduct reports could be “consumed by the very ‘black hole’ the PRA meant to avoid.”

“The lead opinion says ‘the specter of a “black hole” of legislative public records is overblown’ … yet it looms large,” she wrote.

While the Senate already had a practice of publicly releasing entire reports on investigations of senators for workplace misconduct or sexual harassment before the ruling, the House does not, choosing in the past to instead just release a summary of a report or nothing at all.

Last month the House did release the entire report into Republican Rep. Matt Shea, who is accused of participating in and planning domestic terrorism against the United States with involvement in three standoffs against the government. But a recent Associated Press request for investigative reports into two former Democratic House members was initially rejected on Friday, with the House citing the fact the reports were held by the clerk. The AP appealed the rejection, and on Saturday the House said the original rejection was sent in error and the request was undergoing a review by the chief clerk.

Chief Clerk of the House Bernard Dean said Monday the House’s policy on releasing full reports is still to be determined, and that any change would need come from the Executive Rules Committee, which is made up of three Democratic leaders — including new Speaker of the House Laurie Jinkins — and two Republican leaders.

“We want to be in compliance with the law,” Dean said. “Part of the struggle we have is understanding how the ruling applies in this environment.”

The 60-day legislative session began Jan. 13, and House and Senate administrators have seen a sharp uptick in the number of public records requests. In the month since the ruling, the Senate has received at least 35 requests, compared to the 20 they fielded in all of 2019. In the House, there were 43 requests in December, compared to nine in the previous December. And they’ve already received 40 requests thus far this month.

Secretary of the Senate Brad Hendrickson said the Senate is currently in the process of hiring a second public records officer and is working with the attorney general’s office and Senate attorneys to implement a records retention policy in conjunction with the House. Dean said the House is potentially looking to hire a third public records officer.

Dean said that several lawmakers have started using legislative cellphones instead of their personal cellphones for work — for public records reasons. Many lawmakers in both chambers have started going paperless, asking lobbyists to send them digital copies of documents they previously printed out in order to make it easier to retain documents under the law.

“It centralizes the record keeping,” Hendrickson said.

Later this week, lawmakers in both the House and Senate will have mandatory training with attorney general staff about the Public Records Act.

Talk to us

More in Northwest

Man who runs Everett business charged in U.S. Capitol case

Joseph Elliott Zlab, 51, of Lake Forest Park, was arrested in Everett on Thursday, the FBI said.

Students lead charge as Langley council takes climate action

The Whidbey Island city has declared a climate emergency and has pledged to involve United Student Leaders.

Since Washington state passed Initiative 502 to legalize recreational marijuana, rates of drivers under the influence of cannabis and involved in fatal collisions have risen at an alarming rate. (
Numbers of stoned drivers increase, law enforcement responds

One WSP trooper said a THC breathalyzer would be a “game changer” for police and the courts.

The Cold Springs Fire in Omak. (Okanogan County Fire District 6)
Officials hope to douse Western blazes fast, avoid megafires

2020 was one of worst years on record, with 10 million acres scorched and 18,000 structures destroyed.

Vancouver principal resigns amid racist language accusations

An investigation found favoritism among school staff and the use of racist language.

Washington schools to open full time in fall, masks required

Officials are recommending COVID-19 vaccinations but are not requiring them for in-person instruction.

New state law makes drug possession a misdemeanor

Gov Jay Inslee says the measure will “help reduce the disparate impact of the previous drug possession statute on people of color.”

A ferry was in Everett for repair in November 2020. (Sue Misao / Herald file)
Ferry fire will cause Puget Sound summer travel delays

A reduced number of boats, crew shortages and quarantines related to COVID-19 will limit capacity.

Juneteenth to be a state holiday in Washington state in 2022

The day commemorates when the last enslaved African Americans learned they were free on June 19, 1865.

Most Read