Judge Kirby

  • Kirby Arnold / Herald Writer
  • Saturday, September 27, 2003 9:00pm
  • Sports

It’s always wise to watch what we say, because words tend to rise again as reminders of how wrong we can be.

For example:

American League West prediction: Seattle Mariners, Oakland A’s, Anaheim Angels, Texas Rangers.” Kirby Arnold in The Herald, March, 2003.

Oops.

I really thought this was the year the Mariners would avoid being, well, the Mariners, and maintain their division lead to the finish. Collectively, the pitching staff was stronger, the bench was better and, maybe most important, no way would Mike Cameron and Jeff Cirillo duplicate the horrid seasons they had in 2002.

Oh my.

If it’s any consolation, the Mariners were talking with a fair amount of confidence themselves.

Remember?

This team has a history of getting out of the gate fast.” Manager Bob Melvin during spring training.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

If the 2003 season should bury anything, it’s the notion that those first 19 games in April against the AL West are vital to the success of the season.

The Mariners did jump out of the gate well – going 11-8 and taking a one-game lead over Oakland after the first run through the AL West. When they beat Atlanta two out of three in what seemed like a World Series preview, the Mariners were 23 games over .500 and eight games ahead of the A’s on June 13.

By June 24, the Mariners had their 50th victory in their 75th game.

Then they won only 40 of the next 84.

Both teams are good defensively, the starting pitching might be better this year, and the bullpen is basically the same.” Jeff Nelson in June, comparing the 2003 Mariners with the 2001 team that won 116 games.

When Nelson uttered those words, the Mariners had an eight-game division lead, they’d already won 50 games before the halfway point in the season and a lot of people were doing a lot of math.

Things change in baseball, as they say, and Nelson knew it. For a look at Nelson’s words of prophecy, see below.

I’ve had some coaches comment that the ball is jumping off my bat better.” Jeff Cirillo, enthusiastic during spring training at the improvement in his hitting.

Does anything better illustrate how misleading spring training can be? Cirillo’s .249 average last year seemed glorious compared with the .205 he’s at now.

Once we get Kaz back, we feel like we’ll be back at full strength and that we’ll have some options in all sorts of different roles.” Melvin, on the bullpen balance that fell apart after closer Kazuhiro Sasaki suffered broken ribs when he stumbled over his suitcase.

Sasaki never returned to the closer role and the bullpen turned into a mix-and-match effort that sometimes resulted in the equivalent of plaid pants with a striped shirt.

Shigetoshi Hasegawa became an excellent closer but his presence there robbed the bullpen of his invaluable work as a setup reliever against left-handed hitters.

Jeff Nelson was traded after criticizing management for not improving the team at the trade deadline and Arthur Rhodes struggled with a sprained ankle.

The once-automatic Shiggy-Rhodes-Nelson-Sasaki finish became a mish-mash of setup and closing that involved rookies Julio Mateo and Rafael Soriano, enigmatic Armando Benitez, struggling Rhodes and Hasegawa.

The fans come here to the greatest facility in baseball and support this team unbelievably. They deserve more than just, ‘OK, we stood pat again.’ Out of all the three sports here, the Mariners stand the greatest shot at getting a championship in this city. When you win 300 games in three years, you are that close. Maybe that extra player we could have gotten today could have gotten us there.” Relief pitcher Jeff Nelson on July 31 after another trade deadline passed without a significant move by the Mariners.

Six days later, Nelson was gone in a trade to the Yankees for Benitez.

Sometimes the words we speak are prophetic. Long before the trade deadline, there were hints that the Mariners wouldn’t make an impact deal; there was the thought that some players would falter again near the end of the season; and the feat that others would never solve the problems that afflicted them last year.

Remember?

We have to take a look and see what flexibility, if any, it leaves us in the future. It will affect what kind of flexibility we have.” Assistant general manager Lee Pelekoudas in February after an arbitrator awarded Freddy Garcia a $6.875 million salary for 2003, almost $1 million more than the Mariners had offered.

The Mariners have a contingency fund for such things, but the message that day was loud: The money that flowed into Garcia’s pocket would inhibit how much salary the team would add with in-season moves.

To twist a quote from Rocky Bridges 19 years ago when he managed the Everett Giants: “The only way the Mariners will turn loose of a nickel is to get a better grip on it.”

Whether the reasons were financial or otherwise, the Mariners didn’t address their needs – a power hitter for the offense and a left-handed pitcher for the bullpen – and they floundered the rest of the season.

I just hope we do something this time.” Nelson, two weeks before the trade deadline.

In essentially the verbal forerunner to the post-trade-deadline criticism of management that got him traded, Nelson stressed that a marquee acquisition can be important to a team’s psychological well-being.

We know how that turned out. Nelson is back in the playoffs; the Mariners aren’t.

I’m not a machine and it sometimes does happen. It’s very difficult to pinpoint what was the cause of that. I’m still learning from that.” Ichiro Suzuki at spring training after faltering at the finish of the 2002 season, when he batted .248 the final month.

Suzuki, apparently, is still learning. Entering Friday’s game, he had 31 hits in his previous 150 at-bats (a .207 average).

Last year I was so screwed up I didn’t have an idea up there. There were times of greatness, and there were times when I didn’t have a clue. There are a lot of goals I want to achieve, but the No. 1 goal is consistency. No. 2 is preparation. I want to prepare myself to be a better hitter.” Mike Cameron at spring training, vowing to change the problems that led to his league-high 176 strikeouts last year.

Cameron had cut his whiffs to 136 entering Friday, second-most in the league behind Jason Giambi’s 139. He also had just 12 hits in his previous 87 at-bats.

If you don’t go to your bench early, then you get forced to do it. If you don’t, then come playoff time your guys aren’t rested and you’re limping in. Hopefully we don’t get to that point.” John Mabry at spring training on the proper use of bench players.

Melvin never settled into a rotation that would give key players regular rest. It didn’t help that Mabry and Greg Colbrunn, two veterans who the team needed for their experience off the bench, suffered injuries.

As a result, the Mariners’ four main reserves – Mabry, Colbrunn, Willie Bloomquist and Mark McLemore – combined for fewer at-bats (659) than Ichiro Suzuki had (665) entering the final series.

Finally, there were words that Mariners fans didn’t want to hear.

I think this year most likely will be the last one. I’ll probably take a break and enjoy the things I haven’t been able to enjoy in the summertime for years. In some ways I’m looking forward to that.” Edgar Martinez at spring training as he prepared for his 21st professional season.

Martinez seemed less committed to that stance as the summer went on, saying he would play out the season and have a long talk with his family before deciding if he’ll play again.

JUDGE KIRBY

Remember when the last day of the Mariners’ season meant keeping one eye on the Seahawks’ score?

When the only intrigue was whether a minor league call-up would show any promise for next year? Or if the entire team could muster as much enthusiasm for the final Sunday of baseball as they would for the first Monday of golf?

Oh yeah. That’s how the Mariners finished last season, after two years of postseason baseball elevated everyone’s expectations, only to deflate them with a late nosedive out of first place.

Here we are again.

This was supposed to be the weekend that meant everything to the Mariners. Now it means nothing while they serve as scrimmage material for the Oakland A’s tuneup for the playoffs.

The season ended last week as far as the Mariners were concerned.

Today, they finish it with a different kind of drama. It’s personal now, especially for Edgar Martinez, Jamie Moyer, Mark McLemore, Mike Cameron and Pat Gillick.

  • This could be Martinez’s last day in a baseball uniform. He said at spring training that this probably is his final season, then softened during the summer by saying he will decide in the offseason.

    The man who began his pro career as an unheralded player with the Bellingham Mariners in 1983 could end it with a fitting finish this weekend. Martinez entered the final homestand needing two home runs for 300 in his career and 235 as a designated hitter, which would tie Harold Baines’ DH record. A solid finish could give Martinez a .300 or better batting average for the 11th season.

    He might not achieve those numbers, but Martinez’s final at-bat today will be a moment to treasure. It’s OK if you can’t watch it through dry eyes.

  • Moyer, today’s starting pitcher, can become the first 21-game winner in Mariners history and also will implant himself solidly into consideration for the American League Cy Young award as the league’s best pitcher.

    Roy Halladay of the Blue Jays has long been the favorite, but Moyer has essentially caught up with him. A victory today would give Moyer a 21-7 record. Halladay pitched Saturday trying to improve his record to 22-7. The earned-run averages are similar – Moyer 3.27, Halladay 3.22 – although Halladay has pitched 257 innings compared with Moyer’s 209.

    Halladay probably will win it, but somewhere there should be a soft spot for a 40-year-old, soft-tossing left-hander. Moyer deserves a healthy vote.

  • McLemore, 38, won’t draw the attention that Martinez will, but today could be his final game before retirement, too. He said at spring training that this could be the end of a pro career that began in 1982.

    “The two things are what my family and I decide at the end of this year and how my body feels,” McLemore said in March.

    While he avoided injuries that plagued him last year, McLemore showed the signs of an aging player. He didn’t run as well as he had in the past, his arm seemed to reflect the impact of elbow surgery last winter and his .233 batting average is his career-worst as a major leaguer.

    None of that should diminish what McLemore helped define in four years with the Mariners. As a veteran switch-hitter who played six positions, he became a 10th starter when former manager Lou Piniella rotated him into the lineup and gave other starters regular time off.

    McLemore was a leader on and off the field, and that was never represented better than the night the Mariners clinched the AL West title in 2001. Just nine days after the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks, he led a parade of Mariners around the diamond at Safeco Field, carrying an American flag in a tasteful celebration of the team’s accomplishment.

  • Cameron’s contract expires after this season and there’s no assurance he will return. After making about $8 million this season, Cameron obviously cost himself dearly with another difficult season offensively.

    The Mariners must decide if Cameron’s outstanding defense is worth the cost of his offensive shortfalls, not to mention the salary he may get.

    If this is Cameron’s final weekend as a Mariner, he could say good-bye with what he does better than anyone: a long run and a leap against the center field wall to rob someone of a home run.

  • Gillick’s contract runs out, too, and he has said he’ll decide within 10 days of the Mariners’ last game whether he wants to return or leave.

    He was criticized this year, not only for failing to make a trade-deadline deal to help a struggling team, but also for spending the last days before the deadline at his home in Toronto handling matters by telephone.

    Yes, Gillick was responsible for a team that squandered the division lead two years in a row because he did little to address its greatest weaknesses – more punch for a floundering offense and a second left-handed relief pitcher.

    But remember that he also helped build the clubs that went to the 2000 and 2001 playoffs, coming closer to the World Series than any Mariners team.

    Talk to us

    > Give us your news tips.

    > Send us a letter to the editor.

    > More Herald contact information.

  • More in Sports

    AquaSox infielder Luis Suisbel follows through on a two-run home run during Everett's 13-1 win against Tri-City at Funko Field in Everett, Washington on June 15, 2025. The Valencia, Venezuela native hit two of Everett's five homers on the afternoon. (Shari Sommerfeld / Everett AquaSox)
    AquaSox blow past Tri-City to close out homestand on Father’s Day

    Luis Suisbel hits two of Everett’s five homers, and Teddy McGraw stars in debut during 13-1 win.

    AquaSox shortstop Colt Emerson takes a swing during Everett's 3-2 win against the Tri-City Dust Devils at Funko Field in Everett, Washington on June 14, 2025. (Shari Sommerfeld / Everett AquaSox)
    Emerson walks off Tri-City to extend AquaSox win streak

    The Mariners’ top prospect hits an RBI-single to seal 3-2 win; Batista has 2 RBI in return.

    Everett AquaSox infielder Michael Arroyo receives high-fives in the dugout during Everett's 8-1 win against Tri-City at Funko Field in Everett, Washington on June 13, 2025. The 20-year-old Colombia native had two home runs and a career-high six RBI. (Shari Sommerfeld / Everett AquaSox)
    Arroyo’s big night lifts AquaSox to 8-1 win over Tri-City

    The 20-year-old smacks 2 homers and a career-high 6 RBI while extending hit streak to 10.

    Everett Silvertips defenseman Landon DuPont was named CHL Rookie of the Year at the 2025 CHL Awards in Toronto, Ontario. (Photo courtesy of Josh Kim / Canadian Hockey League)
    Tips’ Landon DuPont named CHL Rookie of the Year

    The 16-year-old is the first defenseman in 30 years, and first Silvertip ever, to win the award.

    Stanwood sophomore Addi Anderson in The Herald's 2025 All-Area Softball Pitcher of the Year. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
    The Herald’s 2025 Softball Pitcher of the Year: Addi Anderson

    The Stanwood sophomore had a 1.32 ERA to lead the Spartans to a district championship.

    Michael Arroyo hit a 2-run home run for the Everett AquaSox in an 11-4 loss to the Tri-City Dust Devils at Funko Field on Thursday, June 12, 2025. (Photo courtesy of Shari Sommerfeld / Everett AquaSox)
    AquaSox pitching goes cold in loss to Dust Devils

    Although they held a first-inning lead, the Everett AquaSox fell… Continue reading

    Jackson senior and UW commit Allie Thomsen is The Herald's 2025 All-Area Softball Hitter of the Year. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
    The Herald’s 2025 Softball Hitter of the Year: Allie Thomsen

    The Jackson senior had a .544 batting average and 1.600 OPS while striking out just once.

    Seahawks defense end Leonard Williams (99) participates in a workout at minicamp at the Virginia Mason Athletic Center on Wednesday, June 11, 2025. (Photo courtesy of Edwin Hooper / Seattle Seahawks)
    Seahawks bond over stories of their paths to football glory

    Leonard Williams’ path to the NFL included stints of homelessness.

    Edmonton Oilers center Leon Draisaitl (29) celebrates with teammates after scoring the game-winning goal in overtime against the Florida Panthers during Game 4 of the NHL Stanley Cup Final at Amerant Bank Arena on Thursday, June 12, 2025, in Sunrise, Fla. (David Santiago / Tribune News Services)
    Panthers blow lead, Oilers even Stanley Cup Final series

    The game probably shouldn’t have gotten to this point.… Continue reading

    Edmonds-Woodway senior Alex Plumis is The Herald’s 2025 Boys Soccer Offensive Player of the Year on Thursday, June 5, 2025 in Edmonds, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
    The Herald’s 2025 Boys Soccer Offensive Player of the Year: Alex Plumis

    The Edmonds-Woodway senior scored 23 goals and dished nine assists.

    Stanwood’s Rubi Lopez cheers after getting a base hit during the 3A District 1 championship game against Sedro-Woolley on Thursday, May 15, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
    Wesco all-league softball teams announced

    Wesco has announced its all-league teams for boys soccer. WESCO 4A First… Continue reading

    Taylor Dollard of the Everett AquaSox throws a pitch in a 5-2 victory over the Tri-City Dust Devils at Funko Field on Wednesday, June 12, 2025. (Photo courtesy of Shari Sommerfeld / Everett AquaSox)
    Strong pitching anchors AquaSox, sinks Tri-City

    Everett AquaSox pitching held Tri-City Dust Devils to just two… Continue reading

    Support local journalism

    If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.