Removing dams too drastic a measure to save salmon, orcas

For the record, I do love seeing orcas and other whales in the Puget Sound.

Seems there are still many groups who think the only way to save our resident orca population is to remove the four lower Snake River dams in Eastern Washington. They claim it must happen now to open up thousands of miles of tributaries for salmon spawning. There’s science behind it, I understand. They claim we must do everything we can to save salmon, which will help the orcas survive in Puget Sound. Even if given the green light tomorrow, it will take years to remove the dams.

But we’re not doing everything we can to help salmon in Puget Sound right now.

According to a 2015 estimate, seals ate 8.6 million chinook salmon in the Salish Sea, while our resident orcas only ate 83,200 chinook. Seems to me if we are really serious about saving salmon and orcas, we should be doing something to reduce the number of seals and sea lions in Puget Sound. A 2017 estimate puts the population of harbor seals at 51,000. I’m pretty sure there’s never been that many seals in the sound. The Marine Mammals Protection Act is outdated and needs to be changed. This applies to the whole West Coast. Salmon would benefit everywhere from San Francisco to British Columbia.

I’m not a fan of removing the dams on the Snake. I believe global warming is real. And I think it’s a bit crazy to contemplate removing these four dams which provide irrigation water to some of our best farmland, when we are seeing more and more severe draughts. We need to do everything we can to protect our domestic food supplies, and water supplies. Seattle residents may be drinking water from behind those dams 20 years from now. Who knows where global warming will take us.

My point is, do what we know we can do today to help save salmon and orcas. But do not take drastic measures like setting the wheels in motion to remove dams without a comprehensive plan that mitigates all the potential effects of global warming on us humans. Unless your goal is more orcas, and less humans around to bother them.

Curt Bry


Talk to us

More in Opinion

With long-term care insurance, It's important to look at how the benefits are structured. (Dreamstime/TNS)
Editorial: Fix WA Cares and let it resume its important work

The long-term care program needs modest changes to fairly provide a valuable benefit to seniors.

FILE - Elementary school teacher Carrie Landheer protests for stronger COVID-19 safety protocols outside Oakland Unified School District headquarters on Jan. 7, 2022, in Oakland, Calif. Officials across the U.S. are again weighing how and whether to impose mask mandates as COVID-19 infections soar and the American public grows weary of pandemic-related restrictions. Much of the debate centers around the nation’s schools, some of which closed due to infection-related staffing issues. (AP Photo/Noah Berger, File)
Editorial: Keep guard up against covid’s omicron variant

As much as half of the county could be infected by the variant; and hospitalizations are surging.

Gary Holt, who reads bills being considered in the Washington House, wears a mask as he sits behind a plexiglass shield with reflections of state representatives meeting remotely on it, Wednesday, April 21, 2021, at the Capitol in Olympia Wash. The House was considering a proposed new tax in Washington state on capital gains that would be imposed on the sale of stocks and bonds in excess of $250,000. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
Editorial: Add your voice to Legislature’s 60-day session

It’ll go quickly, but state lawmakers’ packed agenda includes transportation, policing and the budget.

Burke: Old time religion fine, but keep it, government apart

Were the U.S. a ‘Christian nation,’ would we all be comfortable with the changes to public life?

Voting rights bills needed to defend democracy

One year ago, we witnessed an attack on our country: an insurrection… Continue reading

Trump, others responsible for Jan. 6 should be prosecuted

What a sad morning to wake up on Jan. 6 and realize… Continue reading

Boeing, other companies still donating to ‘Sedition Caucus’

It’s been one year since the frightening and shameful Jan. 6 insurrection… Continue reading

Saunders: ‘Voting rights’ bills seek unwarranted regulation

State laws that the federal legislation seeks to change aren’t the barriers to voting Democrats claim.

Most Read